Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Rotten question...

Posts

Rotten question...

#1

Rotten question...

Marv

Hi Folks,

I have an old wagon/buggy wheel that sat on the ground too long. Several years, actually. The wood that was subjected to the wet ground has rotted. Most of it is still intact but kind of punky. It has cracked and separated in two places. I have had it in the sun to dry for about a week. A small piece, about a 3/4 x 3/8" chunk has fallen off. The wood appears to be oak. One of the spokes is involved.

I want to repair the rotted area and paint over it. The wheel will be only for decoration.

Replacing the rotted wood with new wood is not an option that I'm comfortable with.

I'm thinking epoxy for the repair. Maybe JB Weld because of it's thick viscosity. I can apply it sorta like puddy.

Do I need to treat the wood with the stuff that stops the rotting process before doing the repair?

Any and all suggestions will be most appreciated.

Thank you,

Marv

Re: Rotten question...

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

A few options.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

JB Weld is kind of spendy for this type of repair, so I wouldn't go that route myself.

First, I'd use a chlorine bleach solution (3 parts water to 1 part household bleach) on the damaged area after you knock out any loose or punky wood, let it sit for about 15 minutes, then rinse it and let it dry in the sun. I would then use some wood hardener (as near as I can tell, it's just a very, very dilute form of drying oil). Either way, you basically need to apply a clear, penetrating, drying/curing finish that will stabilize the wood fibers.

Now your options expand a bit. Top 3 on my list would be (and not necessarily in this order, it depends on the size of the repair):

1. Durham's Rock-Hard Water Putty. It's a yellowish powder that you mix with water and pack into the hole. You may need to tack on some blocks covered with wax paper as forms if you have to build up a corner or 3-sided areas. You can vary how much water you add to it to affect the consistency. This stuff sets up pretty quickly, generally you have about 5-10 minutes of working time.

2. Epoxy putty. You can get tubes of this stuff, where the two parts are extruded together. Cut off the approximate amount you need, knead the putty until the two colors have mixed together uniformly, then force into the damaged area. There are different cure times available, as well as sizes. You can get a 6" x 3/4" tube for a couple bucks at an automotive store (or order it from Billy Mays' replacement, Anthony Sullivan--"Mighty Putty"), but I've even ordered a couple pounds of the stuff from an automotive store and got two separate chunks that together are about half the size of a standard red brick.

3. Bondo. I like the Bondo with fiberglass in it. Fairly easy to work with, sets hards, sands pretty well.

Of all the options, #2 is probably the worst. The reason I say that is because epoxy putty tends to be thick, so it wouldn't get down into all the nooks and crannies of the damaged wood. I would probably go with #1 just because you could apply a thinner coat (mixed thinly) so that it does get in all the nooks and crannies, then apply a thicker batch to fill the bulk of the missing volume.

Jason

Re: Rotten question...

#3

Re: Rotten question... *LINK*

Dave Paine

The WEST company makes a product for wood repair. Developed for boats. Not cheap, but it should work.

Meant to be absorbed into the pores of the remaining wood, which is important. If the material is on the surface or the wood one, like Durham's, there is potential for the fix to "pop" out over time.

I like Durham's. I prefer to use where I have a good clean surface. I used to fill in some knot holes in PT plywood for a garden cart. This is out in the elements and so far the Durham patches have not popped. May not be the same if the original surface is not sound - like your wheel.


http://www.westsystem.com/ss/

Re: Rotten question...

#4

Re: A few options.

Marv

Thanks Jason for the suggestions. I'll be trying your No.1. Sounds like the way to go.

Marv

Re: Rotten question...

#5

Re: Rotten question...

Marv

Thanks Dave for the link. I'll be checking it out.

I was over at the Turner's forum a bit ago and read about Turner's Choice, a wood treatment type stuff. A guy said it worked great on rotten wood and made it so he could turn it on a lathe. Have you guys heard of or used this this stuff?

Marv