We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
It's time to change the tires on my Delta Saw and I'm torn between rubber (shorter lived but apparently not as prone to grooves) vs. urethane (much less expensive and longer longer lasting.)
I'm looking for opinions and experience and I'm sure there's a bunch of it out there.
I think the answer is that it doesn't really matter very much, Doug, and in conversations with Mark Duginske and others over the years, he indicated that he feels the same way. I'm sure others may have different experiences, but I've never owned a saw with urethane tires and I only ever had to replace the rubber tires on a 50 year old Walker Turner saw I used to have. One variable I think you should control is the attachment of the tires to the wheels. Some people rely on a tight stretch fit and friction to hold the tire in place. I prefer something more positive and have used spray adhesive successfully. (Hold a folded newspaper behind the wheel as you simultaneously spin it by hand and spray it with a light coating of adhesive, then stretch the tire on.)
The crown of the wheel is another variable that you have limited control over. If your saw is a large one that you will use mainly for wider blades, the rim is probably flat and should have a flat tire. Many smaller saws have crowned rims that flat tires will conform to. The crown helps keep narrow blades (say, up to 3/8" or so) centered on the tire so they don't accidentally jump ship unexpectedly.
I had the same problem about 10 to 15 years ago. My 14" delta band saw tires were just beginning to dry rot a few years after I bought the machine used. I bought two Carter polyurethane tires from Woodcraft and a set of Cool Blocks. I also purchased the 6" riser from Delta, and a 1 hp, 1720 rpm Dayton motor. The tires are 7/8" in width and the wheels are 1" wide. Typical. I buy new tires and start with a problem, but everything else works great.
Now, the decision you have to make. The Carter poly tires are about 1/8" smaller than my wheels and the tires shift places from front to rear. I positively know that my wheels are parallel, or as Mark Duginske puts it, coplaner, because I adjust them every time I change a blade. I wanted to glue them in place with contact cement. Before I did, I called Carter and they said that my warranty may be void if I did.
Since then, I have not been able to use small blades, e.g., from 1/8" to 3/8". There is one good thing I can say about the poly tires, they wear very slowly. Mine are in great shape and since the warranty is up, I finally glued them in place. I now use small blades all the time, and rarely have problems. Every now and then the blade moves forward, towards me, but does not run itself the wheel. It's because I may tighten the blade a little when I'm using the saw, without adjusting the wheels parallel or coplaner.
In Mark Duginske's book, Band Saw Handbook, Illus, 235. pp. 113, "The a crown exerts a controlling force on the band, which helps track the blade near the center of the wheel." However, on the same page, Illus, 236., "Blades are usually tracked in the middle of the wheel. Some flat-wheel manufacturers recommend that you track wide blades with their teeth off the tire as shown in illustration B." I would think the reason for this is not to allow the teeth on the blade which may wear the tire down the quickly. Last on the same page, in Illus. 237, Duginske says, "Crowned wheels provide about 1/4" of contact between the blade and the tire. The lack of support for wide blades can lead to problems."
PriceCutters.com, mainly a router bit company, has USA brand polyurethane tires if your interested. Their tires for a 12" band saw, the width is 1". Same 1" width for a 14" band saw, and 1 1/2" width for an 18" band saw. I am going to buy the USA 1" tires from PriceCutters.com and hang on to them for when my polyurethane tires wear out. It may be a long wait. The Carter tires on my saw are going to last a long time.
The Band Saw Handbook copyright is from 1989. Mark Duginske has a new band saw book called, The New Complete Guide to the Band Saw. The copyright is from 2007. You might want to invest in this book for the new information needed to operate a complex tool, like the band saw. I'll be buy a copy.
Without a doubt, the band saw is probably the most complex tool in your shop. It is in mine and it pays good dividends in your work to keep it running as perfect as possible.