Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

What's bad about black walnut?

Posts

What's bad about black walnut?

#1

What's bad about black walnut?

David Frame Jr.

Good Afternoon Gentleman,

Earlier this morning, I had a conversation with Todd at Whiteside Machine Company. I own several of

their up and down spiral solid carbide router bits of different sizes. This is the first time I've had a 1/2"

down spiral bit burn the tip up in a matter of about one hr. More mortises need to be made in the 3 in 1

crib I'm building for my expectant grandson. So, I'm touching up the bit up with a diamond stone. If I

change the bit now, it will throw the mortise off. The plunge router is connected to a special base I made.

This is the first time a solid spiral carbide bit burned the tip on me. Believe me when I say, "I use these

bits all the time," Clean them when finished, dip them in 3 in 1 oil and put them back in their own

plastic cases.

Todd at Whiteside said that black walnut contains silica, which can burn the cutting edge off a bit in

minutes if to much of a bite is taken at a time. He also mentioned that breathing in silica it contains, is

bad news. My Jet DC-1200W-1 Limited Edition with a two way 4" port connected to the

squirrel cage, catches the major part of the wood chips, but not fine airborne dust.

Since working with wood for the past 37 years, I've recently developed an unmanageable cough when I

drink or eat, and my breathing is much more shallow. I don't smoke and have managed to contact

COPD (Chronic Obstuctive Pulmonary Disease) from the airborne dust with some of the woods I work.

My doctor confirmed this with an x-ray

a week ago.

The moral to this story is to wear, at the very minimum, a cheap dust mask or better yet, a good one.

Maybe, buy organic respirator, if you don't already have one for spraying finish. And last but not least,

build or buy a fine filtered dust collector. I own three squirrel cages. You would think I would have built

one by now.

Adios until next time,

David Frame Jr.

Re: What's bad about black walnut?

#2

NOT Silica

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

High silica woods grow in the tropics. Makes them quite hard [ex. Lignum Vitae].

Walnut's not in that class.

Walnut's draw back is the juglone protein which some are sensitive to or will, with exposure, become sensitive to causing allergic reactions.

I've machine lots of walnut with carbide saws and bits with no effect on the tooling.

Re: What's bad about black walnut?

#3

JL

Juglone is not a protein.

JL

It is a quinone (multiringed structure with various pendant groups).

It can be toxic. The various other compounds can gum up a router bit or saw blade - but they usually clean off reasonably well.

Re: What's bad about black walnut?

#4

Re: Juglone is not a protein.

David Frame Jr.

Hi Guys,

Thanks for setting me straight on the chemical contents of balck walnut. I suppose it's all those years of

not worring about the fine sawdust being inhaled from the exotics and plywood that I cut.

By the way, I can,t believe the price of dust masks these days. I spent 2 hours trying to decide which

type of mask to buy. I finally bought MSA safety Works #1005403 pack 20 of harmful dust respirators.

The price at Home Depot is $19.97 + tax. A buck for a good dust mask inn't bad.

Thanks your the time and info,

David

dframe01@hotmail.com