Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Local Store Loyalty

Posts

Local Store Loyalty

#1

Local Store Loyalty

Ed in Lawrence, KS

I'm getting ready to purchase some wood for a project. There is a locally owned yard near by that I have used in the past, but their prices are right now are significantly higher (+20%) than several other suppliers (the Orange Borg being one of them). My total purchase will be in the $3,000 range, so we're talking $600 here. I do get better service at the locally owned place, and the guys are more friendly, etc. But how much more would you pay to keep your business with a locally owned lumber yard?

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#2

Re: Local Store Loyalty

John Veerkamp

Ed, are you sure the quality is the same. The borgs buy lumber to meet a price point and the quality is usually seconds or worse. I'll bet that if you were comparing truly equal products, there would not be that significant of a difference. Of course if quality is not an issue, then my point is moot.

John

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#3

Re: Local Store Loyalty

Ed in Lawrence, KS

I guess I shouldn't have been so generic in the description of what I was buying. What I'm buying is Hardie lap siding. My locally-owned yard wants $7.50/piece and The Borg wants $6.25/piece. I have had the same issue with QSWO, though, and the quality was comparable so I ended up buying (not from the Borg) from from a regional supplier rather than the locally-owned yard. I guess I feel some loyalty towards the locally-owned yard but have a hard time donating $500-$600 to the cause.

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#4

Re: Local Store Loyalty

Barry Irby

I raised this question the other day. I really doubt that the Hardie company produces a lesser quality/cheaper siding for the Borgs, but I wonder. There are several brands of this stuff out there. Be sure you are comparing apples and apples.

I would go to the local yard and ask if they can meet the price. Maybe you can pick it up yourself or make some other small accommodation to help them. Come to think of it the local borgs don't deliver with out a significant charge.

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#5

Re: Local Store Loyalty

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Agree with Barry

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#6

Re: Local Store Loyalty

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

If it was me I would not pay a premium of 20% to buy from a local source. However as a couple of posters have said maybe there is something that can be done to lower the price difference. On a purchase of that size 5% would be my max difference that I would be willing to pay.

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#7

Re: Local Store Loyalty

Jesse Cloud

Depends on how important friendliness and service are to you. The yard I go to most of the time is positively surly and they act like you are intruding when you ask them to score the lumber and give you a price. However, they have way better quality than anyone else around and thats what matters to me.

If your trade is important to them, they will probably give a little on the price.

On the other hand, I wouldn't be one bit surprised if HD gets a different grade of siding than other places.

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#8

Have you asked them about it?

John in NM

There's one yard I really like down in Roswell, show up with a 3 ton flat bed to fill and they give you a builder's price regardless of whether you're a builder or not. I would bet your local yard has a commercial price for large orders, they probably couldn't stay in business otherwise. So basically, tell them the size of the order, the price difference, and how much you'd rather give them the business, you may like the result :D

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#9

Clint Searl

Re: Local Store Loyalty

Clint Searl

When I built my 30 x 40 shop, I ordered a load of 20ft 2x12 rafters from a local yard, at the end of winter. What they delivered was soaking wet, moldy, and starting to rot. They had to know how bad the wood was. I gave them the opportunity to replace the whole load with good stuff, which they did. I didn't do business with them after that, regardless of price.

On the other hand, I got high quality 14ft 2x6 and I joists for all the framing from Lowe's along with personal service and the best prices.

Clint

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#10

$600 ? . . .

steve mackay

Thats a LOT of sandpaper and glue. I'd hit up the "local" guy and offer him a chance to make a deal (AND my money). I can't support another business at the cost of my own . . . but I'd give him the chance.

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#11

Re: Local Store Loyalty

FredD

It sounds like you buy hardwood sometimes Ed, do yourself a favor and try Kansas Hardwoods in Bellvue , they are a sawmill that has good deals on Native Hardwoods , dry their own and are closer to you then me you will be glad you did.

Between Wamego and St Mary's

FredD

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#12

Re: $600 ? . . .

North of the Border

That's the best advice on the topic, I believe.

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#13

My experience

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I needed some oak plywood for a project a while back. The local BORG's were about $10 a sheet cheaper than the local supplier. However, the BORG ply was one sided and the local supplier ply was two sided so I bought from the local guy. After I got the plywood home and made my first cut I discovered that the plywood from the local source measured 49" x 97" so I could get two 24" pieces from each sheet.

With that said I would not pay 20% more for the same quality product, just to buy local. I earn my money so I like to get my money's worth.

Lee

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#14

Let him bid

Bill Howatt

Yes, by all means give the local guy the opportunity to do better.

My experience is that if you go in with your total list of materials for a job you will definitely come out with a better price than the regular price. You may not get the whole difference but it may be enough to make you happy and keep a local business viable.

Bill

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#15

Kneale Brownson

Tiered pricing

Kneale Brownson

My local has a sticker price on everything that's generally higher than the borgs, but at the order desk, they have books with progressively lower per-piece pricing for progressively larger orders.

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#16

Hardi Plank

iew

You will need a nail gun that adjusts nails with heads. The head should just touch the siding and not penetrate, doing so will void the Hardy warranty. I bought a Hitachi that shoots #6 nails and sets perfectly. Hardy will give you a blade (3 diamonds) to cut the planks, these suckers are hard and make a mess just like cutting concrete. Don't forget to put a piece of vinyl between ends and lap them over the top.

Re: Local Store Loyalty

#17

Re: Hardiplank  And more.....

Barry Irby

I used a roofing nailer to nail the Hardie I installed. Go online to the Hardie site and carefully read the installation instructions. They are touchy about the shank diameter on the nails and they prefer you hang the siding by nailing in the top edge. Leaves very few nails visible. Wear a dust mask, the dust is nasty.