Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

How much cupping is too much?

Posts

How much cupping is too much?

#1

How much cupping is too much?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

I am making some smaller walnut boxes with sides 3/4" x 18" x 11" and, the top/bottom is 3/4" x 14" x 11". I milled up the rough walnut after several weeks in my shop. The wood is from Oregon and was supposed to be dry. Guess it wasn't as some boards have a cup to them along the entire 18" length. Yesterday, I bought a Lignomat Mini Lingo DX/C and the wood now reads about 8 - 10% moisture content. Some was so far gone I ripped and reglued to get them flatter. I am left with maybe a 1/16" gap in the middle when I lay the board flat on the tablesaw. Hand pressure alone will make the boards lay flat. I was wondering, what is too much cupping for a small case that will have through dovetails at the top and bottom to hold it together? These are important pieces to me and I don't want them splitting apart in the future.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#2

Re: How much cupping is too much?

Jesse Cloud

Should be an interesting thread. I suspect you will get lots of different answers.

Here's my 2 cents worth. First of all, if the pieces are really important to you, save the cupping wood for another project and get some stable wood.

Dovetails would probably stop any future cupping, but I would use several, spread throughout the width of the boards, not just one each at the top and bottom. Maybe a bigger problem is that fitting dovetails onto a piece that wants to cup is going to be a royal PITA.

If the piece will go through large humidity changes, it will probably continue to want to cup, just getting it dry before doing the joinery won't help. Usually the problem is that you have a tight arc in the middle of the board and the outer rings will absorb water and grow faster than the middle, denser wood.

Good luck!

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#3

Fully Agree

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#4

JL

Re: How much cupping is too much?

JL

IMO, I would find some new wood.

The amount of cupping that you describe will leave focal gaps in the joints. Yes, you can help "pin" the joints by judicious use of dovetails. You can also chamfer the edges between your joints to help disguise any possible gaps.

The biggest problem is that you will be continually looking at the piece and "picking" it apart. To paraphrase John Jordan's turning phrase - "Life is too short to use crappy wood". If the wood is especially pretty or has dynamite figure, then I would consider using it - other than that - I would find new wood.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#5

After All

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

It DOES grow on trees.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#6

Excessive fretting

Bill Tindall

This issue comes up here periodically. Wide lumber always cups when it sits around so we need to learn to deal with it. Lets think about the situation.....

Any cupped board that can be pressed flat with modest "hand" pressure can be effortlessly held flat with typical good joinery. Right? Doesn't matter if the board is a table top or a case side or box side. The joinery will flatten the board and keep it flat for ever more. No worries mate.

There are two things to worry about. Does the cupping indicate insufficiently dried lumber? In this case the answer is clearly no. The other issue is that the board needs to be mashed flat to mark the dovetails. There are various ways to accomplish this task. The handiest in my mind is to clamp the boards to be joined against a right angle bracket on a flat surface. Such an arrangement will mash any cup from the lumber to be joined and the flat surface will ensure the joined boards will lie in a single plane.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#7

gaps in joints? Why?

Bill Tindall

Not if the board is mashed flat when the dovetails are marked.

I doubt that I have ever assembled something from lumber 12" wide where the lumber was perfectly flat. No problem though because the joinery will hold it flat. I once pulled more than an inch of twist from a board I very much wanted to use in a table top simply by slowly pulling it over time against the table framing. Ditto for box sides, case sides, panels in frame and panel joinery, etc.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#8

Re: How much cupping is too much?

Sgian Dubh

Doug said, "Guess it wasn't as some boards have a cup to them along the entire 18" length."

The only problem I can see with the advice so far is that the description from Doug suggests the wood probably isn't cupped, but it may be bowed. Some clarification from Doug might be useful.

So Doug; is the wood cupped (across the width) or bowed (along the length), or perhaps both? Slainte.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#9

Re: How much cupping is too much?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

The boards are beautifully figured claro walnut cut sequentially from one wide long board which makes for great grain and color continuity. I would describe it as cupped in that it is concave (or convex) across its 11" width but, straight along the 18" length. I've frequently heard that using wider boards(one piece sides and tops)comes with its own set of problems. Now, I may have first hand experience.

The dovetails will run the full width of each piece and I will make the amount of wood removed for the tails as equal as possible to the amount of wood removed for the pins. In other words, very equal spacing/size.

If I continue to use this wood which should I try to make the outside? I've read in drawer making to make the inside of the tree the outside of the drawer. This should make the sides fit flush and the cupping would need to be drawn in flush with its mating part.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#10

Wide lumber doesn't present significant porblems

Bill Tindall

"I've frequently heard that using wider boards(one piece sides and tops)comes with its own set of problems. Now, I may have first hand experience"......You don't have a problem, there aren't significant problems using wide lumber, and it can be oriented whatever way it looks best. Or maybe I should say, what problem do you think you have? Do you believe that the dovetail joint will be too frail to hold the sides flat? Presuming you cut tails first, the only problem you face is mashing the pin board flat for transferring the tail profiles to the pin board. The joint will hold it flat upon assembly, presuming your dovetails are tight.

After the box is made the next step is to plane the sides smooth to the pins and tails. If a few microns of cup are not flattened by the strength of the joint this cup will be flattened during the planing operation.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#11

Ellis Walentine

My take

Ellis Walentine

You said you milled the wood after it had been in your shop for several weeks, and that the MC is 8%-10%. Yet, the boards cupped after you jointed and planed them? That says to me that there was an imbalance in the distribution of the remaining moisture in the boards. In other words, they hadn't equalized enough to stay flat after planing to thickness. That's just an observation, not a remedy at this point.

Regarding holding them flat with joinery, the answer is always situational. In the case of your boxes, I don't see why dovetail joints wouldn't be adequate. Generally, of course, you want the least amount of stress built into your joinery, to avoid problems later. But, I'd say mechanical joinery is a legitimate solution in this case to overcome a small amount of cupping. I choose the outside face by appearance, not rule of thumb.

Ellis

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#12

The "bottom line" to this question

Bill Tindall

What determines too much is not the amount of deflection but the force required to straighten it. If the strength of the joinery is not challenged by the force to flatten the cup, then the cup is not too much.

Nobody mentioned straightening the cup. Spritz some newspaper with water. Cover the damp sheet with a dry sheet. Put the offending board concave side down on the news paper. Watch it magically uncup in a matter of minutes. Quick mark the dovetails, cut them and assemble the box. I used to do this straightening but now I just mash the boards with a clamp on a right angle block and do the marking.

I posted a couple of years ago a technique for straightening bow, a more serious board problem. More serious because the joinery will usually not straighten it.

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#13

Ellis Walentine

Taking this a bit further...

Ellis Walentine

... mechanical remedies in general are fair game in woodworking, cabinetmaking and construction in general. Rather than write a treatise on the kinds of mechanical interventions that might find their way into our work, let's start by put the cupping issue in a larger context: solid-panel cabinet doors. From an engineering standpoint, the stiffness of the rails is what keeps the panel from cupping. Doors need to be designed with the anticipated cupping force in mind, or else cupping for whatever reason (high humidity in the room but not in the cabinet, coupled with a finish that isn't impermeable enough to retard the moisture transfer adequately) can cause (particularly) flat-sawn panels to cup. If the rails don't have the stiffness (a combination of cross-sectional area (section modulus) and fiber stress in bending (varies with species), the cupping force can overcome the rails and cup the entire door. So, when we make typical cabinet doors, we're assuring flatness by mechanical means.

This conversation can easily go a lot further, but I'm out of energy for today. Think about ways to flatten a cupped table leaf, for example. Or a box lid?

Lotta potential for a good wood movement discussion...

Ellis

Re: How much cupping is too much?

#14

Re: Taking this a bit further...

FredD

Ellis , since you mentioned Table leaves ;-))

My outfit did the interiors for the General contractor who built a copy of Tara for the lady that was the head of the Nuclear Medicine Department at UC Berkely and she had bought the entire Antique collection of Emily Post of the Saturday Evening Post family.

The dining room table in that collection of Mahogany was left open with all of the leaves installed and the table had to be at least sixteen feet long and five feet wide and the leaves were about one inch thick and 18 inches wide and dead flat.

You would have drooled to see it. and it was well over a hundred years old and in Museum condition.

The custom made folded leather pads for the top more then likely cost more then any table I have bought.

So I think for a flat table leaf , start out with one that is flat, not one you have to "adjust" as it were.

FredD