Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

Posts

Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#1

Bart Goldberg

Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

Bart Goldberg

Hi All, I am need of a cordless impact driver. I tend to be partial to the Ridgid HD brand cause of the lifetime warranty on the batteries. But, I would not go that route if there is a significant difference to other brands.

Any suggestions?

Thanks

Bart

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#2

Re: Cordless Impact Driver

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Went with the recommendations of several contractor friends and bought the Hitachi 18v Lithium driver. Great tool, very nicely balanced, you can't beat it for deck building. Puts 2-1/2 screws through PT 2x like going through paper. Saved me [& my knees] HOURS of time on the last deck walk I built.


I used a 14v Dewalt to pre-drill and the Hitachi's charge would work 50-60% longer.


Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: Cordless Impact Driver

Bart Goldberg

Thanks Mark - appreciate the advice.

Bart

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#4

Re: Cordless Impact Driver

Barry Irby

I have a Makita 12 volt impact driver. It will drive 2 1/2" screws into PT Lumber like it was butter. It will also drive 3/8" lag bolts 7" long into redwood beams with no trouble at all.

My point is that it is small and light and nicely balanced and has plenty of power. I also have a matching drill and the battery is interchangeable. It does use the Ni-Cad batteries that are heavier than the LIon batteries.

Do you have any tools now that use rechargeable batteries? Could you buy a matching impact driver?

OTOH, The batteries are the weak link for all these tools. If you can get the warranty on the Rigid tools, I would be impressed. Double check carefully and if they still offer the deal be sure you register it carefully. I think they have dropped the lifetime warranty.

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#5

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Second Makita..

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Bart,

I�m really happy with my Makita, 18 Volt Li-ion impact driver. It fits my hand, is light and well balanced, and does what an impact driver is supposed to do...

I think the real differences are the batteries. All my other tools have older technology batteries and you can tell. The charge on Li-ion batteries seems to last forever. When it does drain down it just stops, it does not get weaker and weaker as the battery discharges. It only takes about 30 minutes, or less, to fully charge one. If you have two batteries, you can�t run the first one down, before the second one is charged up. You can also go away for months and the tool will be almost at the same charge level as when you left it.

Small word of warning no matter which driver you buy. As I�m sure you know, an impact driver has a � inch hex drive. The bits that come with the driver have a hollow or notched out spot at the bottom. Dry wall bits do not. (See pic)


At least on my Makita, if you insert a dry wall bit and use it to drive several deck screws, it is nearly impossible to get the bit out. Not sure if this is a universal rule, but it took two of us about an hour to get one bit out. No ill effects, but I won�t be doing that again. I now use an adapter to hold any dry wall or deck screw bits.

Regards,

Jim R.

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#6

My contractor son runs an adapter in his always

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Confusion over terms???

Jesper, Denmark

I just bought a makita 18 volt impact WRENCH for a job I need to do next week. Not wood related, but driving a lot of screws in a machinery modification. The impact wrench has a 3/8" standard male square drive. It fits Hex socket drivers.

I also have an 18 volt (and a 14.4 volt) Makita HAMMER drill with a standard chuck.

The impact wrench has the impact blows in the rotation, where the hammer drill has the impacts axially oriented for driving drill bits through masonry etc.

All three are Li-ion batteries and are a switch from De Walt tols with NiCd batteries, which do not last long for my relatively infrequent use. "Not long" in my book is several years.

For driving screws in difficult wood or long screws in things like decking, I have a small can with linseed oil, and dip the screw tip in the oil before driving. They go in much easier and in the case of driving screws in black locust makes it possible to remove the screws afterwards - which is otherwise not possible.

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#8

Re:Confusion over terms???

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

Check out the Makita BTD 141 LXT 18v Lithium Ion Impact Driver. Best cordless tool I have ever owned 1/4" hex, Tough enough to remove 3/8 bolts, delicate enough for #6 machine screws. When Lisa pick it out I didn't think I would use it much, I almost never use the drill, almost always use the driver.

glc

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#9

Makita on sale *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

I see that the Makita is on sale...


Impact driver on sale

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

No confusion.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

An impact DRIVER is a different type of cordless screwdriver. It is similar in its operation to an impact wrench, though at a much lower torque (1000 in-lbs is typical, versus 4000 in-lbs for an impact wrench), and at a much higher blows per minute. Impact wrenches are more designed for automotive work (thus the standard 3/8", 1/2", 3/4", etc. male square drive), whereas impact drivers are designed for typical carpentry/remodeling/renovation work and thus have a 1/4" female hex drive (they're not really intended for drilling, so no 3-jaw chuck).

Jason

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#11

Bart Goldberg

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

Bart Goldberg

Thanks everyone for all for your replies and good advice. It looks like I'm gonna get the 18-volt Makita. On Amazon, the reviews for this tool were very good.

FYI - I went onto the Rigid site and read the user reviews of their impact driver. I was amazed at the number of complaints. Mostly about the batteries, and several about the long wait time for replacements. I guess having a life time warranty is only as good as the service you get for that piece of paper.

Bart

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

#12

Re: Looking for Cordless Impact Driver

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot ID

Hi Bart,

I see you've already made your choice, and a good choice it is! I just wanted to add that I have one Hitatchi and about three Makita impact drivers. The Hitatchi is good, but the Makitas are great! We bought them for a very large deck project, but now use them all the time for all kinds of stuff. I bought mine before they came out with the nice lithium models, and I would definitely get a lithium if I were shopping now. They are great tools! You will be glad you got it!

Scott.