Do you need to make it openable?
John in NM
If so I'd go with a bungee or rope. If you tie a couple loops in the rope you can cinch it tight by feeding the slack end through the end loop and back through the other before tying off - works like a block and tackle but with loops instead of blocks. Terrible description... sorry...
If you need it to be permanent, I'd go with metal banding for pallets. The type I have would be pretty tricky to use on a barrel as its designed to work on the flat area of palleted goods or lumber. There are other kinds that use nylon straps and a little wire dealy to hold it tight - those are re-useable IIRC, but I've never had one to try. Too expensive for a cheapskate like me to buy new, mine is one a friend found at a scrapyard and gave me when he was done with it.
I've got lime plaster stored in three plastic drums, got them from an oil distributor, anti-freeze came in them. Cut the tops off with a jig saw, starting at one of the fill holes and leaving the lip to tie plastic over the top so the water can't evaporate out of the plaster.
When I lived in Tucson, we had a house with a parapet around a flat roof, and used to collect the water for our trees. The barrels filled right up in about 10 seconds during summer storms, and would sometimes have a 5' jet of water gushing out the open hole (used one for the gutter, the other to siphon out with a garden hose). One time I'd left the hose in - I was siphoning the barrel and had to run an errand. It rained while I was away and I found the barrel empty when I came back. The barrel had filled and the excess pressure of over flowing had primed the hose so it self-siphoned.