Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

dumb tablesaw question

Posts

dumb tablesaw question

#1

dumb tablesaw question

Dave Tenney

I have an old Craftsman 100 table saw with a new motor off of a Delta Contractors saw. The saw works great, but if I push it too hard it'll blow the breaker.

At my day job, we have a newer Shop Fox contractors saw. Has about the same power as my saw at home and will also blow the breaker at the shop if pushed too hard.

I also work a part time job with my uncle doing construction. In our work trailer we have a 20 year old Makita job site table saw. You can plug this saw into any old circuit in any house and push 2x4's through the thing like crazy...You can bog the motor till it cries uncle ripping a soaking wet treated 2x6 and it has never blown a breaker that I can ever remember.

Why do the contractor saws blow breakers and the Makita has never blown one?

Inquiring minds want to know. (well, at least I want to know!)

Re: dumb tablesaw question

#2

JL

Re: dumb tablesaw question

JL

You never said what size breaker or what else may be on the circuit.

I'll venture some thoughts though.

I had an old Sears contractor's saw. Nice saw - but I still prefer my cabinet saw :b . It would pull maybe 17 amps (or more) on start. It always drew a LOT of current when it started. It might bog down on occasion and draw some more current then.

The only Makita jobsite saw I've ever used was a nice compact, small direct drive unit. It would draw 15 amps at maximum. The maximum current draw was (is) 15 amps.

The maximum current draw is what blows the breakers. I could be all wet - but those are my observations.

Re: dumb tablesaw question

#3

For starters, check

Bruce, a MN Galoot

the size and length of the wire you having between the outlet and the motor. I used to have exactly the same problem. Some years before, I had put a 15'length of wire I took from an old extension cord and used it successfully for a long time. Then when I upgraded the motor from 3/4 hp to 1.5 hp, it would blow the breaker every time. Turns out it was a 16 ga. wire. I finally got smart and upgraded that wire to 12 ga. and 12 ft. Nary a problem since.

Re: dumb tablesaw question

#4

Re: dumb table saw question

Barry Irby

Look on the motor label. It should list RLA (Running Load Amps) and LRA (Locked Rotor Amps). The Running load Apps is the amount of current the motor pulls when it is running at full speed with no load. The other one is what happens when the shaft is locked and and can not turn. It takes the most energy to start the shaft and spin it up to speed, that is, the start up current, which is the usual time we find the shaft sitting still with the current on.

Some breakers are designed to "ignore" the startup current surge if it only lasts a second or two.

So, If your saw draws Running Load Amps that are near the rating of the breaker and you start to load it down, the amp draw goes up and if it exceeds the rating of the breaker for more than an instant, the breaker will trip.

It also depends what else is on the circuit with the saw. Lets say the saw pulls fifteen amps, but there is other stuff on the circuit pulls four, then it would only take a one or two amps increase to trip the breaker.

I am not sure what effect the cord has on actual current draw, but it would clearly be better to have the cord be big enough.

Re: dumb tablesaw question

#5

Re: dumb tablesaw question

Bill Howatt

It has nothing to do with startup current since both models start fine; the problem is when the saw is loaded and the motor is drawing its full load current.

The size and length of cord can be a factor.

The diameter, sharpness and tooth style of the blade can be a factor.

I don't know but the job-site Makita may have a universal motor rather than an induction motor and it has a better torque characteristic under load. This effect could be amplified by an undersize supply cord.

If you have a reasonably sharp blade and the saw is in the 1.5HP range I would be looking at the power cord size/length. Ripping softwood shouldn't easily kill a saw.

Bill

Re: dumb tablesaw question

#6

Re: dumb tablesaw question

ThomD

I used to have a saw like that. It was 3/4 hp and one could win a fight with it. If it decided it wanted to kick, one could just hold on and stop the motor. Then the lights went out. I always assumed the non-rotation was bad.

Re: dumb tablesaw question

#7

Re: dumb table saw question

Dave Tenney

Thanks for all the replies...I'm a bit late in checking the board, but the family business has been very busy.

It look like I'll be updating the circuit the saw is plugged into to use 12 gauge wire and see if that helps. I did get to use a contractor saw recently that was wired for 220 and man what a difference!

Dave