Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Isolating switch for your workshop??

Posts

Isolating switch for your workshop??

#1

Isolating switch for your workshop??

Hamish

I have just been reading Barry Irby's message about the problem with his compressor intermittently starting up because of a leak and the safety problems that could arrise.

At the moment, I am half way through converting an outside room into a workshop, and have been wondering if I should install a main isolating switch to shut off all the electricity running into that room. I had thought about putting it just inside the workshop door but I'm also wondering if I it would be better to locate it in the house instead. In that case, I might run a separate wire for an entrance light.

Do any of you have similar safety switches in your workshops?

Do you consider it an important item to include in your wiring design?

Has anybody in hindsight wished they had had such a switch?

Looking forward to your points of view.

Cheers, Hamish.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#2

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Bill Howatt

My shop is in my basement but if I were to build it again I would give serious thought to an isolating switch. I can't easily add it because I have a couple of house circuits coming off the same sub-panel as the shop (shouldn't have done that).

If you have small children (or maybe even teenagers) around you can easily ensure nobody starts any machines and the switch can be padlocked too.

By turnng off the switch you can disable anything accidently left plugged in that shouldn't be such as soldering irons, glue guns, perhaps battery chargers, ....

I think I would put it beside the shop doorway. You want it in your face on the way out and you want it very convenient or else you won't use it as intended. If you are like me, it it isn't convenient it will not be used. You also don't want to go to the shop and then have to run back to the house to turn the power on.

Bill

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#3

Ellis Walentine

Absolutely...

Ellis Walentine

... at least as regards air compressors and machines that have pressure-activated switches. Near as the fire marshal could tell my shop burned down because we had a huge old air compressor whose unloader valve got stuck and wouldn't let the compressor turn over, so the motor (5hp 3Φ) sat there and strained until it heated up the wiring in the breaker box, which subsequently arced and started the fire. This probably isn't much of an issue with smaller, modern compressors, but I would advise you to just be sure you turn off all compressors before leaving the shop.

Ellis

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#4

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Tony - Memphis

My shop is an small building on our lot. By code, the electricians had to install a switch in the house that shuts off the shop completely. The shop has it's own 100A service, but the switch in the garage shuts it all down. In the shop, I have a set of switches on the wall that control all my circuits (except the lights). When I leave, I make sure all switches are off. Makes me feel better knowing everything is shut off. One mistake I made is that I control my outside lights and my DC with X10. I have to leave a circuit on to power the X10 receiver. I could hardwire a receiver in and may do that for the light circuit. That way, I could turn off everything but the light circuits and still be able to turn on my outisde lights with my remote (it's too dark to see to get in sometimes). The wall switches were an idea I read in a magazine sent in from a reader.

Tony

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#5

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

If you can put all your shop circuits into a single sub-panel, then there are two safe ways to do this that I know of.

1. Use a double pole single throw fused disconnect. These are heavy-duty units with the large outside lever on a steel housing that holds the two knife switches and the fuses. This is the safest and cheapest way to go.

2. Use a activator/contactor switch which uses a magnetic switch for the main disconnect and a lower voltage switch for the control. My DC, running out in my garage but switched from the basement shop, is set up this way. My unit is "small", 220v + 20 amps, controlled by a 110v circuit that has 3-way actuator switches. These are not cheap when you get up to the 60-100 amp range that might be put in to feed an entire shop.

DO NOT, however, use circuit breakers as switches! I've seen several people propose this and it is dangerous. Breakers are not built to take numerous "trips" as would occur if they were used as switches. This is a way to start an electrical fire, get fried, or probably both when the breaker malfunctions.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#6

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Hamish

Thats a good idea of yours Mark to install a main switch with a lock. My daughters are in their teens now and don't take much interest in what I do but I'm sure there will come a time when boyfriends will appear, and that could change things.

As regards to where I ought to install the main switch, one with a large handle, as Mark suggested sounds good, but I'm not sure if it would be better placed inside the house near the outside door that I use to access the shop or just inside the shop door. I feel I ought to be able to isolate the whole shop for peace of mind when I'm away, against fire, little fingers etc. I might install a secondary light circuit from the house, to say one or two strip lights, to use when I need to fetch something out of it, like a tool or God forbid, a bicycle!

Hamish.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#7

Re: Disconnect

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Ideally, you want the disconnect close to the service panel which would tend to say "in the Shop" area. I know of no reason, however, that you couldn't put a second disconnect in your house where, I presume, the feed to the shop originates at your main panel. This would allow you to kill all power to the shop without getting into it in case of emergency or really bad weather.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#8

Eh Gods, YES !

steve mackay

Go ahead and put in a small breaker box (OR big ?) Safety, fault isolation, and you'll still have power (read : lights and radio) while you work on different circuit. AND if your running a new wire into it PLEASE run 220 ! Thats the only "majior" mistake I made in the whole process.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#9

separate subpanel with main cutoff

Chris Friesen

I've got a subpanel with cutoff in the shop that controls most of the outlets. The overhead door, a couple of lights, and one receptacle per bay (basically the original wiring in the garage) still work with the panel off. All the rest, including all the 240V stuff, gets disabled.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#10

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I can either secure all power at the shop's 100A subpanel or the main panel that feeds it in the garage below.

Something to think about, in addition to pressure activated switches like compressors, you may have some power always being used by a few of your machines if they have older style, low voltage, magnetic switches. If so, power is going to the 24V transformers at at all times- I can hear them hum when it is quiet in my shop. While the transformers don't draw a lot of power, they draw some.

Anytime I will be gone for longer than a day, I secure all power to the shop.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#11

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Hamish

Many thanks for all your suggestions and ideas. Living over here in Spain means that we only have 220v. Professional workshops are usually three phase 380v, which is way beyond my needs. I think having the ability to shut off power completely to the workshop will be the way to go. Whether I put the main isolating switch in the shop or the house, I will decide once I have chewed over the pros and cons a little bit.

To date, I have leveled the floor, rendered the walls, it is a block and cement construction, and am now about to add some sound insulation which will also help keep out the cold in the cooler months. It will be now when I have to thread the cables around the walls, before I cover them over with the wall panels. So I'm also busy working out the best places where to place the sockets, so they won't get in the way of future cupboards or whatever. It all seems to take up so much time, as I would really like to make some sawdust, but I'm getting there slowly.

Thanks for looking, cheers, Hamish.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#12

Locating plugs

Bill Howatt

An idea to possibly consider depending on your requirements. Locate plugs sufficiently high off the floor so they are still accessible if you lay sheets of plywood etc against the wall.

Bill

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#13

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Big Dave

I apologize if I'm late to the party here. I'd like to tell you what I did in my shop regarding your question. I "finished" my shop last year and tried to incorporate as many safetyl features as I could. Power was the biggest one. I knew I wanted to be able to isolate power to the tools, but I also wanted power available for the lights...

A little background: The shop is 26'x36', w/ 10' walls, 200a service. In order to get 200a service, I had to upgrade the meter base for the house (which is mounted outside the garage) to 400a. Power was then split inside the meter base with leads feeding the house and shop (200a each). A disconnect was installed next to the distribution panel for the house (inside the garage) to isolate the shop. The shop is then fed through it's own 200a distribution panel.

Now, power isolation for the tools is achieved through the use of an "E-Stop" switch located near the door. The e-stop is wired to relays to that feed all the recepticals powering tools - 120v and 220v. When leaving the shop the e-stop is depressed, opening the relays and killing power to everything but the lights, clock and refrigerator. Reset the switch upon re-entry into the shop, and it's business as usual...

The pic shows the relay panel next to the shop distribution panel.

I hope that makes sense to everyone...

Dave


img

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#14

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Jesper, Denmark

It makes perfect sense. the relays are designed to break full load currents, where a disconnect switch is not designed to be opened under load.

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#15

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Don Evans

I see one possible problem when it comes to air compressors.

I cannot state that ALL compressors are this way but I know some are.

If you kill power to them while they are running the bleeder valve will NOT open and release the pressure off the pistons for the next start up.

They DO work ok if you turn off the switch on the compressor itself, they are design that way but if you kill the power prior to that switch it doesn't dump the pressure.

Simple in this case to wait if compressor is running and hit the switch after it stops and you hear the hissing (bleeding) stop. But you gotta know this is only reason I mention it.

Don

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#16

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Jay Lombardo

Dave, my compliments to the installer. Don't know if it was you or your electrician but that is nice work. That is what is meant by "neat and workmanlike manner" .

Jay

(electrician)

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

#17

Re: Isolating switch for your workshop??

Big Dave

Thanks, Jay!

I'll pass that along! A friend of mine wired the panels for me - said he needed to practice a bit. He's a low voltage guy who works with HVAC controls and likes to see if he can do as well, or better, than the electricians he has to work with...

Dave