Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Hiding really bad oak floor fills

Posts

Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#1

Hiding really bad oak floor fills

Kneale Brownson..Ready for first summer in CO

Just purchased a house in Colorado with a "premium" oak flooring upgrade that looks so bad I'd like to cover it with carpeting.

They filled knots, tearouts and even some bark areas on this really low-grade oak. In Michigan, we'd have used most of this oak to heat the shop with in the winter.

Flooring is varnished with (if the can in the garage is correct) a Varathane flooring finish.

Can I darken the whole thing so as to hide the fills with a tinted finish?

Any other solution?

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#2

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

Stuart Hough

Kneale,

If this is a new home you had built, I would call the builder and let him know that the floor in unacceptable and needs to be replaced. Invite them to come look at it and ask if he would want that shoddy work in his home. If he refuses to correct the problem, then offer to advertise the quality of his work on the local TV news consumer advocacy segment, and promise that you will give his work a special review on websites like Angie's List. Offer to provide pictures to the realtors around town to get the word out. By the time you finish this, he should have the crew there ripping out the garbage and installing what should have been put down in the first place.

Just my humble "tired of being screwed by the builder" opinion.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#3

Was he wearing a mask?

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

When you purchased the premium upgrade didn't you notice the mask that the salesperson was wearing? ;)

I would politely ask the builder to replace it be fore threatening any other actions.

Lee

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#4

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

Nat Robison

Kneale,

You didn't specifically indicate that this is a brand new house you're taking from the builder or a 10-year old house that you happen to know the details of.

If brand new, I'd bring it to the builder's attention. If he can't tell that it looks bad, let him know your options......Is he paid in full yet? Might be worth paying your atty. an hour's worth of time to draft a letter, etc. I have a 45-year old house in Michigan with original oak floors and nowhere in the 800 sq. ft. of flooring is anything that looks like it was patched, filled, etc. Doesn't sound kosher to me.

If this is an older house that's not under any warranty, you can remove existing finish, stain darker, and see what you think. I've seen wood floors stained darkly and it looks to me like it would camoflauge a lot of crap (but no direct experience on my part, though).

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#5

Addl. thought

Nat Robison

I just re-read the original post and it sounds like a brand new house.

What I meant to add was......... I wouldn't do a damn thing myself if I still wielded any financial power in this deal.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#6

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

R Payne

No longer working construction because of this sort of shoddy practice.

Unless you still owe the builder money don't expect any satisfaction. Builders around here change names oftener than some people change socks just to get away from a bad reputation for doing just this sort of work. And this tactic keeps them in business and making money. If someone tries legal action, they go the bankruptcy option and avoid it that way.

It doesn't help matters that many people today don't know what quality looks like or craftsmanship. They are just impressed with wood.

The only real ways to get the job done right is to hold final payment until you are satisfied or get lucky.

Probably the best you will be able to do is strip the finish, stain dark and refinish. Or carpet. Or complete new flooring.

ron

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#7

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

FredD

Kneale,

that's a bad thing to happen to anybody.

Did you see the floor before the purchase?

Who told you it was a Premium upgrade, upgrade from what?

If the Realtor told you this , he is on the hook for defective disclosure.

If it is a new home , it is covered by warranty and the Builder /Flooring contractor is on the hook.

If a lender is carrying a note , tell him the problem and let him know your willing to withhold payment,because you didn't get what you either bargained for in good faith or were led to believe you were getting.

If a bank examiner looked at the property to see what it was like , ask for a meeting at the house so he can rectify his mistake.

If the lender and the Builder worked together on the subdivision , then there is a conflict of interest in that the Lender did not provide his required Fiduciary responsibility to you and if a Realtor was involved , same thing.

Law concerning this type of Consumer fraud varies from state to state, but not much.

Lastly.if the Builder was required to put up a Performance Bond for the house or a Financial bond to maintain his license, speak to them, they will listen.

Above all , do not attempt to disguise or fix the problem yourself , if your interested in getting it mitigated, if it is a subdivision, it might be a eye opener to see what similar houses floors look like.

Good luck,

FredD

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#8

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

Kneale Brownson..Ready for first summer in CO

I had pix in the original post but they got lost when my message went to moderation because I'd typed in a different tagline after my name like we used to be able to do here.

Tried to repost with the pix, but the system won't let them in.

It's an existing house. We bought the house for its location, not for the floor. I just want to hide some of the blatantly filled junk wood while keeping the wood and not turning it into a black floor. I really don't want to strip the floor either.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#9

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

Kneale Brownson..Ready for first summer in CO

Here's the pix:


img

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#10

Wow, that's the worst floor I've seen

Nat Robison

I suggest you get to Bed, Bath, & Beyond and get some area rugs. I'm betting that filler will not stain as darkly as the wood but I might be wrong. That wood is just all over the place.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#11

Man!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That floor looks like it was made from rejected pallet stock!

Good luck on getting it resolved.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#12

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

Looks to me like the floor is from utility grade oak flooring with no sorting at all.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#13

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

FredD

Now you know why there is a wood putty called "Trowel Grade" for flooring people.

It seems from the limited view that you have mostly shorts , hence a lot of joints and it also seems to me that the best way to improve the look is to get rid of the flooring and have it done over.

May not be what you wanted to hear , but given the time to try and mask it with stain and refinishing , you may want to reconsider and use a good grade of Pre-finished flooring from Cherokee if your already in the house , or do a typical flooring job that is sanded and finished in the field.

Either way you will not be reminded of how it looks every time you enter the house and while Carpet is a consideration, it's not cheap either.

FredD

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#14

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

Barry Irby

Years ago I was in Lumber Liquidators and they had a similar grade of oak flooring. It was actually the rejects form everything else. If their better grade of flooring was selling for $3 a foot, this stuff was $.99. They had found away to sell their scraps. If who ever laid the floor had tinted the filler darker, it would look better, but short of sitting down with a Magic Marker and coloring each spot, I think you are out of luck. My experience is that the filler takes less stain and comes out lighter than the flooring and looks like what you have got, while if it were darker, it "hides" a little better. If you had a dark tan marker (for the "wood" and a chocolate brown one (for the knots), you might be able to improve this a bit. (Oh, and a lot of patience!) You could sand the floor lightly, color it, if you could stay in the lines, and put on another coat of finish.

OTOH, You can't make chicken salad out of chicken poop.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#15

I am puzzled...more problems than the floor loom

Bill Tindall

If you are lucky the builder realized he was loosing money at the end of the project and cut corners in the finish work. I would fear that this floor is a reflection of cost cutting throughout the building process.

I don't know why flooring of this quality is even available for installation. I suppose it must be rejects from a flooring factory, stuff that used to be burned to heat the kilns. Strip flooring is cut from #2 common oak so there are plenty of defects available if the lumber is machined into flooring first and then trimmed to produce the various grades. I am still amazed that what this stuff could sell for would justify the expense of producing it and marketing it.

Oak lumber has been inexpensive the past couple of years so the raw material cost of this wood would not be even a dollar/bdft less than clear oak.

Quite clearly the builder saved a few cents per square ft installing this stuff instead of something of higher quality. This fact would suggest to me that there are similar "savings" throughout the house yet to be discovered. Were it my house I would be hiring a building inspector to carefully go through the house to see what other corners got cut, with the hope that I could force the builder to fix some of them either through any sort of home guarantee or code violation that could have occurred.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#16

Re: I am puzzled...more problems than the floor lo

Kneale Brownson..Ready for first summer in CO

Oak ain't cheap in the Rockies.

This is a package house--one of half a dozen styles/sizes in the development. The whole development is done on the cheap. But the houses sell for astronomical prices because of location, location, location. The ceilings aren't finished quite flat, not all the wall plastering was done smoothly, etc., etc.

We had an inspection. Reputable inspector said this house was surprisingly better than many in the development.

Every room on the ground floor has this oak treatment. With no furniture, the fills stand out like neon signs. We're trying to fill it with furnishings to see if that mutes the effect somewhat.

I'm thinking we'll try area rugs where there isn't furniture.

Thanks for the suggestions.

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#17

Possible solution

Grant in Iowa

Using a router with an appropriate carbide tipped bit, remove the ugly pink filler wherever you find it. Try to make the holes look like a knot by making them round or ovoid.

Then mix some epoxy with powdered black or dark umber (or some pleasing combo you find while experimenting) powdered dye. Mask off each hole with blue tape by taping over, then cutting out the hole with an exacto knife. Fill the holes to slightly mounded with epoxy and heat with a heat gun to evacuate bubbles, if needed. If so inclined, you could patch the larger holes with a router template and something like bowties. Turn the sows ear into a silk purse.. well... OK maybe not silk, but denim anyway.

I use black dyed epoxy to fill knots often, and the dark color makes it appear to just be a dark feature in the wood or knot. It isn't easily seen as a patch, especially to the layman.

Once you have made the epoxy repairs, sand, stain and refinish as desired. I suggest darker would be better.

I agree..that pink filler is about as ugly as it gets.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Hiding really bad oak floor fills

#18

Kneale Brownson

Re: Possible solution

Kneale Brownson

Thanks, Grant. Sounds like a workable solution. Most of the fills are in knots anyway, so that should make sense.

As I add furnishings, the fills are less predominent than when viewed on a bare floor.