Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Finishing Oak Stairway

Posts

Finishing Oak Stairway

#1

Finishing Oak Stairway

Joe Pack

Good friends of mine have built a gorgeous dome home, doing almost all of the work themselves. Now they are to the point of finishing an oak starirway, but are running into some problems.

The oak has been stained with a ZAR oil-based stain. They have planned to finish the stairway with polyurethene, and have done a couple of small areas with one coat of poly. The problem they have run into is air bubbles messing up the first coat. The poly was used as is from the can, and was stirred, not shaken (James Bond in reverse). A general purpose brush was used.

I offered my limited words of wisdom, but told them I would defer to folks here with more experience and knowledge.

Some questions:

1. Is polyurethene the best material to use on their oak stairway? Is there a better finish (more durable, "warmer", easier to apply) to use on an oak stairway?

2. Should some sort of sealer (shellac?) be used over the oil stain prior to the finish coat?

3. If the poly is the finish to use, should it be thinned to help eliminate bubbles?

4. What type of applicator should be used with either poly or other finish? Would a wipe-on technique be less touchy?

You get the idea...any help would be appreciated. I am going to direct Michelle to this thread so she can read it herself, so detail would be great.

Thanks for the help. I built up my WoodCentral buddies as the "go-to" folks, but no pressure....

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#2

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

FredD

If the Stair were mine and the treads and raisers exposed, and because I like the look of Shellac on Oak which was for years the traditional finish there's where I would go.

If the Zar wasn't completely dry , if the Poly was water base instead of oil, get some oil base poly and I would say seal the stair with Shellac first.

The poly while not as pretty and warm as Shellac and certainly not as easy to repair scuffing and dings is a very tough finish , relative to the Shellac , but still not bullet proof , no finish is.

Zinsers Sealcoat rescues a lot of errors in finishing.

If they do apply the Shellac, tell them to brush a full wet coat , stroked one direction and resist the temptation go over it again , until it dry.

FredD

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#3

Poly was oil-based

Joe Pack

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#4

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

chuckbeck

I second the shellac. I finished my new wh oak staircase a few months ago and finished with 5 coats of shellac, knowing that the years will not be kind to them and I will need to repair them and touch up the finish.

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#5

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

David Yoho

I think shellac would be easy to repair but it wouldn't be my first choice because of how quickly it would show wear. An initial sealer coat wouldn't be a bad idea under poly but I wouldn't be prone to use poly either, as it is hard to repair.

I think, once again, my first choice here would be Waterlox because while it cures hard, it's better at accepting additional coats down the road when rejuvenating worn places. It can be applied using a good natural bristle brush or wiped on with a soft cloth.

David

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#6

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

Bill Tindall

1. Is polyurethene the best material to use on their oak stairway? This is the best choice for durability and it looks better than any water based finish I have ever seen.

2. Should some sort of sealer (shellac?) be used over the oil stain prior to the finish coat? Not necessary and potentially a risk. Thinned varnish is the best sealer. May want to thin the first coat 1 part solvent to 3 of varnish.

3. If the poly is the finish to use, should it be thinned to help eliminate bubbles? YES, about 1:4.

4. What type of applicator should be used with either poly or other finish? Doesn't matter. What ever one is most comfortable with. I use a brush because I am old fashioned, but it may well be that foam brush is better or even a pad. I get a glass smooth floor finish with a 4" high quality brush.

Would a wipe-on technique be less touchy? Sure, if you want a soft undurable finish.

EPA seems to be doing all it can to make solvent based finishes unattractive such that the insignificant amount of VOC's added to the air from finishing stairways will no longer despoil the environment. The main strategy is to tighten regulations that result in the manufacturers needing to up the solids content of the products. The result is that they are too thick for proper application. Add some VOC's back in the form of mineral spirits, whatever is necessary to get good flow out. Probably 1 part solvent to 4 or varnish will do the trick.

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

Clint Searl

The oil poly is a good choice. Thinned and wiped on in several coats will keep away the bubbles and provide a durable finish without the fussy application requirements of shellac.

If they want to consider an alternative , a waterborne poly floor finish would be my choice. The Varathane brand contains aluminum oxide for enhanced scuff resistance.

Clint

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#8

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Joe,

As mentioned, manufactures have backed off the VOC's in oil formulations for marketing compliance reasons. Thinning is therefore required to get the finish to release entrapped air and level properly. While mineral spirits is the most common diluent, VM&P naptha actually does a much better job on oil poly and varnishes. Reason being that its vapor pressure is 2-3 times that of "MS" so it evaporates faster while also thinning the oils better, and you'll have the film reach "dust free" status much faster. Add not more than 20% by volume.

CAVEAT: Dilution with naptha should only be done with a working volume of finish: that amount that will be used within 48 hours which should NOT be returned to the main container. Reason is naptha tends to accelerate the polymerization process so the mix will gel in the can in a fairly short time.

The only time I'd use shellac on a floor is if I had to seal in a stain to prevent bleeding into a waterborne top coat. In that situation (not what you've described) a spitcoat would be enough. While shellac is a lovely finish (I use a lot of it), its durability will not be at all good on stairs where the wear results from essentially a scuffing/grinding motion of shoes with embedded grit.

Foam brushes do a good job and are easy to handle, but you can get good results with a high quality bristle brush. Lambs' wool pads that have been properly prepared (washed and conditioned to remove excess hairs and dust) will give outstanding results, but they're harder to use in corners. For best control of runs and sags on vertical sections, avoid back-brushing the finish.

hth

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#9

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

Keith Newton

I would heat a couple of steps at a time with a heat gun, or hAir dryer before brushing poly.

If the air inside the wood warms after, the expansion will cause bubbles.

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#10

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

Ron Bauman

I have done a fair amount of urethane finishing and I have a method that usually gives a mirror result. If you apply the coat scrubbing across the grain with a pretty good brush you'll raise a bunch a bubbles, but then you do what is called "tipping off" where you very gently with the grain and just barley touching the finish drag the brush tip over the new coat. This removes the brush marks. Then stop. if there are a few bubbles left use a pin or needle to pierce them and then walk away. I'd practice this a few times to get the hang of it and then have at it. Keep in mind there is no such thing as perfection.

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#11

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

FredD

Joe,

I told you Shellac has been the traditional finish for things like floors , stairs, for several good reasons , Chuck can testify to it's appearance.

Some of the posts have been inaccurate or misguided , here is a Overview from the leading Shellac manufacturer in the country.

They are speaking from well over a hundred years of product experience and have a R &d Department staffed with Coatings Chemists.

MSDS

Surface Preparation Guide

Project Tutorials

Color Guide

FAQ

Coverage Chart

Glossary

Videos

Specification Library

Educational Courses

Warranties

Case Studies

Newsletters

OVERVIEW:

Bulls Eye� Shellac is an alcohol-based solution of lac, a natural resin imported mainly from India, that is available in Clear and Amber tones. Clear shellac dries transparent with a faint, golden cast that is much lighter than oil-base varnishes, while amber shellac has a warm, orange cast that gives a rich, antique-look to woodwork. Bulls Eye Shellac has many advantages over other clear finishes: it�s easy to use, dries quickly, is non-toxic when dry and cleans up easily with ammonia and water.

PRODUCT FEATURES:

Traditional finish & sealer

All-Natural, non-toxic, easy to use

Classic finish for wood trim, paneling and furniture

Great protective sealer for crafts and household projects

Dries lightning fast - can be recoated in under 45 minutes

Does not darken or yellow with age

Easy clean up with alcohol or ammonia and water

Do yourself and your neighbor a favor, check out: Zinnsers.com

Fred

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#12

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

Chris Friesen

I've had bad experiences with the Varathane Nano Defence stuff. This is the waterborne floor finish with aluminum oxide up here in Canada.

I bought a gallon of it and it was all "gummy" and stuck to the lid. Got another gallon that looked fine. Got delayed for a few months and just recently opened up the pail and it was all "gummy" as well. Luckily the store took it back but I'm never using that stuff again.

I'm doing some stairs as well and I'm going to go with Bona Mega. Seems to get good reviews.

Re: Finishing Oak Stairway

#13

Wise Choice

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Not also that the Bona Mega can be easily tinted for warming things up. I've got 3 coats of satin on my living, dining and foyer floors and the stuff's very tough and showing no wear after 2 years.