Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Time for a new new computer? OT

Posts

Time for a new new computer? OT

#1

Time for a new new computer?  OT

Barry Irby

I was cleaning up my e-mails today and found one from Hewlett Packard about my new computer. They picked up from my registration that I had one that had software problems with the hard drive and they STRONGLY recommended I go to their site and download a patch.

This is not my cup of tea. I am more of a woodworker than computer tech.

So, I follow the instructions. The web site asks for the number that identifies my computer. I rummage around, under the desk with a flashlight and find out its a p6367cb. No luck. They can't identify it. I rummage some more, under the desk and on the computer. Finally decide they are looking for one less digit. Tried p6367b and it worked. When I got tangled up in the next question I called them at the number they listed and ended up talking to someone in India. For about an hour and half we turned it on and rebooted and downloaded and burned CD's and on and on. It never updated the software. We tried resetting the boot sequence, we tried installing from the hard drive, and from a bootable CD.

Keep in mind that this computer is about three months old. The reason I did not notice the Urgent Update sooner was it was buried in all the offers from HP to sell me more computers and software and printers.

After all that, the supervisor reviewed the case and said "nevermind, Your particular computer/hard drive does not need this."

I'm completely steamed. I bought this computer because the hard drive in the last one failed, three times. To be threatened with hard drive failure and then told to NeverMind is past my limit.

HP updates stuff in the computer regularly. Why could they not update this while I was sleeping? Or would it have been unreasonable to have hem send a tech to the house to do it? Why did I have to rummage for all the numbers? They already knew them, that's how they knew I needed the upgrade before I did. And, If I needed this upgrade, how dome I am getting the NeverMind now?

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#2

Re: Time for a new new computer?  OT

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Barry, go buy a DELL now, they are having some good sales. I have two and never any problems. The one I have here is the Inspiron 1525, 250GB, and 3GB RAM.

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#3

Re: Time for a new new computer?  OT

Charles in Mtl.

Barry,

I would delete all HP programs as they are nonessential to the proper functioning of your computer. There is in all likelihood nothing wrong with your computer and with the hard drive. Download HD Tune and see what that gives you.

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#4

Re: Time for a new new computer?  OT

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

I get really irritated with overseas customer support. Since I have been building my own desktops for many years I don't have the problem with my computers but I have had the problem with other electronic devices.

BTW, if I were going to buy a desktop it would not be a Dell. One of my sons has purchased several Dells over the years and I am not impressed.

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#5

Re: Time for a new new computer?  OT

Bill Howatt

I don't think anybody who builds their own desktop computers would be impressed by Dell products. Proprietary hardware and cost-cutting designs don't impress me.

Bill

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#6

Second That

David Yoho

I don't build my own any more because the cost savings isn't there like it once was and I just don't have the time for it these days. The only reason to build now days is to get exactly what you want in one but I've been fairly successful doing that with new HP's I've ordered.

That said, I still work on many computers for people and I am still not impressed with Dell's offerings. A buddy of mine recently was looking for a new computer and talked with a "techie" at a local store. When he mentioned he was looking at Dell the guy advised that he steer clear of them due to reports of reconditioned drives and other parts being used in an effort to hold down costs. His recommendation was to go with HP, as I had also advised him to do.

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#7

Go Mac and don't look back.

Joe Pack

Owned and used both. Started with PC, then experienced Mac, then back to PC at home and work, then Mac and PC at work, now Mac only at home. Nothing but "techie" problems, errors, bios errors...blah blah...with PCs. Foreign language/located "customer service" with PC stuff is a joke. I want to use it, not reprogram it.

Went with Mac exclusively (13" laptop and 20" iMac) and have had only one problem with a touchpad. I talked with a tech who answered within 2 minutes and spoke in a language I could understand and used words I could understand. In less than 5 minutes I had arrangements, not for repair, but for a new computer! Picked it up the next day at a nearby Apple store even though I bought the original online as a refurb. Get THAT kind of service from HP or Dell!

It is not true that Macs don't have occasional problems, but it IS true that the problems are (1) easy to fix without needing to be a computer nerd and (2) in my experience, occur extremely rarely instead of once a month like my PCs.

The Mac may cost a few dollars more, but the lack of frustration on my part has been worth at least as much as the price differential. And when comparing configurations on an apples to apples basis (sorry, I couldn't resist that one!), you may find that the cost differential is not that great.

One person's opinion. That and 50 cents will buy you 1/4 cup of yuppie coffee! :-))

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#8

Yup.

paul in AZ

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#9

Re: Go Mac and don't look back.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've owned Gateways, and used IBMs, Dells and HPs at work. I've made my own and had problems with all, mostly operating system software related.

A little over a year ago I got an IMac. Not once in that time has it locked up on me. Based on Unix, it's a much, much more stable and secure operating system.

The things I like: system stability, plug and play capability, and it always works. The search is like nothing you've ever experienced. By the time you finished typing your search string, the search is done. Try that on a Windows PC. You'll be sitting there for minutes. Mac software is more intuitive, as is the operating system.

Things I don't like: more apps for Windows, a little more familiar with stuff because I did PCs for 25 years and used to be a tech for a Gateway outsource company. If you're really familiar with Windoze, you'll first have to think what you want to do and then translate that to the IMac way of doing things. However, this is worth it. If you don't have a lot of experience with PCs, a Mac is much easier to learn.

Graphics, well, I'm not sure PCs will ever get graphics like IMacs.

It's not a straightforward conversion to IMacs, but it's worth it.

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#10

Mostly Agree

David Yoho

I must agree with almost all that's been said here about Macs. My son, being a graphic designer and Web developer, uses a Mac at work and has two here. Since the day he got his Intel-based 17" MacBook Pro, I've seen first hand how well behaved a Mac is. The Mac OS is what sets it apart from a Windows-based machine and is truly the heart of why a Mac out performs a PC. Now my son uses a 27" IMac here and with its HD screen, it's amazing how great things look on it.

As to the statement that you're not sure PCs will ever get graphics like IMacs, I must disagree. It's entirely possible to get graphics as good as on a Mac on a PC provided a high quality graphics card and a very high end monitor is used. Based on the ATI graphics card and the high end monitor in his IMac, there's nothing there that's proprietary. In fact most of the hardware in a modern Mac is pretty much the same as found in many PCs. And let's not forget, God forbid, any Intel-based Mac can run Windows. I don't think I would but it's an option.

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#11

Re: Time for a new new computer?  OT

Walt Smith

IMO there are two classes of PC's--consumer class and business class. Comparing $399 BestBuy/Staples machines to $1000 business class machines is like comparing a Harbor Freight bandsaw to a MiniMax and expecting the same result. I think building your own using quality components can still cost effective. No, I can't build my own including the Microsoft tax for $399, but I can build my own for not that much more and maybe end up with a more stable longer lasting machine. I'm typing this on a machine I assembled in around 2005 running Ubuntu Linux and it does everything I need it to do. It has had a hard drive upgrade but not due to failure. If I were going to buy an assembled machine, I'd look for a local shop that's been in business for a while. "beige boxes" may be derided but if quality components are used and there isn't a bunch of crapware installed, they can still be competitive. I'd know where to go for tech support, and it wouldn't be India.

Re: Time for a new new computer? OT

#13

Re: Mostly Agree

Jerry Samsen

But iMACs do run windows. My iMac runs WindowsXP under Parallels for Mac. Works great and runs faster than my Lenovo work notebook.

Apple MACs are more secure than Windows PCs mostly because they are not under attack by hackers / virus writers. If MAC market share increases, they may present a bigger target that these bad guys go after.