Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

What do you think the chances are?

Posts

What do you think the chances are?

#1

What do you think the chances are?

Craig in Silverdale

I was just looking at the picture frame in the latest Fine woodworking. I have some scrap maple, although not thick enough for the base, will work well for everything else. The thought came to me of ripping it and gluing a strip of Plexiglas between the pieces. Then before finishing the wood, hit the plastic quickly with my torch to glaze the edges. Was thinking the parts should hold using super glue. Any thoughts on this? If it doesn't work, I still have fire wood. I'm going to sand the gloss off the plastic before glue up.

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: What do you think the chances are?

Moses Yoder

I would suggest experiemnting with a small piece before committing to it. In my experience I think the torch would burn the wood before it polishes the edge of the plastic.

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#3

Ellis Walentine

More info needed

Ellis Walentine

Craig, you've lost me. What picture frame?

Ellis

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#4

Re: More info needed

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Is it the "STANDING FRAME HAS TWO FACES" by Christian Becksvoort in issue #212?

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#5

Seems high risk, although it'd be interesting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I know precious little about the plastics - you might want to talk with a local plastics dealer. I think there are several ways to polish the edges, flame being only one of them. There may be a method that's less likely to result in an exciting shop event.

Acrylic and wood will likely have different expansion rates, and expand/contract for different reasons - temperature would have little impact on the wood, but a lot on the plastic, with the reverse for humidity. You should use a flexible glue for the joint, or some attachment method that will permit movement.

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#6

Yes, issue 212; pg 42

Craig in Silverdale

Moses was right about the wood burning before the plastic edge melted. Cut the rough edge off this morning and proceeded to burn the maple as I tried to head polish the plastic. Thought I could burn the maple to an even tone. I should think again. Then when I cut the burned edge off on the table saw, the plastic showed fracture marks. Apparently, the heat hardens the Plexiglas. The edge of the acrylic does get rather nice if I sand with 2000 grit paper, but not sure any stain or finish would hold with the wood sanded that smoothly. Perhaps this will be the one to sit on my desk, as a reminder of a seemingly great idea, not so great. But, wood working is a continual learning process. I now know several ideas not to try again. Thank you for the responses.

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#7

Ellis Walentine

Late to the discussion

Ellis Walentine

I looked all through the latest FW (#213, M/J '10) to no avail. Now, I see the frame you're (probably) talking about in issue #212, by Christian Becksvoort. No matter. The thing that I'm questioning is your notion of using acrylic sheet as a laminate for one of these pieces. Apart from the fact that it is a pretty tiny chunk of wood we're talking about here, Plexiglas requires a special glue to bond to wood. Acrylic cements PS30 and PS18 (one and three part products respectively) will do the trick, but regular wood glues and epoxies won't. You might have some luck with epoxy if you create a decent mechanical bond between the surfaces. I'm still not sure if it's the look that you're going for or what. Why not laminate a thin strip of wood in there?

Regarding flame polishing, you've already found out the answer to that question, and, yes, sanding to a high grit is the way to go. From there, you should be able to carefully buff the edges to a clear gloss with the appropriate buffing wheels and compounds. Don't count on any stain sticking to it though, and I'd go for a wipe-on finish that will stick to the wood but wipe off the plastic.

If you're that short on wood, c'mon over some afternoon and we can snooker some up for you in my shed. :)

Dunno if this helps...

Ellis

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#8

Re: Late to the discussion

Craig in Silverdale

Ellis, Thanks for the info on adhesives. I just thought of using the Plexiglas simply because I happened to have some sitting by the workbench when I was there. Not short on scraps at all, but I do appreciate the offer. Next time I'm in the area, I'll stop in. Your not TOO far from Seattle, right? I might try to buff the edge as you suggested. Now if I can just find my rouge.

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#9

FWIW, the current issue...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

#213 has a letter to the editor in it about that frame. The author of the letter, a certified picture framer, details some do's and dont's for the materials used in a frame. Might want to check that out.

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Acid free mat board is the key

Ellis Walentine

I looked at the original article when Joe steered me to issue #212, and immediately scanned the exploded view, hoping to figure out how much space had been left between the two pieces of glass for mats and art. (They didn't show or tell you, but rather left it to you to subtract the thickness of two pieces of double-strength glass from the width of the groove in the base of the frame.) Clearly, there isn't enough room in the remaining 1/8" space for a minimum of three pieces of mat board and two pieces of artwork, so my framing alarm went off, too, as Also, like the letter writer suggested, acid free (sometimes called archival) mat board is key to properly preserving the artwork, at least if you care about preserving it.

If I were to make that project, I'd first determine how much the total thickness of art and mats would be, and then add a little extra for a margin of safety when assembling.

Ellis

Ellis

Re: What do you think the chances are?

#11

Re: Sorry I think it's bad idea

Don Evans

Craig: Just cause you have it doesn't mean you should use it.

But I do want to warn you about burning it if it doesn't work out.

Never burn plastic, it's fumes are toxic.

I have a neigbor who after gathering leaves and putting them in plastic bags and tossed them in an open fire pit. Rapped the whole neighborhood up in black toxic smoke.

After a friendly discussion he will not repeat that mistake!

For anyone needing or wanting one here is link to a plastic suppier that I deal with:

www.usplastic.com

click on "sheet, rod" and check out "plastic bottles and labware for things we may be interested in. After "sheet, rod" you'll also find a button to find the special glues needed for acrylic SC125, this is to glue acrylic to acylic and another for poly, I think the poly one will also do acrylic so if gonna use both it may be best buy. Be sure to get applicators from them for this glue as it is just like water in viscosity.

I made a dust collector out of acrylic for my carving station but have to make another one with better design. Got all the material just haven't got the time so far...

Don