Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Function vs Art

Posts

Function vs Art

#1

Function vs Art

Dave Paine

Ellis had a recent survey about whether we consider our work to be functional or art.

I responded my work so far has been functional, but I try to include more artistic elements.

Example in the picture. A friend asked if I could create a Cribbage board, and provided a "Go-By" from a craftsman, David Levy. Nice looking board, and his website has more interesting pieces.

The function aspect is the required set of holes. Turned out the "Go-by" had non-standard holes. I drilled first set at 3/16in diameter, then bought the pins and found they are designed for "standard" 1/8-in holes. I preferred 3/16-in since the pin height felt better to me.

So I had to cut out the 3/16-in holes, and "patch" the board with pieces of bubinga.

Board is cherry with bubinga, black walnut, lacewood, hickory and padauk inlays.

End pieces are maple with rosewood accents.

The end knobs are pine and the only pieces stained. The pine beads have 3/8-in dowels inserted and cover the storage of the pins, which is 3/8in x 3in deep holes.

The friend liked this result better than the "Go-By".

Function vs art, you decide.


Re: Function vs Art

#2

Re: Function vs Art

FredD

My favorite card game and a great board to keep score.

Haven't played fce to face since it started being on the internet.

FredD

Re: Function vs Art

#3

Ellis Walentine

Re: Function vs Art

Ellis Walentine

Looks like functional art to me, Dave. Nice job.

The point I tried to make about function vs art was not that everything you make is one or the other. Even pure art has the function of engaging the viewer. Functional objects, for their part, can be artfully made or not, which is a more subjective judgment than whether or not they fulfill their functional requirements.

My contention, which met with varying acceptance as most art/craft discussions do. My idea is that woodworking is a part of a larger enterprise of problem solving. The problem can be some purely functional objective or it might be purely artistic -- or some combination of the two -- but it may also involve other skills and media, as when you build a cabinet with glass shelves and a slate top, maybe with some electronic component. I thought about this all the time when I was doing architectural interior work, as my chore as the designer of all this stuff was to incorporate anything that was necessary to 1) solve the functional mission, 2) satisfy the aesthetic requirements, and 3) meet the customer's budget expectations. In a smaller sense, even if you are building something only for you, you are the customer for that piece and you impose your own expectations and cost constraints on the work.

When you design a cribbage board, you naturally want it to be more than a piece of 1x4 with a bunch of holes in it, so aesthetics enters the picture. Your decision to go with the 3/16-in-dia pins was a design decision you made based on the feel of the pin height, another aesthetic (tactual, in this case) issue. And, you chose complimentary woods that please the eye and make the game more enjoyable for the participants. So, your solution is a pleasant combination of art and function.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Function vs Art

#4

Either way, beautiful....I want to know

Barry Irby

How you drilled the holes. I am completing a deck rail that required over a hundred pairs of even spaces holes. Not even close to the scale a precision of the holes in this board, so how did you do it?

Gorgeous work and it brings back memories of playing cribbage with my Dad when I was about ten.

Re: Function vs Art

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Either way, beautiful....I want to know

Moses Yoder

If I needed to drill holes for a cribbage board I would simply make a drawing and send it out to our cnc router :D

Re: Function vs Art

#6

Re: Either way, beautiful....I want to know *LINK*

Dave Paine

Barry,

Practice helps. I ended up drilling the holes three times. First time was with pieces of black walnut, the original design. Lots of tearout and not as consistent as I wanted.

Second time was with the cherry, I improved consistency, but had tearout. I then realised the drill press was set on a speed (580 rpm) which was far too slow.

Third time was the charm. No tearout and better consistency.

For this project I used a fence on the drill press to give a consistent offset.

I used the green 3M tape so I could mark out the holes. I used my Incra rule, the type with slots cut at exact intervals for use with a mechanical pencil. I lined up one mark, made the other marks, moved the rule, etc.

I then followed up with a bradawl (not sure of US name) to make a small hole at the intersection of the offset and each increment.

I set the fence to match the offset, and then moved the board to line up the point on the drill to be over the bradawl mark.

End results look good, but not as perfect as CNC, but this is to be expected with such manual work.

For your deck, I do not think you need the same attempt at this precision. I think you will be using 3in or 4in spacing, so 1/8in out will not make any difference. You need the top and bottom to be consistent.

I like your idea of drilling a hole and then ripping the piece. Feels like the best approach for the top and bottom to match.

For you size of project, perhaps a jig like the Lee Valley one in the link. I have this item and would use it for a larger scale piece. Works well so far.

Alternate is to create wooden jig with scrap pieces spaced at lumber thickness and plywood glued on top, the drill two holes on top. In one place a piece of dowel to be used to place in first hole and define placement of next hole. Works well, although drill hole may enlarge over time. This is why I prefer steel bushings.

Good luck.


Drilling jig

Re: Function vs Art

#7

Re: Either way, beautiful....I want to know

Barry Irby

I agree that I needed no where near the accuracy to drill a deck rail as you did to drill the cribbage board. An 1/8 may have been a bit sloppy and I had to guard against repetitive or accumulating error, but nothing like what you did. I ended up using a piece of peg board. Nailed a fence on it and clamped the two pieces side by side with a half inch spacer between them to allow centering a row of holes holes over each piece. Then I used a self centering bit to mark a pilot hole in each rail piece. Basically just punched an 1/8" hole about an 1/8" deep every four inches. Then I drilled 9/16" holes at each location with a spade bit. Eyeballed them. Drilled through the top piece and about 5/8" into the bottom piece.

For what you did, I would have ripped some scraps and made a bunch of shims. With a fence and a stop block on the DP, I would have drilled the first hole and then inserted a shim at the stop, drilled the second hole and inserted another shim. When I reached the end of the first group, I would have inserted a thicker shim. and started the second group. For the second row of holes I would have put a shim between the workpiece and the fence and repeated the whole process. It would be faster to do than to describe.

Where did you get the pins? Now that I think about it, I might try to make a cribbage board.

Re: Function vs Art

#8

Re: Either way, beautiful....I want to know *LINK*

Dave Paine

Barry, good example to illustrate more than one way to solve a problem.

The pins are available at many locations. I did a Google search and got many hits. Places sell games and parts for games.

I happened to be needing some supplies from Lee Valley and they happen to sell the pins, so I did not have to make a few $ order and pay almost as much shipping.

Link attached. Good luck if you decide to make a board.


http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=32777&cat=1,250,43313