Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Cherry table top question

Posts

Cherry table top question

#1

Cherry table top question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

I am making a cherry end table. Similar to what Christian Becksvoort did in FWW #210 with turned legs.

The top will be about 16" wide by 24" long. I have a nice clear 4/4 cherry board that is about 15" wide by about 10' long. It's been sitting in my (basement) shop for about 4 years. I should be able to get just about all parts (less the legs) from this board.

For the top, would it be best to mill two 8" x 24" boards and glue them together for the top, or would it be better to mill 4 4" x 24" and glue those up? If I do the 4 pieces I would match the grain attempting to hide the fact that the 8" piece was ripped.

I guess I am concerned about keeping it flat. Normally I have narrower boards that I arrange for look opposed to alternating growth rings and so on.

So, should I do 2 8" pieces, or 4 4" pieces?

Thanks for any suggestions.

Re: Cherry table top question

#2

Re: Cherry table top question

paul in AZ

Joe:

I have built several cherry tops like you describe. None have shown any tendency to misbehave.

For my money I think it doesn't matter which option you choose.

Me... I'd go with the wider boards simply because there is less jointing and gluing up.

Re: Cherry table top question

#3

Re: Cherry table top question

DouginDenver

Personally I'd go with 2. Cupping should not be a big issue with a 16 inch table unless there are no aprons to hold it flat - but even then I think you are ok. What about a 15" wide table and one board?

Re: Cherry table top question

#4

Re: Cherry table top question

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Joe,

By this time the cherry should be very stable. I would seal/finish both sides of the single piece and use that, especially if were to rest on a bottom frame with ample regard for seasonal wood movement. If it ever should cup, I'd then rip it in half, joint, glue-up and refinish.

George

Re: Cherry table top question

#5

Re: Cherry table top question

Mark Salomon

Two boards will make the top look static; you'll get a better top if you rip and use three boards.

Re: Cherry table top question

#6

Lee Grindinger

No glue joints

Lee Grindinger

If you can process the board full width I'd reduce the width of the base so the top could be used without ripping and gluing. The base structure will keep the top flat if it's attached allowing for movement.

Remember this, homes did not have such extensive climate control when much of the "best" advice was formulated concerning ripping and gluing tops. Since most homes don't range nearly as far as they did 25 years ago wood movement has become less of an issue and the techniques I was taught 30 years ago (rip, reverse and glue) have largely been abandoned by contemporary woodworkers like Tage Frid (R.I.P.) and others.

Lee

Re: Cherry table top question

#7

Re: Cherry table top question

del schisler

if you can get it plane down or it may be all ready be Why not make it 15" No cutting Just a nice one board Under the top you can put a few strip's up right not flat that is where you would get the most strength You could glue plus screw Than i don't belive it will cup any If it hasn't cup by now I dont' belive it will i belive you would be all right but i would do the board's on the bottom

Re: Cherry table top question

#8

Re: Cherry table top question

Jesse Cloud

I think making a 15 inch table is the best advice among all the good advice above.

If you have some type of mechanical fastener (buttons, z-clip, etc) between the apron and the top, there should be no concern with cupping.

BTW, 99% probability you already thought of this, but if you are gluing up multiple pieces and want a 24 inch top, mill the pieces a couple of inches longer to allow for trimming the ends.

Re: Cherry table top question

#9

Re: No glue joints

FredD

I agree with Lee on using one board ad I would take it one step further.

I would apply the finish equally on all sides and ends before I fastened it to the Apron, to see if if the board developed a tendency to cup and I would not use a water base sealer or finish.

I also have read some of Tage Frid's stuff and he specifically said he picked boards for appearance , regardless of whether that alternated the end grain and on glued up wide panels he started fastening at one edge and moved across the width ,thereby rolling the top down as he went if it was cupped.

FredD

Re: Cherry table top question

#10

3 times 6 Works Too

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I chose to rip and reglue as I needed 18" width and my jointer is only 6". In this case it worked out quite well because I used the remaining board to build the drawer fronts etc. and thus carry the rippled grain over the table edge.

Re: Cherry table top question

#11

the bottom line......

Bill Tindall

Do what ever looks best considering the lumber you have at hand.

If I could not do the top in one attractive piece then I would see if I could find two pieces that would approximately "book match." Your wide piece will have a rift or quartered grain on its edges which might be easy to match with an additional piece. If the top must be 16", I would consider seeing if I could glue a 1" or two 1/2" pieces that would result in a non-obvious joint and yield a 16" top. I have not had this approach work out very often, but it works often enough to consider.

Cupping never has been a relevant issue unless the the lumber wasn't dry to begin with or the "antique" table got sent to the chicken pen for a time where it got rained on before being rescued for restoration. My favorite example of the use of a wide domestic board is a piece in Pleasant Hill , KY that has a nearly 2' wide x about 8' long walnut board for a side.

Re: Cherry table top question

#12

Re: Cherry table top question

Paul Vander Woude

I would use a single 2" by 8" board, and re-saw it, so that the two resulting 1" boards are book-matched. Cherry is pretty stable, and the fasteners you use to attach it to the apron will help hold it flat.