Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

Posts

OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

#1

OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

Brian in Brighton

As we all see the pictures of the newly cut pipe something came to mind. WHY can't they undo the flange bolts just below the cut and put a new flanged pipe on it? Surely that must have torque amplifiers to loosen the bolts, or cut them off.

Am I just stupid to see something this obvious?

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

#2

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I had been thinking the same thing the other day. Also, I have been wondering for a long time why they didn't just use some big hydraulic pincher to just crimp the pipe. They should have done that on day one or two.

I can't believe it took them this long. If they can sheer it off, they should have been able to pinch the pipe flat in the beginning.

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

#3

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Jame Cameron- Avatar, Titanic, etc., offered his (considerable) expertise and world-wide deep diving and photograpy contacts- BP said "No thanks, we've got it." Cameron called them idiots!

I agree about the flange and bolts.

Another possibly quicker way might have been to insert a smaller diameter probe that has a cable and/or pulley attached to it, right into the spewing pipe. The probe would be designed to grip or expand and wedge itself inside the existing pipe. The cable would then be used to pull, guide and install a secondary valve assembly on top of the old one. Once the new valve is securely in place, remove the cable and close the valve.

I have few other ideas too!

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

#4

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Alan, sounds like a very dooable task which would work. I know a little about pipework...having been in the pipetrades for 35yrs before retirement.

What I really want to know about is that "Blow-out Preventer"what does it do, how is it supposed to do its work...and....what went wrong with it.

I personally think the oil companies, drilling companies should NOT be allowed to do any drilling and exploring for oil under any circumstances UNLESS they have POSITIVE solutions for such a blow-out.

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

Moses Yoder

I am not sure what the pressure is on the pipe, but I heard 15,000 pounds per square inch. I don't think you can crimp a pipe shut and have it hold under that pressure. I am getting a little tired of all the people who think they are so much smarter than all of these oil drilling experts that are doing everything they can to stop the leak. So far as taking the pipe off at the flange and fastening another pipe on, once again we are talking about extreme high pressures a mile under the ocean; I would like to see someone attempt that, it would be entertaining for months. If you set a bulldozer on top of the pipe the pressure from the oil would simply blow the bulldozer up into the ocean.

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

#7

Re: OT Pipe replacement, am I missing something?

Barry Irby

Moses, I tend to agree with you that most of us don't have a clue and some of our ideas are pretty hair brained.

But we are talking about suggestions to a company that that put a non functional blowout preventer on a well a mile deep. I doubt WE will ever know why it did not work, but the fact remains, it didn't. Seems to me they should have tested it and assured themselves they were ready. Or perhaps there should have been a little redundancy.

I have to admit I am vastly impressed with the deep sea ROVs. I had no idea they had a device that could handle a set of shears big enough to snip off a 20" diameter pipe. On the other hand, this is what they do for a living and they should have the tools to do it with and a plan for when it goes wrong.

If they can thread a "top hat" over that pipe and clamp it on, Why would it be so hard to believe they could install another flange? Obviously they don't want to do that, but they haven't told us why. We don't need to know why, we just need to watch them do the magic.

And I know nothing about the pressure, but that does not look like a 15,000 psi stream of fluid to me. Perhaps that's because the surround water is at tremendous pressure from being a mile deep. OTOH It seems to me that you would only need to worry about the Difference in the pressure. If the water is at 5000 psi and the oil is at 4999, it would still come out, but you would only have to deal with that little differential.