Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT Contractors what is with them?

Posts

OT Contractors what is with them?

#1

OT Contractors what is with them?

Dustmaker Mike

OK I might not be building an apartment complex or a Wal-Mart, but I do expect to get at least an estimate back. I have contacted 4 local recommended contractors to do some concrete work. Depending on the cost of the concrete work I am going to be building a shop a front porch and extend the garage out the front so I can park my truck in it and still walk around it. I cannot get a permit until I know what I can do and I cannot figure out what I can do until I get the concrete estimate. Not a one has returned my call after doing the measuring and promising they will get me an estimate in two weeks. It has been well over 4 weeks on the last one and 6 weeks from the first one. So I guess they are not really hurting as bad as we have been led to believe.

I have another two names to contact today wish me luck.

Rant off

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#2

I dunno

Neal in San Jose

Speaking as a contractor - I was one for 13 years - I don't know why many of them operate that way. I got MANY of my jobs because I was the only one to get back with a bid. My SOP was to simply to sit in my truck after the site visit and do most of the figuring right on the spot. That way, if I missed anything, I could simply go back and knock on the door and revisit. The client was usually thundersruck and happy to help.

Then, when I got back to the office (spare bedroom), I'd make any phone calls I needed to, check prices on special items and write it up. I had a personal goal of all bids complete AND DELEVERED in 24 hours. It was not unusual to get a deposit check when I delivered the bid, simply because of what you are talking about. No one else had even bothered to call on the phone.

What I am saying is keep looking. There are good ones out there.

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#3

Good strategy Neal...

John in NM

Basically never put off until tomorrow what you can do right now. I believe every single one of my co-workers could learn something from that, especially the Flakey-Waffle-Man who's in charge!

What you understand that so many others do not - if you put it off until tomorrow, it will likely be forgotten tomorrow as well.

Keep looking for bids Mike, those guys who don't bother to put together a bid and send it to you are the same one's who're afraid of committing to a price because they'd have to stick to it. They usually don't understand how to estimate or plan, and probably also can't get a slab flat or make up square form work! Hard to have to keep looking when you're on a tight schedule, but it'll be worth it to get a good contractor.

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#4

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I had the same problem several years ago when we decided to replace 20+ windows, the siding and the roofing on our house. We contacted 6-7 contractors at a local home show and filled out their inquiry forms listing what we wanted done. Three actually called two came to the house one gave us a bid. It was $22,000 worth of work. During the home show the local television station did interviews with several of the contractors that we spoke with (and did not even call us) who whined about how slow the building trade was.

Lee

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#5

same problem with new heat pump

John Lucas

I called everyplace in town. Only 3 called me back, 2 sent estimates and one actually came to visit with the estimate. Guess who got the job.

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: My take on it is this:........

Jesper, Denmark

If they can't be bothered to be reasonably reliable when there is a chance of getting a project, what would they do once thay had your down payment and needed to show up and work?

Keep looking.......

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#7

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

John E in SC

I feel your pain. I self-contracted the building of my house about 6-7 years ago. There were 2-3 subcontractors I dealt with during that process that were a pleasure to deal with, but more than that who were just jerks. Had a guy putting up the Hardiplank siding one Saturday morning while I was also out working on the house. About 10 am, I talked with him, and told him when he finished the back part of the house (where he was currently working), I would give him a check for $2000. (Fortunately, I had the foresight to pay him along as he finished the job.) He assured me that he would finish that part by that afternoon, and I mentioned that I had my checkbook with me, and write him a check. Well, it wasn't 30 minutes later, I see his truck going up the drive. "Must be running to get something" I thought. Well, he never returned! It was almost 4 WEEKS later when the yahoo finally came back to finish the job! This of course was after multiple unreturned phone calls, and I had been looking hard for someone else to finish the job so I could fire the SOB, but hadn't been able to find anyone. I could not (and still can't) understand what kind of man couldn't finish a 1/2 days work to get paid $2000.

I often threatened to my wife to quit my "real" job and become a contractor just so I could prove that it could be done the right way. I still think that no matter the economy, anyone who wants to work, has half a brain, and can be courteous, would have no problem making a living in construction, because they would automatically be better than 90% of their competition.

Whew, that picked the scab off an old wound, didn't it!?

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#8

Boom & Bust

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

4 years ago the opposite would have been true because you had scores of "contractors" from which to choose. 80% of them were "trunk-monkeys," but all were chasing the housing boom dollars that flowed free and fast. The good guys were shaking their heads with little work because they were getting killed with low bids by the "transients."

Now, after the bust and with tight money, the one-man bands and handy-man "Doctors" have gone leaving all the work for the guys from the original 20% who weathered the storm and survived. Problem is now that the really skilled operators are swamped with work, and have to do a kind of triage operation. Since all you've asked for is the concrete work (rather than the whole job), you're likely to get put on the bottom of the list because there's much more profit/per/manhour in framing and finish work than there is in just pouring mud. Plus, the masons that have survived have done so by hooking up with the remaining builders.

You may also find that there are more than a few masons who don't want to deal directly with homeowners, preferring instead to work as subs for a GC. It sounds a bit like you were asking these guys what you "could" do rather than presenting them with a set plan and asking for a job bid with fully pre-defined specs. That's another way to have your number "lost" as they don't want to be held to statements and estimates that get changed later with a homeowner coming back to them with "But YOU said . . .!"

This is why I and six friends formed a self-help group for our homes. Decks, additions, renovations, we do as a group. Haven't tried a full structure build, but with the skills developed over the past 15 years, I have little doubt we could pull it off. What we don't do, namely excavation and foundation work, we sub out on detailed plans and specs. We pay fast, and have no trouble getting bids.

Suggest you have a sit-down with your building department guy, with at least a rough plan of your property and proposal and see what he says. Most are willing to do that for homeowners. You'll make some mods and then be able to work up plans that will give your masons details to work from, so you'll be more likely (but not guaranteed) to get some meaningful responses.

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#9

Weeeeeeeeeeell . . .

steve mackay

just remember those are the ones you DON'T want working for you any way. If they can't show up with an estimate they darn sure weren't going to show up to work. You might have dodged a couple bullets there. I know the good ones are out there and they're worth waiting for. Hang in there !

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#10

Re: Boom & Bust

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

I totally agree with a lot of the guys have said about waiting to get the right contractor. Mark said it best....the ones that were around just to get the almighty dollar and scoot before the job was completed...those are not to be even considered. On TV is a show with Mike Holmes who is doing repair work on homes that those sloppy"contractors"...handymen...did and fouled up the entire projects. Mike, do as the man said and talk to your own building inspectors office and get their imput... and get a set Plans drawn up...then seek an estimate from long established businesses....not the handymen types.

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#11

I have plans for

Dustmaker Mike

two different ways to do the job. I have the carpenter framer etc. What I don't have is a concrete contractor. They show up take all the measurements and leave promising I will here from them and I never do. Believe me I will not hire one that can not give me an estimate. I have talked to a few of the bigger company's around here and have one showing up next week. As for the permit I just need to know which set of plans I can afford to do. Then I will get the correct permit.

Thanks

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#12

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

FredD

Mike , welcome to the sometimes frustrating world of construction .

What Neal said about giving a client a fast estimate was always the way I did , unless it was a large addition requiring a building designer.

Some of what Mark says about the good responsible Contractors being swamped with work is more what your going to find in you addition and because it has Concrete flatwork , you will be on a list of any good Cement Mason for longer then you think is reasonable.

If I were you and didn't know any of the trades people , check with your local ready mix plant and/or your Framer who should know.

Because it is primarily Flatwork , any contractor already knows the going rate and the measuring and cost calcs are the easy part , getting the right guy will always mean your on his schedule , not yours.

Around here there are only about three guys I would let near a concrete job and they are booked , all of the time.

FredD

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#13

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

FredD

In addition to what I have stated , you will find that your job with a already busy and competent Mason will put you behind any of his repeat General Contractor clients who commands his attention more then short order work will from a one time client.

But don't give up , find the best recommended people , tell them you know they have a schedule and are willing to adapt to it, they then will be more forth coming about giving you cost calcs and a start date if your willing to wait.

Give them some facts about your life , tell them you travel worldwide in your job and this Summer is your only shot at the job.

Last thing to remember, a Concrete job badly done is a nightmare.

FredD

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#14

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

Stuart Johnson

When I had my shop built I don't know how many contractors. I was interested in a having the slab done and the 30x40 metal building erected. I had 4 willing to come and give me an estimate and set up appointments. I had zero show up. I finally found a firm that specialized in steel buildings. The slab was done by the guys father in law. I thought the bid for the slab was high so they said they would get another one. Ten whole dollars difference. The slab seems to be well done and the building is up but if I was giving out a grade it would be a C. Several leaks and some type of gasket stuff wasn't installed properly. After four calls and promises to come check it out I gave up. The contractor doesn't care about a satisfied customer for small jobs.

I had two contractors (builder and electrical) lined up to do a garage conversion. I had worked with the electrical before and he recommended the builder. When we were in the middle of the estimate process Hurricane Ike hit. Both called me and said they were going to have to pull out of any deal or wait for several months. They were up front about taking my $5,000 job or a $500,000 plus ongoing job down in Houston. I have recommended the electrician to others. I don't have any experience with the builder so can't really give a reference.

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

#15

Re: OT Contractors what is with them?

Brian in SLO

When I built the additions on our house I got so frustrated with contractors I just decided to do what I could myself. That means learning about lots of things that may be new to you. Looking up building codes, getting permits, learning, learning and more learning. I found a contractor willing to work with me and he was impressed with what I was able to accomplish. Learn about a section, build it have the local building inspector come sign-off and on to the next stage. Electrical, done. Plumbing, done. Siding and roofing, etc.

I now consider myself quite capable of home electrical, framing and a darn good drywaller (that one took some time to get good at) and quite few others. My wife even lets me know I can stick around now that I've become so handy around the house.

Granted, there some things you won't have any choice but to find a contractor. But the rest, learn by doing!