Boom & Bust
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
4 years ago the opposite would have been true because you had scores of "contractors" from which to choose. 80% of them were "trunk-monkeys," but all were chasing the housing boom dollars that flowed free and fast. The good guys were shaking their heads with little work because they were getting killed with low bids by the "transients."
Now, after the bust and with tight money, the one-man bands and handy-man "Doctors" have gone leaving all the work for the guys from the original 20% who weathered the storm and survived. Problem is now that the really skilled operators are swamped with work, and have to do a kind of triage operation. Since all you've asked for is the concrete work (rather than the whole job), you're likely to get put on the bottom of the list because there's much more profit/per/manhour in framing and finish work than there is in just pouring mud. Plus, the masons that have survived have done so by hooking up with the remaining builders.
You may also find that there are more than a few masons who don't want to deal directly with homeowners, preferring instead to work as subs for a GC. It sounds a bit like you were asking these guys what you "could" do rather than presenting them with a set plan and asking for a job bid with fully pre-defined specs. That's another way to have your number "lost" as they don't want to be held to statements and estimates that get changed later with a homeowner coming back to them with "But YOU said . . .!"
This is why I and six friends formed a self-help group for our homes. Decks, additions, renovations, we do as a group. Haven't tried a full structure build, but with the skills developed over the past 15 years, I have little doubt we could pull it off. What we don't do, namely excavation and foundation work, we sub out on detailed plans and specs. We pay fast, and have no trouble getting bids.
Suggest you have a sit-down with your building department guy, with at least a rough plan of your property and proposal and see what he says. Most are willing to do that for homeowners. You'll make some mods and then be able to work up plans that will give your masons details to work from, so you'll be more likely (but not guaranteed) to get some meaningful responses.