Circles
Doug Ridley
What is the best way to cut a perfect 9 1/2" circle on the band saw? I was thinking of a small hole 43/4" from the blade and using a nail thru my piece as a pivot.
Ideas and suggestions please.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Circles
Doug Ridley
What is the best way to cut a perfect 9 1/2" circle on the band saw? I was thinking of a small hole 43/4" from the blade and using a nail thru my piece as a pivot.
Ideas and suggestions please.
Re: Circles
John Veerkamp
Doug
That is the basic circle cutting technique. Works fine.
John
Re: Circles
Doug Ridley
Thanks, John. That's what I thought but as I have never cut many circles after all these years I wondered if somebody had a different method.
Re: Circles *LINK*
del schisler
you can do it with a Plung router and spirel bit here is the web site This if you are going to cut lot's and just want to buy a jig I have this one They have one that will fit all router's
http://us.oak-park.com/catalogue.html?list=JIGS--&product=J091
Re: Circles
Doug Ridley
Thanks Del. Don't have a plunge router and just need the one circle so I reckon I'd better stick with the bandsaw.
Re: Circles
Dick Coers
Depends on how perfect the circle needs to be. Starting the cut is the tough part on the bandsaw. Woodworker's Supply makes a jig that slides in the miter slot as you start the cut. You hit a stop, then start rotating the piece. This lets you use an oversize blank and make a continuous cut. If you start on a nail, you may have a small flat where you start and stop the cut.
Re: Circles
Barry Irby
I think you are on the right track. I have done a few. I tend to leave a half inch blade on my BS all the time as the sort of universal blade, but I think for this job you need a narrower blade, maybe a 1/4".
What I did was set up a piece of plywood with a runner on the bottom that would slide into the slot on the BS table. Drilled a hole in it for the pivot and a similar hole in the work piece. Then put the work pace over the pin and slide the jig into the slot and advance it until the blade is aligned with the center of the pin. Then rotate the work piece. (This allows you to cut into the workpiece as you start.)
Hard to describe this, but the leading edge of the teeth must be "lined up" with the pivot. The cut should occur where a radius line intersects the tangent. There might be a little play in this, depending on how your blade cuts, but it needs to be pretty close.
I was cutting bowl blanks and they were thick and green, tended to bind and make the blade want to wander, not a good thing.
I made a circle cutting jig with two rows of holes. One row was set up to the tangent (or whatever) to the blade when the front edge of the jig lined up with the leading edge of the table and the other row with the back edge of the jig lined up with the trailing edge. Most of the time, I would just slide the assemble into place and hole it with one hand and turn the work piece with the other. You can clamp it is you have room and you can put stop block on the bottom if you need to.
And the other consideration is how per perfect is perfect. You can cut a flat spot on the piece or sett eh pivot to be 4 3/4" from the edge and then set up the jig and put the piece on it and then turn on the saw, but I found that left a flat spot on the edge of the piece.
You can also do this with a trammel point on a router or on a lathe.
Yep, and then...
Ellis Walentine
... take your plywood base with the nail and your bandsawn circle to the disk sander to clean up the sawn edge and fair the circle perfectly.
Ellis
Re: Circles
John Lucas
That works perfectly if you make a sliding table with a stop that centers the cutting tip of the blade with the center of the circle. I cut out 30 circles for our Tuba Ensemble to assemble into Tuba Mutes. These had a slight angle to the sides to match the taper of the mute but the circles were perfect.
Perfect Circle key set up
Lee Schierer McKean, PA
A circle cutting jig like the one from woodcraft works very well. However, one key that is not well defined in the instructions is that the front edge of the blade teeth need to be perfectly aligned with the center of rotation point on the jig. If they are very much ahead or behind that point the blade will wander off the true circle cut line, cutting a spiral path and eventually bind.
Lee
Re: Check the archives 4/26/2008
I cannot find my original posting, but Shaver does it so well.
Tuba mutes????
Ellis Walentine
I knew you had done nearly everything, John, but in a million years I wouldn't have guessed you were in a Tuba Ensemble, or that there's a market for shop made tuba mutes.
Never a dull moment around here....
Ellis
Re: Circles
steve mackay
Rough it out on the band saw then tweek it on the bench sander. "No-fail".
Probably not easy to find
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Trumpet, trombone, sure; but I can't imagine the market for tuba mutes is very large. And it wouldn't be easy finding big enough plumber's helpers, not to mention that the players would need either spider-like arms or a helper to use that approach. I'm a little surprised that plywood worked; I wouldn't expect it to have the right resonance.
Takes me back...when I played trombone about a million years ago (just after they stopped making trombones from woolly mammoth tusks), there were several different forms of mute, each with its own sound. Playing with a mute changes the pitch of the instrument, up to about a half-tone but not consistently (varies from mute to mute), so you had to learn how to compensate. Easier for us slide players than for the trumpeters, because you could just move the slide a bit until the note was right. And they restrict volume, so you had to blow harder, which itself affects both tone and pitch. But SUCH a cool sound; I really understand why Miles Davis went through that period when he played exclusively with a mute.
Re: Probably not easy to find
Doug Ridley
Thanks for the help. I got it done and got a very good job.