Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Your government at work.

Posts

Your government at work.

#1

Your government at work.

FredD

Get to that in a minute, the new issue of WoodShopNews letters to the Editor is titled this month "Readers have plenty to say about Ryobi Verdict" and it aint pretty.

A good review of all of the Compound miter Saws .

A humongous fan for shops called a "Shop Fan" by it's maker,this dude is 12 feet in diameter, weighs only 140 pounds and has to be at least 14 feet off of the floor.

It's manufacturer name would you believe, is BigAss Fan Company in Lexington ,Kentucky. WWW.BIGASSFANS.COM

Now if you think the Ryobi verdict in favor of having everybody buy Flesh detection technology is intrusive wait until you check out what the EPA has in store for Home Rennovation, Contractors , Door and Window companies and you.

They have proposed a new rule about lead content in existing Pre-1978 houses and Commercial buildings that will add 40 million additional homes to the already existing 38 million that will require any company that works on housing to get certification for the company and it's workers at a estimated cost of 300.00 per worker and company if......more then six square feet of paint is disturbed on the interior or a door or window is changed.

The exterior , same rule applies when 20 or more square feet is disturbed and or a window or door change.

Starting late in April the Government has allowed 60 days for public comment, not much time left folk.

Naturally this new requirement of nightmarish proportions hasn't addressed the logistics of training thousands of new inspectors or allowed for the havoc that adding 15 percent to the cost of a average remodel job or the numbers of Home owners who will opt to fore go professional builders and remodelers, so they can afford to try and do it their selves.

This is applied to the homes that so far have been exempted if there were no children six years or less in age or a pregnant Woman.

Check it out.

www.epa.gov/lead/new.htm

www.nari.org or

www.wdma.com

FredD

Re: Your government at work.

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Your government at work.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Proposed?

The EPA RRP (Renovation, Repair and Painting) rule went into effect 4/22/10.

It's also 6 s.f. of paint disturbed per interior room, not just for the whole interior.

I just LOVE how government agencies that have very little representative oversight get to make laws...uhh...I mean rules. Especially this particular one, which apparently doesn't seem to have enough on its plate--or in its ocean--right now. :\

Jason

Re: Your government at work.

#3

A wise man once said....

Stuart Hough

Stupid is as Stupid does!

Re: Your government at work.

#4

I had rule I followed

Terry Quiram

when I was still working. It concerned design critique on new projects.

"Beware the power of large groups of stupid people"

Re: Your government at work.

#5

Make up your mind

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Rant on. Seems the government can't win; it either does too much or too little, depending on the point you want to make. Lead is toxic and needs to be taken seriously. An under-water oil gusher needs to be taken seriously, too. So why is it that the government is apparently composed of stupid people while the rest of us are just so effing smart? We want a government that never gets it our way but protects us from all dangers, foreign and domestic. I guess I'm just tired of all the carping, complaining, whining and unreasonable expectations. Rant off.

Re: Your government at work.

#6

Re: Your government at work.

FredD

If the article has got the info correct, the proposed rule is open to public comment for sixty day , counting from late April.

This short notice to the public seems like a underhanded method of complying with the Public notice requirement to me.

FredD

Re: Your government at work.

#7

Re: Make up your mind

FredD

The EPA rightly addressed the Health Hazard of Lead paint for small children a long time ago and pregnant women.

This new rule now takes in all of the residences where only Adults and older children live, where formerly I believe the assumption was that Adults weren't prone to chew on Window sills, of course there is always a exception here and there.

In solving a problem that may not exist, the Government creates one for the economic sector composed of homeowners , contractors, painters, Window and door companies and lack of code enforcement and inspector training that will add to the long lead time of when you apply for a construction or remodel permit and actually get the project wrapped.

This is not a good use of the EPA power to regulate, especially when there are Toxic sites all over the country like Libby , Montana that just lay there , killing people and is a real problem , not a theoretical one.

FredD

Re: Your government at work.

#8

Don't know a lot on this subject

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but this proposed standard is about disturbing existing paint surfaces, yes? If existing lead paint is disturbed and not cleaned up right, doesn't that leave lead dust scattered around for the residents or visiting small children to take in by hand contact and/or breathing?

Re: Your government at work.

#9

Re: Don't know a lot on this subject

R Payne

That is a theoretical possibility. So the question becomes: in the real world, how much paint needs to be "disturbed" and not cleaned up properly to create the potential for toxic exposure?

ron

Re: Your government at work.

#10

What's the normal notice period?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I wonder what the normal notice period is? In doing a very short amount of googling, I find notice periods as short as 30 days and others that appear to be 60 days; and still others that have been extended for periods of time, presumably based upon the vigor of public reaction. Maybe there are times when longer periods are set up front; I don't know.

I worked at a (public) university for 30 years, and am well aware of the value of involvement by the people affected in policy development; it leads to better policy when done well. But open-ended consultation leads to stasis. If this has been identified as a public health issue, at some point, policy is necessary.

Re: Your government at work.

#11

Re: What's the normal notice period?

FredD

Here is a direct quotation from WoodShopNews concerning the public comment period.

"In late April, the EPA proposed two amendments to the rule are open to 60 days of Public comment.

The first requires dust wipe testing for completed renovations. The second applies lead-safe work practices and training requirements to Public and Commercial buildings.

The amendments could take effect in 2011 and 2013 , respectively."

Taddei (a spokesman for the NARI) says "the NARI will closely monitor further rule amendments and open comment periods through its Government affairs committee."

Read this link Bill , it explains further and better the effects of the rule on industry and homeowners.

www.nari.org

FredD

Re: Your government at work.

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Just to clarify...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The RRP rule went into effect 4/22/10 as I stated before: http://www.epa.gov/lead/pubs/renovation.htm> Right now, there are proposed amendments to that rule that would extend the requirements to commercial buildings and non-child occupied dwellings as others stated.

There's no question that high levels of lead in the blood are toxic, particularly in young children and pregnant women. There's no question that there is lots of lead paint on older homes that could be a potential problem. What is not a given is that said lead paint makes it into someone's blood stream from incidental contact with some paint chips that might get disturbed during minor remodeling (like changing a door or window or scraping an exterior).

Interestingly enough, the techniques outlined in Lead Safe Work Practices pretty much doom an exterior repaint to early failure. One of the best things you can do for long term adhesion of your primer in an area of peeling paint is to scrape off the loose paint, then SAND the bare wood and feather the edges of the remaining paint, then prime immediately before moisture gets into the freshly sanded wood and lifts the edges of the existing paint. Unfortunately, LSWP requires keeping the surface damp when sanding happens, so the edges of remaining paint will be a future failure point.

The EPA is not large enough to take on enforcement of this rule, so it will be the activists and nosy neighbors calling the EPA and making noise who cause any application of the rule. The bottom line is that the EPA makes it more expensive to conduct business in the U.S. It's one of the reasons many have farmed out manufacturing to other countries. Remodeling can't be farmed out...

Jason

Re: Your government at work.

#13

Re: Just to clarify...revisited

Brian in Brighton

Jason, Just to clarify with you that most of the manufacturing that has been farmed offshores is for a single reason------PROFIT. I've had the "pleasure" of working for companies that felt that the EPA regulations on dumping were unjust and costly, so they just dumped what they wanted on their own property. Too many companies have moved their manufacturing offshore because they can pay slave wages, avoid any enviromental regulations, avoid such intrusions such as fair wages, benefits, lunch breaks, sick days and a whole host of other things that would cause you and I to run away from a job here in the states. BUT, when you move a manufacturing plant to a small country and promise wages of $1-3 a day when the going rate is $0.50 you can get a whole lot of people to give up their safety in order to try to make a better life for their family. When you can convince a lot of ignorant folks of the dangers of the chemicals that work with, or grease the local politicians to look the other way, you can create an enviromental disaster. THEN the company closes shop when the problem is found out. What you should be peaved about is that the stuff being sold in the US isn't practically free after the costs of manufacturing drop 90% by offshoring.

So, when you want to whine about how the EPA is intruding too much, just remember that the EPA didn't just dream up the rules about how we woodworkers have to deal with the chemicals we use, they did it because someone's dad, or granddad suffered or died because he wanted a job and was told by the company that it's perfectly safe to work the way they tell him too.

Rant off.

Brian in Brighton