Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

Posts

Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

#1

Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

David Frame Jr.

Hello Everyone,

I own a C 10 FS Hitchi Slide Compoung Miter Saw. It has been and is still very accurate. About 3 years ago, I bought a FLIPSTOP PRECISION FENCE GAGE, Model JSS FSJ, manufactured by American Design and Engineering Inc. I bought it with two, eight foot sections of aluminum extrusion for each side of the saw. It is an exceptionally precise gage. My original fence was made out of laminated 3/4" plywood. it was fairly true, but not like the FLIPSTOP I have now.

Here lies the problem. Since my miter saw fence is approximately 14 inches away from the wall. This does not give me very much room to work with the fence covering most of the cabinetry it sits on.

Since I only have about $1000 to work with, should I save a few more bucks and buy the Festool Slide Compoung Miter Saw, or should I continue to save and buy a high quality Radial Arm Saw down the road.

Thanks for your time,

David Frame JR.

dframe01@hotmail.com

Re: Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

#2

Re: Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

mike American Sycamore

Save your money! A radial arm saw is not very accurate nor will it stay that way if you move it around to cut different angles. I use my 12"Delta radial arm saw for rough cut off work only. I have a Dewalt slider with a Biesemeyer fence system that I LOVE! Look into a Biesemeyer system....it is a wonderful addition to any shop!

Re: Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

#3

Re: Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

FredD

There's a toothy question if ever one was.

Depends on which you need the most and do the most , accurate angle cutting or fast repetitive cutting to length.

I disagree partly with Mikes assertion that a RAS is not accurate, it is as accurate as you are patient and routinely do adjustments when needed.

That said I would never put out the bucks that Festool wants for any of their tools given that it is not demonstrably clear that they are worth it , though some here have subscribed to their advertising.

Save yourself some money if you want or need a new compound mitre saw and go with a Dewalt , Makita, or Bosch or Milwaukee.

I use a combination of a good RAS and a 14" Makita mitre saw, never have warmed up to a compound mitre saw , but that is just me.

Don't overlook the fine cuts and repeatability you can get with jigs , sleds etc. on your Table Saw.

Happy hunting

FredD

Re: Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

#4

Re: Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

John Lucas

I have not used a high end radial arm saw. I have an older Sears digital readout saw and it does require frequent checking and tune up. I rely on my Powermatic table saw for most critical work.

I have used the Festool sliding miter saw. I'll admit up front I thought their stuff was over priced. This is one fine tool. It is solid as a rock, as smooth as any tool I've ever used, and dead on accurate. It is still overpriced for my budget but I'm saving my money. That is one of the sweetest tools I've ever used.

Re: Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

#5

Re: Radial Arm Saw vs Slide compoung Miter Saw

David Frame Jr.

Good Morning FredD,

I agree with your assessment of radial arm saws. The most accurate that I've used was the Original Saw.

After being layed off from the oilfield for 19 days, I went to work for a childhood friend of mine that is the

Vice President of Czarnowski Exhibit Service. Big mistake. They're about eight branches around the U.S.

Anyway, the reason I'm looking into an RAS is because my Hitachi 10" SCMS' fence is about 14 1/2" away

from the wall. Then, my 16' extruded aluminum fence, 8' on each side of the saw is also the same

distance away from the wall as my SCMS. This leaves me with very little top cabinet space.

My SCMS is in the center of the of 2- 8' cabinets, with a 32" cabinet in the center about 3 1/2" below the

other ones to allow for it to be flush with the other cabinets. They're only 2 saws that fit my bill. they

are the Festool or a RAS. The Festool is not worth $1400.00 and I can't afford a RAS. You were right

when you said Good Hunting.

Thanks for the advice,

David Frame Jr.

dframe01@hotmail.com