Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

OT -relief well?

Posts

OT -relief well?

#1

OT -relief well?

Normp

I've been reading how BP is drilling relief wells which somehow intersect the leaking well. This is the part I don't get.. if they can't even deal with one hole in the earth's crust 5000 ft. down, what makes them think the other holes they are drilling can be succesfully capped? Apparently, they intend to seal the main well through the relief wells. So why don't they simply use the same process with the existing leaking hole, knock the blowout preventer off and seal the existing well or use the same process on this bad well.

What a sad mess.... and this has to be the governments highest priority..

Norman

Re: OT -relief well?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: OT -relief well?

Moses Yoder

I believe the pressure on the well is something like 15,000 pounds per square inch, which is why they can't cap it. They have to put in another shaft to take the pressure off the prior well hole before they can cap it. A BP employee said the reason the well exploded is because they replaced the drilling fluid with salt water, which allowed methane gas to escape into the well pipe and then a small spark somewhere caused the explosion I guess; I don't think the gas would blow without a spark to ignite it. If they put in another well pipe they can divert most of the oil into the working well, which will take the pressure off of the leaking well so they can cap it. There are 46,000 offshore wells; something was bound to happen sooner or later, which is a good reason to invest money in research for alternative energy sources. I think hydrogen is the fuel of the future.

Re: OT -relief well?

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

One small problem...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

You said you think "hydrogen is the fuel of the future". What would the energy source be? Hydrogen can only be used as a means to transfer energy, as it does not occur naturally in a form usable as a fuel. Whether you break it off of hydrocarbon chains or get it from water, it takes more energy to do so than you get in return when you use it as a fuel (even if you could harness 100% of the energy from however you used it as a fuel). So hydrogen is essentially a lossy, non-electric battery for energy--and it's a problematic substance to handle, too--it would be similar to LP, except that it's much harder (takes much more energy) to condense into a liquid. As a gas, there's not much energy density there.

But your explanation of the relief well is on par with what I've been reading/seeing, though I had heard the pressure was more like 40,000 PSI, but I could be wrong on that.

Jason

Re: OT -relief well?

#4

Re: One small problem...

Barry Irby

I am not an expert on hydrogen as fuel, but I think Jason is right. My understanding is that the molecules are extremely small and will leak freely from systems that would do a good job of holding compressed air. And, Because it has so little fuel value you must have a fairly large tank. That tank must be very tough because it may be under huge pressure and very dangerous in an accident (Don't get me wrong, your gas tank is very dangerous also, but not under pressure). So building a hydrogen car is not as simple as it might seem.

And, there is no ready supply of hydrogen. Lets say you used solar photovoltaic cells to crack water. In effect you would have a solar powered car. And when you ran the car, the hydrogen would recombine with exactly the same number of oxygen molecules liberated from the water and create water again. That's great, except that it would take thousands of acres of cells to produce enough electricity to free enough hydrogen to offset a significant amount of gasoline. What they don't mention abut photovoltaic cells often is that they are very inefficient. About five percent of the light that hits them gets converted to electricity, but much of the rest of it comes off as heat and could be contributing to global warming.

There is no free ride.

Re: OT -relief well?

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: One small problem...

Moses Yoder

Well those issues is why we will have to research it, which will cost money. The earth i think is 75% covered in water, so all we have to do is figure out how to convert it into energy and we will be set for some time. Another option that I think will be viable is some sort of nuclear energy, perhaps cold fusion. I think nuclear waste could be shot into the sun for disposal but then I am not a scientist. It's interesting to note that the head of the patent office thought it should be shut down in the late 1800's because he thought there was nothing left to invent.

Re: OT -relief well?

#6

Re: One small problem...

Stuart Johnson

I think nuclear waste could be shot into the sun for disposal but then I am not a scientist

This was written about in the 60's in one of the science articles included in a SciFi magazine. It sounded like it would work and in the scheme of things not too costly. With our (mankind) history of screwing up things we would probably figure out a way to blow up the sun.

Re: OT -relief well?

#7

Re: One small problem...

Barry Irby

I agree we need to figure this out. No matter how much oil there is, its a finite amount. At some point it runs out. We have been using oil for about a hundred years and there may be another hundred years worth left, but even if there is two hundred years worth left, we will have used up all we can get our hands on in two or three centuries. People have been on the earth for thousands of years and we will have exhausted the oil in a relatively short period of time.

There are places where archaeologists have discovered a city built on top of the ruins of a previous city which was built on top of a previous city. If the location was so good or a city, a harbor or a river or whatever, why did the city die out and then return a hundred years later? Wood for fuel may be the answer. They lived there as long as the forests lasted and they could haul wood for fuel into the city. When fuel ran out, people left the area. The forests regrew and they moved back. The same thing is not happening with oil. It took millions of years to generate the oil reserves and we can't wait for them to regenerate.

It seems to me that we need to look at using power that comes from "outside", not something that is stored here and therefore finite. "Solar" Is not renewable and not inexhaustible, but when the sun flickers out or goes boom, we won't be able to help it. So, solar, wind (a form of solar) and bio (photosynthesis using solar) are going to have to be used heavily to extend the useful life of the oil and coal and nuclear.

Re: OT -relief well?

#8

Peak oil

Nathan

The problem Barry is referring to is called "peak oil" (see also the "peak wood" article I posted). It's not as simple as "using up all the oil", though. The thing is, at least in and around the United States, we have already used up all the oil that is easily accessible. "Easily accessible" are the key words, here. There are still lots of hydrocarbons in the earth's crust, but not easy (or safe) to get at.

Now, oil companies will go after the harder-to-access oil only if the price goes up high enough to make this profitable. As we are seeing, the more aggressive companies, like BP, will take risks and make short-cuts on safety to make the value proposition work.

So, it's not a matter of exhausting all the oil reserves. That's not going to happen. What is going to happen is "peak oil", which is the point where all the easy-to-get oil is gone (in a big "whoof" of CO2), at which time the oil price ceases to be stable and starts going up . . . and up . . . and up.

Of course, we all have some idea of what happens when the oil price goes up. And it ain't pretty. The first thing that happens is the price of staple foods spikes (you may remember this happened a couple years ago), causing widespread political unrest and even famine in the developing world.

We can't stick our collective heads in the tarpit forever.