We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
The other day a guy told me he was having chelation to get the tin out of his blood. The specialist he was going to told him not to eat stuff out of cans anymore because it was saturating his system with tin and without the chealation it would reach even more harmful levels.
I am not sure, but I thought they did not use tin in tin cans any more and even if they do I thought the interior was coated with some sort of "paint".
I believe those cans not made of aluminum are still made of tin-plated steel. Many of them are lined with something else, but I don't know what; Wikipedia says that, at least in England, the lining is a plastic with health concerns all its own; see link.
You sure come up with interesting off-topic questions, Barry.
Don't know about the USA but here in Canada baby bottle products that were made with BPA have been banned. I think we still have it as can liners for some products.
Used to be that a piece of hay baling wire and a oil can would fix about anything thing on the farm. Well, hay baling wire is gone, oil 'cans' are gone and now they're going after the last of the tin cans. What's next, duct tape?
Just remembering the old men from my childhood and laughing. They used to say that all you needed for a road trip in a T-model was, a screwdriver, some pliers, an oil can and some hay baling wire. You were set for any emergency.
been their with a trip yrs ago Like you said bailing wire which i bailled lot's of hay with that wire at the brake time you couldn't see your skin hay chaft and oil from the wire Sure need a bath before sat. tub I liked to be first Always had wire and oil can and you forgot tire patches in the little round can and the old glue looked like a leed tube Probly was The glue sure did work tho and the tire pump That sure was good fixing a flat along side of the road With the old screw jack The model T kind The good old day's Glad they are gone
Tell your friend I would suggest he seek a second opinion, this time from a reputable MD. Chelation therapy is for the most part snake oil. He's quite likely throwing his money away, and potentially causing harm to himself.
Basil , if you still want Baling wire , buy a roll of Tie wire , same thing.
The farmers around here that still put up small bales for people with horses (like us) , backed off of baling wire about four years ago when the cost per bale went up to about 15 cents, now it's all binder twine.
Before you go calling something snake-oil, I suggest you understand what you are talking about.
The original poster did not state his friend was being treated with EDTA which is what the article you linked attacks for improvement if hardening of the arteries. The article you linked to does state that EDTA is effective for the removal of toxic metals.
There are a number of elements that are needed in small quantities that in excess cause problems: tin, zinc and copper are among those. When these elements are in excess, the removal of some of that excess will improve the general health of the patient.
"An important theoretical consideration should also be considered. The trace metal most dramatically lost as a result of EDTA chelation is zinc. French researchers have found that 24 hours after an infusion of EDTA, the urine of human subjects contained 15 times the normal amount of zinc [5]. Without replacement, the loss of this much zinc over the months during which 30 to 40 treatments are delivered will increase the potential for severe impairment of immune function, precancerous cellular mutations, loss in selective permeability of cell membranes and altered solubility of pancreatic insulin. Although proponent literature advises that supplemental zinc be administered to guard against zinc depletion, studies showing that this supplementation actually prevents depletion have not been published in the peer-reviewed scientific literature."
Direct quote from the article
Seems clear to me, John E, I believe is a MD , family Doc and does us a favor , feel free to correct me if that is not true.
Whether John E. is a doc or not is irrelevant. The original post mentioned chelation therapy to reduce tin without making mention of the agent being used for this particular application. John E. then links to an article debunking chelation therapy using EDTA for hardening of the arteries. He is using apples to deny oranges.
My question is: who told Barry's friend that he needed chelation? If it is the therapist doing the chelation, I'd agree with the Doc. It's like the softwater guy offering to take a sample of my water and tell me if I need a water softener. Even when I submit distilled water, the report comes back saying I have hard water with a high iron content.
Not trying to start any arguments, and am in no way trying to offer medical advice since I know nothing of the details of this person. I'm just offereing up that chelation therapy is "frequently" (NOT always) used only as a means to separate the unknowing from their money, and definitely has some potential negative adverse affects. I do know that "excess" or "deficiency" of various heavy metals are frequently used as diagnoses by practitioners of various forms of "quackery". While these diagnoses do certainly exist in real life, every case I've ever seen involved some type of "unusual" exposure, well above eating food out of tin cans. That, coupled with the fact that I've never seen anything in the mainstream medical literature about problems associated with "tin excess", would make it seem prudent to seek a second opinion. Of course, you are free to spend your money however you see fit.
You didn't call chelation quackery. You didn't link to an article that has nothing to do with the original post.
You quite plainly state that some diagnosis of heavy metal poisoning serve no purpose other than to separate the unknowing from their money and suggest he get a second opinion. That is a reasonable stand clearly stated.
"Tin" cans are made of tinplate which is tin-coated steel Although tin is corrosion resistant, acidic food like fruits and vegetables can cause corrosion of the tin layer. Nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea have been reported after ingesting canned food containing 200 mg/kg of tin. A study showed that 99.5% of tested cans contain below 200 mg/kg of tin.
This information comes from "Is there any tin in a tin can?" Not a hard search and contains far more info that any of us can supply here. I have to ask. Why is this question here when the search with direct, faster results and better information could have been done on your own asking the identical question?