Saw Stop tested with a finger!
Tom Dunlap
I think this is the inventor of the SS putting his finger to the blade....
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Saw Stop tested with a finger!
Tom Dunlap
I think this is the inventor of the SS putting his finger to the blade....
He is nuts
Dan Donaldson
I am an EE and worked on circuit/software design for over 30 years, and I don't care how confident I was in a design, there is no way I would risk an appendage to a danger like that. Any design or manufacturing flaw at all, and I could lose it.
Re: He is nuts
Bill Howatt
I don't think he's overly nuts.
Notice that he didn't cross-cut his finger such that he could lose it or a big piece of it. He slowly edged the side of a finger into the blade so if it hadn't fired he likely would have only received a very nasty cut on the side of the tip.
I'm not 100% sure but I think that is him putting his hand in the cooler earlier in the clip - quite possibly to make sure his hand is good and moist for conduction purposes.
Bill
He also is part of a lawsuit...
Craig in Silverdale
Against Ryobi. Seems he attempted to sell his Sawstop to them and they turned him down. Later on, someone cut their hand very badly using a portable table saw. The inventor joined the lawsuit saying that if Ryobi had used his invention the man would not have had the accident. HE also tried to get congress to pass a law that his product be mandated on all table saws sold in the USA. The idea is a good one, but I don't like his tactics.
$ $ $ !
steve mackay
Are you sure?
wilbur
Whatever your feeling is about Sawstop or the Ryobi lawsuit, I don't think it's true that Sawstop or Steve Gass joined the lawsuit against Ryobi filed by the guy that sustained the table saw injury. I can't find any reference supporting that.
Re: Are you sure?
Craig in Silverdale
WIlbur, I just read that within the last two weeks. Now I have to remember where. I believe it was in one of my trade Journals. Can't remember which one. Hopefully, it hasn't seen the recycle bin. About gass, I am rather apathetic with him. As for Ryobi, I don't think saws cut people any more than guns shot people. It's all in how you use a tool.
Re: Are you sure?
Howard Acheson
I believe Gass was only a witness for the plaintiff. Neither he or SawStop were part of the action against Ryobi.
Joining a suit vs. being a witness; other thoughts
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
As I understand the lawsuit in question, the plaintiff filed over injuries he'd received. I'm not sure that Steve Gass could join the suit in the technical sense - he's not an injured party. It's clear from the reporting I've seen that he's been right there offering testimony and assisting the plaintiff's attorney(s); it's certainly in the interest of his company's bottom line for him to do so*.
There are a lot of now-standard safety features, like belt guards on belt-driven machinery and housings around grinding wheels, that were once new ideas and, no doubt, greeted with skepticism by workers using the machinery involved. The difference between those safety features and the SawStop seems to me kind of like the difference between seat belts and airbags. Belt guards and seat belts don't cost much, and have a long usable life (although the seat belt manufacturers recommend replacing belts if they ever actually serve their purpose in an accident, I bet a lot of people keep on using them after minor fender-benders and low-speed collisions). They also require a little effort and good working habits to use. Airbags and the SawStop are designed for people who are too lazy (airbags) or inattentive to safety practices (SawStop) to make the minor effort to adopt good safety practices; and, if used, will generate a huge out of pocket replacement cost to the person whose life/finger was just saved.
Still, in a decade, we may find that new tablesaw users will wonder why they EVER built saws without this safety feature. Given that the SawStop, if activated, trashes the blade, I wonder what impact it would have on the sales of high-end sawblades? Myself, if I had a tablesaw with the SawStop, I'd debate whether to spend $100 or more on a really good sawblade, knowing that, in a millisecond of inattention, it could become material for a shop clock.
[MY secret agenda now revealed] All of this is an argument for a return to using handsaws wherever possible. No need for the SawStop on a Disston.
*My saying that does not mean I agree with him. I haven't spent enough time looking into it to decide for sure if he's a passionate believer in the importance of his design or an opportunist hoping that this lawsuit and others will achieve what he was unable to achieve otherwise, which is industry-wide adoption of this safety feature; but my impression so far leans toward the latter.
Found it
Craig in Silverdale
http://www.woodshopnews.com/news/news-desk/498930-table-saw-suit-nets-15m-verdict
Re: Joining a suit vs. being a witness; other thou
John Pappas
"Myself, if I had a tablesaw with the SawStop, I'd debate whether to spend $100 or more on a really good sawblade, knowing that, in a millisecond of inattention, it could become material for a shop clock."
On the contrary. One should follow the same rules for safety; the SawStop should not negate that. So, put on a $200 blade and you still have the incentive to think about safety.
Re: Are you sure?
Fred Davis
The article I quoted here showed Gass testifying for the Plaintiff and was quoted as saying he thought any Table saw without flesh detecting technology was unsafe , defective and should not be sold.
Naturally he would say that and the jury for some strange reason bought it.
FredD
Re: He is nuts
Don Evans
Dan is right. I've been in the Electronic world for 50 years and it is also a matter of component failure. With chip logic came a great reduction is component failure right off the assembly line but it is still there.
I'm retired now but component failure is probably down to about .4 percent off the line. If that is close then that means that there are .4 percent Sawstops out there that will not work when they should. Also what about when they get some age on them and some power gliches that make them non functioning? My point is that when it happens and it will, then Gass will be in world of hurt as he has set himself up for it with his actions.
He will have no defense.
Don
I believe this...things fail, or break...
Stuart Hough
that's the way it is. We as users should take every reasonable precaution we can to protect ourselves, and our associates. If we have not PROPERLY trained our employees in the use of the equipment, then WE are at fault. The sawstop technology is great, wonderful and all that, BUT even it will fail at some point, then what? Will we all have our table saws taken away to "protect us"? Even Sawstop has included a riving knife, anti-kickback pawls and a blade guard. I personally know woodworkers that have had several close calls, due to case hardening, compression wood, and such. They still have all ten digits, complete with tips, because they ALWAYS used the available equipment, paid attention to what they were doing, and followed the rules. Maybe Sawstop should be forced to make their technology available to all the manufacturers FOR FREE, if it is such a vital ingredient in table saw safety. Until that happens, I think Gass sould keep his nose out of the legal system.
Sorry for the rant, I usually keep these things to myself.