Did I say that?
Bill Tindall
To repeat......"Whilst one might imagine book matching lumber sawed this way, as a practical matter, it typically won't work out., unless one is striving for a rustic look incorporating knots and splits."
For those confused by the argument, let me clarify, just in case one is tempted to saw a good log this way with the hope of book matching the result.
Book matching would involve gluing adjacently sawed boards, ideally of similar width. Such boards will come from the center slices of a "flitch" cut log. Unless one is dealing with an exceptional log, as one nears the center knots will be encountered. Even the exceptional log is going to have juvenile wood at its center which invariably cracks upon drying, especially in the case of cherry. Hence, the wide lumber from the center cuts, that by size would be ideal for book matching, will in fact typically have defects in their centers, yielding the "rustic" look I described.
I included "typically" in the sentence that offended some, to allow for the possibility that one might get a book matched table top from the occasion log sawed this way. Personally, I have never sawed a log that I was willing to take the risk.
I have had success achieving a book matched look for a table top by choosing a wide board twice as long and half as wide as the top to be made. I cut the board in half lengthwise and glue it edge to edge. Because the two pieces are from the same part of the tree the grain density and color will be nearly a perfect match, but the grain pattern will not match (but it may be close).
The only reliable way to get true book match is to use veneer from a flitch of veneer.
The fastest way to cut a log on a portable band mill is to "flitch" cut it. If you have a log to be cut don't confuse fastest with best. If you want to know how logs are cut for best yield of clear lumber refer to my article on sawing logs in the Articles Section.