Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Posts

Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#1

Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Stephen Kirk

I recently picked up a Kreg Jig (the full kit). It's already come in quite handy. Adding rails onto my kitchen cabinets to make screwing on the countertop easier, put the runners and kickers on a drawer assembly with it. I plan to make some other fast furniture, too. It's really handy for when I need to work in a hurry and they make a good strong screw - none have broken yet!

Yet the craftsman in me feels kinda guilty. I can make mortise and tenons, dovetails, lap joints, etc (even the sly mortise and tenon!). So, what do you think, is the Kreg a good joinery method or should any true craftsman avoid it like the plague.

And since it's hard to get across in writing, I mean this a bit tongue in cheek.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#2

Re: Kreg Jig -  My Take

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Evening Stephen,

I've gone thru the same soul searching ONCE. If it works, its fine. After all, are we making something useful or something nice to last and to look at? I think Kregg does it all, and I'm not ashamed to use it every chance I get. It doesn't replace my mortising machine or box joint jigs or table saw tenoning jig. Its one more effective weapon in my arsenal.

And the more time sensative the job--the more essential they are. My #3 son is a contractor who uses the Kregg I gave him frequently. No question in our minds about using modern methods.

George

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#3

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Steve in Phoenix

I double-dare you to ask this question on the hand tools board! ;)

Every cabinet shopper thinks dovetailed drawers are the sign of a great craftsman. I present to you the great craftsman of our age:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZlMo72YyqRg

I admit that many times I choose expediency. No one will ever separate me from my Dowelmax! I need to make my limited time in the shop as efficient as possible.

Enjoy the tool!

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#4

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

Stephen,

The Kreg jig is a perfectly acceptable way to assemble wood.

The walnut table below was assembled with pocket screws,

The apron to leg joint and the apron to the top.

This table and 50 more pieces, pedestals and tables are currently in

The University of Michigan's Art Museum.

I say use whatever joint/fastening method you feel is best for the particular task at hand,

Andy


img

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#5

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Jesse Cloud

Depends on what you want to do. For projects that need to get done quickly and don't need to last a long time - they rock. I read that the average kitchen cabinet install lasts seven years. Just no point using traditional joinery in those circumstances.

If you are looking to make something to pass down to grandchildren on mean to sell your work as high end, then pocket screws don't fit. Screws work loose over the years. That grandkid will eventually look at the angle that shows this thing was just screwed together - didn't grandpa have time to go to IKEA??

If you are doing this for your own satisfaction and you feel like you are cheating, that should be a red flag. I have build lots of things quickly that I want to go back to some day and do right.

So, if I were doing utility work for the shop, the Kreg jig would be a no-brainer. If I were selling something as fine woodworking, I would leave the jig be. Both uses are equally valid. BTW, my Kreg jig sits in the tool cabinet just next to the shoulder plane. Both have honored places....

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#6

Chet Kloss

If you ask, it means you think its cheating...

Chet Kloss

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#7

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

David Weaver

Certainly effective and quick. the joints aren't the strongest, but way back in the 90s when I was working part time at a large cabinet manufacturer, some of the joints were pocket screwed. I'd be kind of surprised if they all aren't now.

To me, it's hideous when you look behind a frame and see that hole - it's like evidence of a human powder post beetle, but you can't debate that you can throw things together fast with them.

Regardless of how hideous I think it is, I wouldn't hesitate to use one for some project the wife was pressuring me on. For my own projects, no way.

For commercial use, though? Definitely. Nobody buying commodity work cares about that stuff at all. You have enough trouble finding someone who even knows what dovetails are. Different story for one-off commissioned pieces, but even then, a customer cutting costs may choose to go that route.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#8

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Bill White

I guess that there was some touch of guilt the first time a power saw was used too. I use the Kreg quite frequently with out any feelings about "shorting" the quality of my work. I also glue said pocket joints, and have even added biscuits as well.

Bill

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#9

Seven Years?? That's interesting....

Barry Irby

I Agree with you on the Kreg jig. Utility work, yes, fine woodworking, not so much.

I thought your comment about kitchens lasting seven years was interesting. I do Home Inspections around Richmond, Va. I seriously doubt that seven years is true here. Much longer than that. In most houses I look at the shelf paper is seven years old. I'm thinking closer to 30 years. But, this is a very conservative area with heavy Colonial influence. Wonder what the average is n the rest of the country?

The thing I did not like about the Kreg jig was the screws. They are hardened. (That's a good thing.) But if you hit one with a saw blade, kiss it goodbye. (That's not a good thing.) Not crazy about biscuits either, but they are easier on cutters and blades.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#10

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Barry Irby

I was in a house recently where the seller had built his own kitchen cabinets and assembled it entirely with pocket screws. Apparently it did not occur to him to think through the placement of the screws. Some of them were on the outside of the cabinets and some were inside. (birch I think) The ones on the outside, he just used plastic wood to fill them. The Agent was gushing about custom cabinets. Out of curiosity I pointed out the ovals of plastic wood and wondered aloud what they were. (I knew, but was playing dumb.) The Buyers decided they were Accents. The fact that the accents were there sometimes and sometimes not did not seem to occur to them or bother them.

This set of cabinets was pocket screw heaven. The face frames had them, the face frames were screwed to the boxes with them, the drawers were assembled with them, and the frames of the drop panel doors had them too. So, I think you are right, they would not have recognized a dovetail and would not have cared.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#11

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

David Weaver

The place where I worked was aristokraft. The doors and face frames were decent, aside from the pocket holes and S clips, or whatever you want to call them, that held mitered doors together. i doubt, even as ugly as they were, that anyone will do anything to a door that causes them to fail.

The key to fast cabinet making (no surprise) is pocket holes, big dadoes in the face frames (for the sides) with intentional gaps that are filled with hot melt and stapled into place, and sides that are cut out by some panel cutter that's hooked up to the order computer in the front office, just automatically turning out carcass parts in stacks of 10.

The "upgrade" was ply sides by the time I left. If there was a small gap in a frame as a cabinet went down the line, you filled it with putty. Color of the doors and face frames was really the only important thing, because as little as anyone knows about construction, everyone has an opinion if you get finish that comes out a little different on one door vs. a drawer front.

The doors, drawers and face frames came to us assembled (there were 12 of us on a line), and we put together, boxed and labeled 70 cabinets per hour, whether they were base cabinets for a kitchen or bathroom vanities. They went down the line so fast that even though I was 2/3rds of the way down hanging doors on cabinets, I could still get burned by the hot melt.

If you got a run of cabinets, there is no guarantee that some wouldn't have pocket screwed doors frames and others not, just depends on where the doors came from and what frames were pulled.

Most woodworkers would've been appalled by how the cabinets were put together, but we rarely got any back, and if we did, it was for color, never frame gaps or anything like that.

I remember that stuff well when I'm putting anything permanent in the house, because we all probably have a tendency to be perfectionists. The person who buys the house next probably will never notice. They'll say they do or don't like the color.

Your story about putty on the fronts of the cabinets as an accent is fantastic. Made me laugh loudly!

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#12

I don't know what the average is

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but we're messing with it in my house: the kitchen remodel we did approaching three years ago replaced kitchen cabinets built about 1948. If the average is seven years, someone in our neighborhood must have been replacing cabinets every year or two to compensate for us.

Having said that, I am SO glad those home-built, funky cabinets are gone.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#13

Real estate agents - making a good save

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I do feel for real estate agents, who must frequently be called upon to put a good face on a rotting corpse; still, the word acrobatics in the profession are kind of amazing at times.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: Pocket holes

Moses Yoder

I think pocket holes have been around about 500 years, probably about the same time the first metal screws were made.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#15

Re: Seven Years?? That's interesting....

Jesse Cloud

Hey Barry,

Thanks for the feedback. I'm a little skeptical about the seven years statistic, too. I remember now that I got that from a talk I heard Marc Adams, the Indiana woodschool king, give on making face frames. Before he got into the training biz, he had a cabinet shop. Found that he was doing the same kitchens over and over every few years. Maybe that just means that he built lousy cabinets (hah, hah). So he did some research and got that number. Anyhow, his conclusion was that pocket screws were the way to go for face frames.

I always enjoy your posts, especially those involving your house inspection work. I wonder sometimes how some of the stuff I have built is holding up....

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#16

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Bill Howatt

Interesting description on how it is done in the factory setting.

My house had 1/2" particle board cupboards. The shelves were held in dado cuts by small nails. The back of the uppers and lowers were 1/8 masonite stapled on with a pine strip for screwing them to the wall. The face frames were held together by big staples, nailed into the edge of the particle board carcass and covered with laminate. The drawers were masonite bottoms in dados and the front and back of the drawers were held by 2 nails on each joint. Basically a real cheap job.

They have been replaced but OTOH the real cheap job lasted for 34 years!

I know this isn't the forum to say it but I don't think that the current generation and probably some before it, don't give a darn about dovetail joints and other examples of fine craftsmanship. If it doesn't match the decor or is out of style, there is a high probability it is on its way out the door.

billh

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#17

Re: Seven Years?? That's interesting....

Barry Irby

I have a friend who has been making cabinets for a living for forty years. (Actually, longer than that, we worked our way through college building cabinets.) He has made thousands and thousands of drawers that have simple butt joints in the corners with a few 1/4" crown staples and yellow glue. He has never had a drawer returned because it failed.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#18

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Bartstar

Barry, an old friend of mine did something similar - in that he had drilled his pocket holes on the exposed side of his table, and filled them with the plugs they sell for that purpose. He called it a design consideration. I call it not paying attention to which side of your work you needed to drill. :)

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#19

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

David Weaver

You're right about how long they last. Once they go in place, no problem. I did kick the side of one in once by accident when it was taken off the line and sitting on the ground, and I went to jog past it.

Ply was probably on the sides of 10% of the cabinets, the rest were particleboard, and these were considered mid-grade cabinets. Grooves were all cut in the particleboard by computer controlled machines (this was about 1996 or so). The particleboard is the really fine sawdusty stuff.

Some of the doors were cope and stick - the ones that weren't mitered and were of more expensive wood, like cherry and maple. Some had real wood center panels, and others not, but the doors were done so well that it wasn't that easy to tell which were fake center panels when you looked close. The finish was just a couple of coats of lacquer, but it was actually pretty good on the face frame and doors (sides with the particleboard, of course, had a sticker veneer/tape. Stain was applied evenly (the color thing again, people notice when color doesn't match) and there were some unfortunate folks there who did nothing but wipe stain for 40-70 hours a week (depending on how many hours they actually wanted). A novice finisher would do worse with the finish. I'm not sure I could actually do better even after finishing a few pieces - the finish was never uneven on anything there that I recall.

Nastiest style was called lakewood - apartment type cabinets.

I can't remember what the company changed its name to, and can't find much on google.

Drawer guides were those ultra cheap stamped painted guides held in with plastic dogs on the back. There was a person who did nothing all day but put cabinet backs into a site-made machine that drilled four holes at a time and had spacer jigs to get all of the holes for the guides in the right place. Another job on the actual assembly line was literally taking those guides, plugging the plastic ends on them and bending them (the guides) up in a jig and then putting them in the cabinets. That was hard on the hands - face frame edges are always sharp. That job was right after the units went on the line out of the clamps (pneumatic units that were like a jig and a clamp all in one to put the face frame, sides, backs and bottom together), too, and if you saw a loose brace in the cabinets, you had to be careful getting it out. The hot melt burns deep, and the people on the clamps had arms with deep burn scars all around their forearms and wrists -looked like they were in a swordfight without a sword.

I didn't mind it so much then, I wasn't a woodworker, and I was pretty proud of working on them and how good the face frames and doors looked, and all of the non-lakewood non-rtf doors did look pretty good - they knew what the customer wanted, and they made an effort to make that part look good. It paid decent for a college kid and you could get a lot of hours on the same schedule every day. It was well lit, well ventilated, and they were serious about safety and ergonomics.

Best job I had there was driving a box truck back and forth between buildings bringing doors back to the "door building" from the finish room. I'm guessing osha never measured the formaldehyde coming out of the truck when you got to the door building on a hot day, but it dissipated pretty quickly, and they did test the door building where the doors were and it was in spec.

Cost cutting got the factory last year or two years ago and it was closed and consolidated with another location. I always thought the people there probably had safe jobs because it was non-union, they weren't real high paid, and they were making something that would be expensive to ship.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#20

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Barry Irby

I just found it to be astounding. I suppose if he had put all of them on the outside and then used some contrasty plugs I might have bought it, but this was clearly inattention to which side they should be on. And, yes, I have made similar mistakes, but I doubt I would have let it go by, even on a shop cabinet. And then there was the Realtor and the buyer Gushing over the custom cabinets. He had not even plugged the ones on the interior and there were a lot of them.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#21

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

Stephen Kirk

Wow, there are so many good replies here. I'm glad to see just how useful everyone thinks this kind of joint is and that it has a perfect home in a woodshop. I see that I'll be having a lot of projects coming up that call for speed, not complicated joinery. These are projects both for me and some less discerning clients (cheaper is just fine for them). I love the jig for it's ability to fix things, too. Nice not to have to rip furniture apart. I will use my new found power responsibly and not skimp when another joint is called for.

The kitchen cabinet discussion was really quite fascinating. I never knew some of that stuff. Replacing our kitchen I did see that the cabinets were often of questionable construction. The area in the corner wasn't even a cabinet, just a piece of plywood and a stick in the corner to nail it too. All kreg joints would have been an improvement. But, those cabinets are probably 20-30 years old, so there's nothing wrong with the construction.

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#22

I would have guessed...

John in NM

That the average was skewed by people replacing the super cheep cabinets that builders have been sticking into tract homes for the last 30+ years, but even that doesn't quite fit with Adams' explanation.... I'd be very surprised if someone hired me to replace custom cabinets I'd built within the last decade... weird.

Concerning what Barry says about drawer boxes, that doesn't surprise me at all, a good plywood or solid box will hold up very well with that assembly, because they're most often mounted on good drawer glides. I've seen particle board boxes fail after 15 years of slamming though - one area where overlay fronts cause real damage. I usually build the boxes with a box joint, more because I like them than needing the strength. But then I don't have to meet a bottom line ;)

Re: Kreg Jig - Cheating or a perfectly good joint?

#23

I'm a bit late...

John in NM

but that's nothing new :D

I really like the Kreg jig for face frame construction, its fast and efficient and plenty strong for a frame that is usually glued and screwed to a big plywood box.

I also often use a pocket screw in an enlarged hole to fasten table tops, especially small ones. I usually hand cut those with a large tight sweep gouge though, unless it's a plywood top on a work table.

I once made an elliptical top door jamb that was going in a curved wall - talk about a nightmare - so I had to glue together 4 narrower laminations. Pocket screws to the rescue. :D