We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I am taking some smaller items to a small vendor show this weekend. I'll be exhibiting some new wall cross designs, breadboard/serving trays and these items below- A pair of Oak benches like the one in these photos and a pair of Shaker Step Stools in Ash
Even a Tall fellow can use a step-uip some times...
I've made several of them in white oak or cherry with dovetail joinery throughout. Dovetails on the steps are an eye catcher. They are popular and very useful.
For the next batch -if there is one- consider cutting in an elongated slot ~ 1x4" into the top step for a hand hold. Makes 'em easier to carry around.
Great looking step stools , hard to get a new look for those that hasn't been done, but you did , very nice , hope my wife doesn't see them before next Winter
Very good thoughts about the variations available for these somewhat common little stools. These were a quick build as I needed something for this weekend-It's not a big event but I wanted some variety in the things I am displaying. I'd rather keep these two little Shaker stools as they are made from an Ash tree from my home in ND. I hope to make more of these pieces and will probably incorporate those features in subsequent efforts. I used dowels for joinery here.
-Bill -The bench is bit on the angular side. I think it's basic form has some room for experimentation...-Alan
Glue and dowels were used here. As has been mentioned in other posts-dovetails would add to the look of the pieces and probably the joinery strength-although I'm not concerned with these as they are. Because the grain of the steps and the sides run in the same direction-I glued the steps along the "aprons" and the sides. These are simple in overall design- I searched around the web for shaker step stools. After seeing a few I drew this basic design-18" high and wide and 9" deep for each step.
That is the larger of the two that I made.
I added the diagonal braces just for a bit a flair-how much flair can a Shaker Stool accept? :^)
My wife saw the first and said the rise needed to be less.. so the second ie smaller one is 18" wide and 7" deep and high. This smaller one is a great exercise stool. You can get a decent aerobic work-out just by stepping up and down through a cycle of your choice..Michigan winter's being what they are this could prove to be a cheap winter walking devise-
The larger stool has Non waxed shellac ie Sealcoat finish. The smaller one has a Tung Oil Varnish- You can see that gives it just a bit more depth of color. (The reddish hues on the lower step are from the lights in the room)
Very nice work, Alan. The only thing that is missing is something to reinforce that short grain on the side panels. It's always been part of this particular design problem, probably starting long before the Shakers came along. Sometimes the Shakers dealt with it, but not always. To an extent, it depends on the species of the wood and how strong it is along the long dimension.
If you engineer this piece thoroughly, you might end up putting a cross piece across the side panels/stringers, under the lower step and extending to the back, with slotted screw holes to allow for expansion/contraction. If you don't need it, great, but be aware of this weak point in the design. You can also reduce the risk by using a shallower radius in the bottom cutout. This gives you additional length to the vertical seam.
I sure like them all. The stools are charming. The seal coat finish may not "stand"up to constant use, but then its an easy repair. I've looked for suitable benches to build for our Dining Room, always with as mind to incorporate a low back on each, and upholstered seats. Haven't found a design yet to use. Yours go well as intended, and by their looks, will provide steady seating for generations. Nice jobs.
the legs and foot pads on Alan's bench are very evocative of the Bill Ding figure.
The toy was a fascinating exercise in spacial relationships, balance, and the use of repetition of forms as a design exercise. I actually used a set of them in my high school sculpture class to teach those concepts.
The only thing that is missing is something to reinforce that short grain on the side panels.
Been wondering how much to be concerned with that issue. I guess it isn't too late to add a piece such as you suggest- I'm wondering if I ran a dado in the joint between the two sections and glued in a spline if that would be sufficient.
Not sure what I was thinking when I put the Sealcoat finish on that first one. You are right that it isn't the "sturdiest" finish for this application. I guess it can take a varnish on top...
Your wife and Ellis have hit on the two things my little voice was complaining about. Nine inches is too high for a step. As a builder (of houses) I studied the design of stairs. 7 x 10 was considered Ideal. (I know there are a billion variations and a set of loose rules that govern them, but 7 x 10 is a good starting place.) So, shortening the rise to 7 or 7 1/2 was a good idea. 9 x 9 would make the stool considerable my "tippy" also. I would probably in the appearance and vastly complicated eh design and construction, but it would be "better" if the base were flared out so that the foot print were as large as or larger than the top. (We had a stool my MIL brought back from a craft vendor at Dollywood. The top projected about two inches beyond the base all the way around. It was a neck breaker. When she wasn't looking, I rebuilt it. She commented that the stool wasn't as bad after you got used to it.)
And, I agree with Ellis on the short vertical grain. That was my first impulse when I looked at it. I don't think your spline idea will add much strength. You are just moving the problem slight to the front and rear. The ash is not much longer at that point and adding the spline may actually weaken the ash.
If you make more, since the ends are nearly square, how about rotating the pieces ninety degrees and running the grain horizontally?
I like these a lot. I love the simplicity of the Shaker design. They work very well. I like the angular bench. The angles and contrasting woods appeal to me.
... Shaker stools had front-to-back cleats on the insides of both sides, under the lower step, to reinforce the sides, **unless** the sides didn't have any cutouts at the bottom. The cleats were typically screwed on.
The ideal staircase tread height of 7" - 7 1/2" wasn't taken as gospel when making step stools. In fact, it wasn't unusual for Shaker step stools to have step heights of 10". Most of the examples I've looked at are between 8 1/2" and 10". But there is a center-of-gravity issue here, too. Some Shaker step stools had sides that sloped back, to center the top tread a bit and reduce the risk of tipping.
As you know I am quite fond of re-inventing the wheel. That cross piece could be added discreetly to my pieces..
-Alan
BTW I found this on Pop Woodworking site...
The weight is not distributed over all the short grain-I'd guess at best the weight of the lowest person and 1/2 of the second person is stressing the short grain on the low step. The upper step seems to have a relatively long grain joint...
Actually, I recall I've already had this discussion with them in the past. Keep in mind that the strength of that short grain is species-dependent. Softwoods and straight-grained pieces will not have the same resistance to shearing force as denser hardwoods and species with interlocked grain. Add to that the length of the short grain. All I can say is that the Shakers didn't trust it without cleats unless the short grain wasn't that short.
By the way, anyone could stage that photo. If you did a vector analysis of the forces on a piece like that, though, you would most certainly not offer this as proof that you can flout shortgrain construction limitations. At some point, a heavier person or a sudden force will tip the scales and the stool will come tumbling down. This is the laddermaker's conundrum, and it's also why laddermakers pay such high liability insurance premiums.