Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

interesting joint/glueline failure

Posts

interesting joint/glueline failure

#1

interesting joint/glueline failure

DizD

About 10 yrs ago I acquired some Santos Mahagony leftover at a processing facility. I made a 30" X 60" 4 board table top w/ breadboard ends for a computer table/desk. During the first year or so the sides shrunk somewhat and a short section of the middle joint developed a hairline crack on one end. Not a problem because of the desk pad and other "stuff" covering the top. Fast forward to last month: late one evening we heard a loud "snap", sounding something like slapping a yardstick down on a table. When I went looking I found the hairline crack had become more akin to a san andreas fault - its now about a 3/32" gap along the entire glue line. Somehow I don't think acclimating the boards a few more weeks in the shop would have made much difference!

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#2

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

John Pappas

My guess is that you glued the breadboard along the entire width instead of just glueing a small section in the middle. Glueing a short section in the middle would have allowed the panel to expand and contract with changes in the humidity. Instead, as the panel tried to shrink a crack developed. Eventually the shrinking forces were enough to break the glue bond around that crack which allowed it to open up as much as it did.

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#4

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

R Payne

I am curious as to what type of glue you used.

I can't say using a different glue would have worked, just curious.

ron

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Wood Movement

Moses Yoder

Many people disregard wood movement when building projects. You have to keep in mind that wood can move as much as 1/4" across the grain; it will expand in the summer because warm air can hold more moisture than cold air, and the wood will adjust to the moisture content of the air. There is no glue in the world that can prevent wood from moving; something will give somewhere, as you have experienced.

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#6

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I made dressers for our bedroom out of hickory. About 4 years after they were made we were sitting in the living room one winter evening and heard a loud pop from the bedroom. I looked around but didn't find anything. A few weeks later, the cat tipped over the trash can by my wife's dresser. As I was picking up stuff and putting it back in the trash can I noted a large crack up the side of the dresser. I checked the other end and found a similar crack.

In building the dresser I had glued drawer support boards across the grain of the side panels in several locations on each side panel. As the wood dried out from the winter heating, it couldn't move. The result was the split the full height of the side on both sides of the dresser. Later that year when the weather was warm, I removed the glued pieces from the dresser sides and attached them with screws in slots so the side panels could move. I also glue the crack together. That was 15 years ago and there have been no problems since.

Lee

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#7

The only glue joints I've ever had fail

Bruce, a MN Galoot

and there have been several, have been because I broke the rules.

In mortise and tenon joints, I had a piston fit and scraped the glue from the mating surfaces.

In edge grain, I applied the glue at a temp colder than the working temp stated on the bottle and that resulted in a "frozen" glue line where the glue didn't have an opportunity to penetrate into the surface of the wood.

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#8

Re: Science fair project

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Grandson did a school project to discover the strongest glue. He used 1" x 6" pine from Lowes and six different common glues. He used a 1" lap joint at the ends of 24" boards. He allowed the glues to cure for two days. He placed a coffee can on the joint and added 16p nails until the joint failed from the weight alone. No other stress was used. Gorilla glue took SIX times the weight of any other glue. When it failed the wood broke, not the glue joint. In this test the Gorilla glue proved much stronger, but I still hate to use it!

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#9

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

Howard Acheson

You are correct John. The likely issue is that the breadboard ends were completely glued in. Of course, this creates a cross-grain joint that does not allow seasonal wood movement. Breadboard ends must be constructed with attachment methods that allow the main panel to expand and correct.

At this point, the only fix is to cut off the breadboard and install a splined joint with solid attachment in the center and sliding joints in the outer portion of the panel.

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#10

Re: Science fair project

R Payne

That is great for initial strength. But it doesn't tell us anything about how the glue loses strength over time. I've made several repairs of PVA glue after many years when the glue failed. But testing the same type of joint with the same glue after a few days results in wood failure.

That is really where my interest lies, what glue lasts over time. We know that hide glues and similar glues can last centuries. None of the modern glues have been around long enough to know if they can last that long.

By the way I've used Gorilla glue once and decided I have no use for it. I just don't like the way it works.

ron

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

#11

Re: interesting joint/glueline failure

DizD

As some have observed, because the joint obviously failed, the design was ultimately to blame. One of the major factors also was, in my opinion, the density of the wood used. The breadboard was put on with a loose spline with a screw through the edge of the breadboard about 8" from each end. The spline was probably only glued on one edge (yellow glue as I recall.) The screw holes in the breadboard were drilled somewhat oversize and most likely wallowed out laterally to provide expansion room. I figured that when the shrinkage occurred and the wood contacted the screw, the wood was too hard to allow any compression of fibers. So, the two outer boards shrank around the fastener between the two boards and ultimately pulled the center joint apart. In most domestic hardwoods I believe the fastening system would have provided enough give through compression to relieve the stress. The comment about the longevity of glue could also be said about the wood in this case - if its an unfamiliar species, you may not know how it will respond over time. I was suprised at the amount of shrinkage in such a dense wood