Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Posts

Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#1

Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Ralph Lipeles

Hi,

I have 5 section wooden garage doors. My property tends to be wet. In the summer I get so much condensation on the garare floor that puddles form. Over the last 40 years I have replaced the bottom sections of the doors twice. They need replacement again. So I am looking into new doors.I have looked at Raynor and Overhead. They both look well made but are both are painted steel. The salesmen assure me that the paint is good and the doors will never rust through. However, with my bad experience with wood doors, I am concerned. Are there any non metal, or heavily clad metal doors, that may hold up better for me? I appreciate any help that you people can give me.

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#2

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Marv Horn

I live on the Oregon coast ans had the same experience with wood. Put in a vinyl door about 8 years ago and it's perfect. Only drawback is a "squeak" as sections rub together when operating. Can here it next to the door but not in the house. We have few temperature extremes so I painted it and it's held up perfect.

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#3

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"The salesmen assure me that the paint is good and the doors will never rust through."

There's no such a thing as a paint for steel that won't eventually break down, especially in an environment like a garage door. Never's a heck of a long time. Of course, "rust through" could mean "rust showing through the paint" or "rusty enough to make holes in the steel." You'd be replacing the doors long before you reached that last stage, because they'd be so ugly. If the salesmen meant the first definition, and if you can get that in writing, backed by the company, you might have free replacement doors for the rest of your time in that house. Make sure labor is included in the warranty.

You might, separately, want to consider whether you need dehumidification in your garage, if you keep anything in it that would be damaged by condensation.

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#4

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy? *LINK*

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Hi Ralph,

When we built our home I had Overhead Door series 490 Thermacore doors (R17) installed. They have never been painted and still look good after looking into the Texas sun for 8 years. Yes, they will cost a little more, but I think they are worth it.

BTW, the Termacore doors are made up north and had to shipped in from Yankee land.

Good luck with your search,

Ken


Thermocare doors

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#5

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Chuck Kettler

I live in central Indiana and have an insulated fiberglass door. It has presented no problems at all. Keeps a 30 degree temperature differential during the winter.

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#6

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Fred Davis

Overhead door is a good company that leads in the garage door industry.

We have had them at our place for thirteen years , insulated , with a row of window in the top section and no problems at all .

Sounds like you need to vent your garage , Fibreglas doors will not rust , though they give up in direct Summer sun after a few years, but still a better choice then wood and I still would go for the Overhead brand , they service what they sell.

FredD

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#7

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Ralph Lipeles

Do you know who the manufacturer is?

Thanks,

Ralph

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#8

I'll 2nd Fred.

Stuart Hough

My company uses Overhead doors on the truck docks. They are insulated, painted steel and, in the case of my store, have held up for 15 years. the paint is just now starting to break down a bit, and our dock gets full sun most of the year. I've had both Overhead and Raynor in the various houses I've owned over the years, and have to say I think highly of both in the residential arena. JMHO

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#9

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Ralph, yes I would advocate using the Overhead doors. And, if you get so much moisture that it gets inside and puddles on the garage floor...then I suggest you install some drainage tile piping outside the garage door in the driveway so the water is taken away from the door. Also, install a rubber boot on the underside of the door which will help in keeping out any moisture.

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#10

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

Jim Dillon

Ralph,

Fifteen years ago, we had Maryland Overhead Doors (don't know if they are the same "Overhead Doors" chain mentioned in this thread), install two Clopay brown, steel, insulated garage doors. Except for a little fading in the afternoon sun, the paint is holding up very well. At that time, there was a manufacturer of wooden garage doors, but I sure didn't want to chance the maintenance issue if problems arose. The wooden ones were nice looking, but expensive IIRC.

Jim

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#11

Overhead now owns Wayne Dalton

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

A few years ago, Overhead Door Corp. bought out the door side of Wayne Dalton Doors (and Genie openers) so are now the largest residential garage door manufacturer in the US.

(They did not buy the Wayne Dalton opener division which manufactures and sells the I-Drive, other openers, and HomeLink)

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#12

Put the icing on the cake and *LINK*

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Buy an Overhead Door Phantom Garage door opener. They are well made and do live up the claim of being quiet. Two people can stand directly under the motor and carry on a whisper conversation. The only noise of notice is the little bit of noise from the door rollers moving along the track. Also, the opener anticipates the top and bottom of the door travel and and slows down in last 3" of opening or closing.

Slicker than snot on a glass door knob,

Ken....


Phantom opener

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#13

Re: Put the icing on the cake and

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

I can't say they are that quiet, but my Idrives are quieter and faster than most openers, plus they don't require a rail and ceiling mount. They mount on the door header and wrap around the torque tube. That made it easier to run the DC ducting to my shop above:



Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#14

I have heard good things

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

about the 'motorized spring' type openers, Alan. I didn't know they existed back in 2002 when we needed garage door openers. If I ever have the need for another opener, I will certainly look at the trackless type. In the interim I still like the Phantom. :)

Happy saw dust,

Ken

Re: Which Replacement Garage Door to Buy?

#15

Re: I have heard good things

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Good thing you didn't get them back then! Despite winning all kinds of awards for the technology, there were major problems, not the least of which sloppy installation by homeowners and professionals not used to the Idrive- it didn't take kindly to that and really needed carefully balanced doors. Anyway, the gear box main gear was made from soft brass and often stripped when overloaded and they received a batch of bad circuit boards from their supplier. Needless to say they got a black eye big time from those two problems. The current units are fantastic, a bit expensive, but fantastic.