Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Questions on using Waterlox

Posts

Questions on using Waterlox

#1

Questions on using Waterlox

Bartstar

Hi All,

I'm finishing a serving tray and using Waterlox as the finish. I used the Finish/Sealer for the first two coats, then switched to the regular satin finish product for the next 4 coats. Two questions:

1) I typically apply Waterlox with a foam brush, then wipe it off with paper towels. This seems to take a long time to build the finish. Should I just paint it on and leave it on instead?

2) How many coats of finish should I apply for a serving tray? I have already done 6 coats, with light sanding between coats with 600 grit to remove the dust nibs.

Thanks

Bart

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#2

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I apply thin coats with no wiping. I get a faster build that way. Last coat is sanded flat with 400 and 600 grit Sic paper, then gently wiped off with a lint-free cloth. Do not use paper towels for this step as they shed fibers into the finish. Lastly, when fully cured, I'll work the surface with compound to an even sheen.

Six coats of Waterlox would be more that sufficient if you weren't wiping it off. It's not the same as a Danish oil, where you wipe off "excess" that doesn't soak in in 15 minutes. Put less on and let it self-level and set up.

BTW I prefer the gloss because the additional varnish resins make for a tougher film with more visual depth. You can always kill the gloss surface with your rubbing compounds to get an even sheen of your choice. With the satin's flatting agent, you'll never get a higher sheen.

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#3

According to my local expert...

Grant in Iowa

I have a professional woodworker friend and member of our local woodworking club who just gave the club a presentation on his Waterlox finishing method.

He sands to 150+ grit, and perhaps more on dense woods like tropicals. He also sands end grain to a finer grit most times too. This prevents the end grain from being a lot darker.

Then he does a coat of Waterlox for its beauty and ability to bring out the grain features in the workpiece. Within a few hours, he inspects the surface to ensure that there are no sanding marks. If there are, he sands them out by hand and applies another coat of Waterlox, wiping away the excess. Then after it dries again, he applies a LIGHT coat of Minwax wipe on poly in either satin or flat finish. He applies it with a foam brush and then wipes off the excess with a blue disposable shop rag(Sams club) immediately. This seems wasteful, and like you might not be getting anywhere, but the wipe-off is necessary. Waiting until the surface isn't tacky again, he applies a second coat of Minwax wipe on. I think he sands with the grain with an abralon pad between coats as necessary to remove any nibs. You could also use 0000 steel wool, so long as you clean carefully afterwards.

He claims that in one long day he can take a project from ready to finish to done, getting 4-5 coats of wipe on poly over the Waterlox. He can even work on other projects at the same time in the same space, since it is only tacky for maybe 20 minutes before it hardens to where dust isn't an issue. This assumes the humidity cooperates.

Waterlox is a good product, but in the presence of alcohol or similar liquids, the wipe on poly can provide superior protection. Part of my friends presentation was that the above process is what he uses for any horizontal surface. He says he does use only waterlox on some items that will not be handled or abused such as wall hangings. You can also do several coats of waterlox and then do one coat of Poly if you desire, but I like his one coat of Waterlox approach and see little reason to make changes to his regimen.

I have been nothing but impressed with the finishes he achieves with this regimen...and fast. Further, a wipe on poly finish can easily be repaired in the future by adding more finish layers. Even sanding back to bare wood and starting over can be done with the Waterlox/ poly combo.

It should be stressed that he is removing nearly all of the Wipe on poly by wiping after each coat. This is the secret to a quick drying smooth surface, he says. On larger pieces, you may need to do it in sections so it doesn't get tacky before you wipe it off. Further, he says the Minwax product works well for this, and he doesn't recommend substituting other brands, as he hasn't had the best results with them.

He builds high end custom projects and artpieces aimed at upscale buyers for a living. The finishes on them are very nice, he has total control of when to stop the poly coats so you don't get a plastic look. He usually stops at 4-5 coats on oak, so the grain texture is still visible in the rings of the wood.

Anyway, that is what he does, and I highly recommend that approach having been impressed with the results.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#4

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

Bartstar

Thanks Mark -

Question on the high gloss stuff - - Can I use that right over the Satin stuff I've been using to achieve a higher gloss finish?

Regards

Bart

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#5

Yup

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Just evenly scuff the surface with 320 or 400, then vacuum off well to remove any grit or dust.

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#6

Re: According to my local expert...

David Yoho

I've been using a similar regimen that I learned from a professional reproduction furniture maker in my area that has refined the way my Waterlox finish looks. The main difference is I use the Waterlox from start to finish. I only use poly when it's a better choice due to its harder end result and then only over itself - not over the Waterlox.

I mostly use the Waterlox Original Sealer/Finish, using the flood-on / wipe-off method for the first two applications and changing to a wipe-on / wipe-off method from there on. The final coat or two are just thin coats wiped on and left to dry. Depending on the wood species, I usually end up applying between six to eight coats total.

After the first two initial coats, I can apply at least two coats per day with no problems. The end result is stunning and guarantees no runs or sags in the end. I will not and do not use the blue paper towels when wiping. I find using T-shirt material works best.

I always wondered why my old Waterlox application method didn't turn out like I thought it should, which made me question the use of the product after all I'd heard about it. Once I learned to build it slowly with thin coats, I began to see the difference I'd been expecting from it.

David

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#7

Examples

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The center walnut bowl (14") was finished in exactly the way I described. No drips, runs or sags.

Admittedly, it's high gloss rather than satin, but you can see the possibilities.

The second turning, an 18" piece of ambrosia maple uses a bit less gloss, but retains the optical depth. Being an oil finish, it's very easy to renew.


Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#8

Thanx, gentlemen!

Stuart Hough

I was just killing some time trolling through the messages when I came across this thread. And again I say I LOVE THIS FORUM! Every day I learn something new and interesting! This will help when I do my next project. What a great site!

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#9

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

Howard Acheson

Waterlox Original is just an oil based varnish. It is slightly more thinned than most other varnishes so it can be used as a wiping varnish. But, it can also be brushed very successfully.

If you use it as a wiping varnish you end up wiping almost all of the wet finish off leaving a very thin film. It will take quite a while and probably 6-8 applications if you wipe off the excess after each coat. If you just wipe it on and let it dry it will take 4-6 coats to get a good, protective film.

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#10

Blue rags

Grant in Iowa

I respect Davids perspective and experience with Waterlox. I am sure he has a reason for his opinion about using disposable rags. I'd be interested in your perspective on disposable rags.

I am not sure what the aversion to the disposable blue shop rags is, but both my professional friend and I have been using them for many years with no issues. These are the variety sold at Sams Club, and seem to have no appreciable lint that comes off of them. They are even durable enough to survive a trip through the washing machine (accidentally).

I'm sure there are many iterations of these disposable rags, and I make no claims about any of them besides the ones Sams Club sells. The blue dye doesn't bleed into anything with any solvents I have used, and they generally don't leave lint any worse than a cotton rag might. All of that and they are about ten bucks for a "bale" of something like 9 or 12 rolls.

For fire safety, I lay them flat on the concrete floor if they are soaked with any type of finish until they have dried.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#11

Re: Blue rags

David Yoho

I do buy and use the Scott Shop Rags in my shop but I don't use them when using Waterlox. Although the first time I ever found them packaged in a ten-pack was once when I was at a Sam's Club, the closest one to us is way over on the other side of town and not worth the drive for me. Usually I get them at one of the local big box stores either by the roll or in packs of six when I can find it.

I like the blue shop towels because they actually don't leave a lot of fiber pieces behind. I do like to use them when applying Watco. However, for applying Waterlox, they are too expensive to use. I can buy a large container of T-shirt material that lasts longer and is more cost effective.

The main reason I use cloth with Waterlox instead of the blue shop towels is a trick I learned for re-using them. I cut one piece of cloth to use as an applicator after the first two coats where I use a foam brush to flood it on. This piece is used initially to wipe away the excess. Starting with the third application, because by now it has absorbed so much finish, I use it to apply the finish. I cut a fresh piece to use to wipe away excess. If the second piece fills up too much, I replace the first piece with it and cut a fresh piece to wipe away the excess. The trick to re-using these rags is to store them in a ZipLoc bag in the freezer between applications. Because our freezer is out in my shop, this is very handy for me. Depending on the size of the piece being finished, I usually only use two to three pieces of cloth material. I would use far more blue shop towels. After I'm done, I put them in the ZipLoc bag and toss it into the outdoor trash can.

David

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#12

Re: Blue rags

Fred Davis

David, you guys are making getting the rags harder then it needs to be.

Go to a professional paint store and buy painters rags in ten pound boxes.

They are invariably white cotton mill ends or tee shirt material in various sizes.

I once had a connection Calfornia with at guy who worked in a refinery and he brought me the mill end rags, a trash bag full at a time.

He said the refinery bought them by a boxcar full at a time.

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#13

By The Box

David Yoho

That's how I buy them - by the box. There's still a bunch left after all I've used out of it.

David

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#14

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

Howard Acheson

Just want to make the point that Waterlox Original is a varnish and a pretty standard varnish at that. It is NOT tung oil. Like all varnish, it's made by mixing a resin and a drying oil that is then heated together until the two combine into a new compound called varnish. In the case of Waterlox Original, the resin is phenolic and the oil is tung oil. The phenolic resin makes is harder than varnishes made with other resins and the tung oil gives the varnish slightly more water resistance.

The point is that Waterlox is a varnish made with tung oil, it's not tung oil.

So, Waterlox should be applied in the same manner as any other varnish. It should be brushed or wiped. It should not be wiped off. That just means that you end up using a lot more of the finish to end up with the proper film thickness. There are detailed application instructions on their website at www.waterlox.com.

All that said, if a finisher has had success using a different technique then he should continue. No need to change something you are happy with.

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#15

Net Net

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Howard,

Your point is well taken. Appears what is being done is the Waterlox is being used like a Danish oil to wet the surface fibers of the wood for some "pop" in the grain. He's then substituting the urethane resins for the film coating. This could be better than simply applying the poly because the urethane is not a penetrating finish. However, the same effect at less cost would be to use a Danish oil or even some BLO as it's cheaper than Waterlox and you're not mixing resins.

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#16

Ellis Walentine

Wiping varnishes

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Howard, for your observations. Personally, I have been using it for at least 40 years, mostly because of its handling characteristics and amber tone. It has its limitations, of course. It is rather soft, so it scratches easily, and its amber color might be too much on light woods.

When I first started using Waterlox ("Transparent," it was called, in the old orange-and-white can), it cost about $15 a gallon. Now that it has skyrocketed out of my price range (what, $40 a quart?), I've been using other varnishes with perfectly acceptable results, simply thinning them with naphtha or mineral spirits to a wiping consistency. I recently finished a large case piece with thinned spar varnish, using the same method I generally use with Waterlox. I also like General Finishes Seal-A-Cell. I find it very similar to Waterlox in appearance and handling, and it doesn't turn to jelly as quickly.

As you say, if it works for you, don't change it. The objective with any film finish is to build the appropriate millage on the wood surface. I try very hard not to put excess finish on the wood. At today's varnish prices, I'm particularly wary of any product or technique that ends up leaving most of the finish in the trash. I never use "Danish oil" finishes for this reason. First off, they're not Danish and they're not oil; they're mostly thinner with some long oil and some varnish in them. The only way I know to use Danish oil economically is to rub it on so thinly that you don't have any excess to wipe off. To me, it's not worth it. I can get that "close to the wood" look -- plus equally dust-free application and a lot more protection from alcohol and water -- with a couple very thin coats of Waterlox or other wiping varnish extended out to a practically dry surface.

My usual application technique was to use a small piece of cotton rag, soak it in Waterlox and wipe it on, replenishing the rag with more finish as necessary until I had attained the ideal film thickness for that coat -- not so thick that it sags and takes a long time to dry (with more dust problems), but not too thin and dry either. I often diluted the first coat 5% to 20% to improve the penetration and bring out the chatoyance of the wood. If I'm going for a thicker film, I brush or spray on a wet coat or two. I've even brushed on regular varnish for the "build" coats, sanding lightly with 280 or 320 stearated paper after each, and then finished the regime with a light coat or two of wiped-on Waterlox.

I've never settled on a "best" rag for applying varnish, as long as it is soft, lint-free, and doesn't have any synthetics in it. Cotton flannel. In fact (I hesitate to admit this), I get the best results -- no rag marks, no wasted finish at all -- by using my bare hands to massage the finish into the wood. I don't recommend this for the obvious safety reasons, but it is food for thought. You can probably get the same benefits safely if you use nitrile gloves to protect your skin. It works great on turned pieces, but I certainly wouldn't suggest it for larger work.

More fuel to the fire.

Ellis

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#17

Massage - Added Benefit

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

That "Naptha Buzz"

YMMV

:D

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#18

Re: Wiping varnishes

Bartstar

Ellis,

Thanks for your posting. In the past, I've applied Waterlox using a foam brush, flooded the surface, then wiped off the excess with a paper towel. A very wasteful technique. It also takes many coats to build an acceptable film. I recently tried just brushing it on and leaving it. I found this to not be acceptable as it allowed the Waterlox to drip/pool and takes to long to cure, thus allowing too many dust nibs to form. I like your idea of wiping it on instead. It looks like a more efficient way to apply it and not have most of it end up in the trash.

Thanks

Bart

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#19

Thats what I do too...

John in NM

After the first couple coats I find it builds quickly as the dried coats below seem to catalyze the following coats. Trick is to put it on thin as Ellis describes, a wipe or two and leave it alone. Out here in the desert I can get 4-6 coats per day on after the first couple have dried.

Re: Questions on using Waterlox

#20

Re: Drying

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Bart,

You can speed up the drying by adding up to 10% naptha BUT

1. Never add it to the can; and

2. never return "mixed" product to the can.

Reason is that the naptha will tend to start the jello stage much more quickly. I therefore only mix it in small amounts that I will use up in a single day as the next morning it'll be "gone."