It depends..Lawn and Garden WIKI (incredibly long)
Grant in Iowa
To me it depends on several things:
-How much lawn do you have?
-How is the lawn contoured and landscaped?
-Is mowing all you want to do?
-What is the budget?
If you have lots of grass...say an acre or more, and lots to mow around, and all you want to do is mow, then a zero turn machine is a no brainer. Pay attention to what the pros use in your area, and consider those brands. These machines can also tow a yard cart, dethatcher, and other light implements.
If, on the other hand, you have lots of hills, or need to mow a ditch or want to be able to till or do any ground engaging work, then a garden tractor is the way to go. Hyraulic lift, power steering, larger tires all mean easier to use. I like garden tractors because they are built heavier, and therefore usually last longer when compared to lawn tractors.
If you have up to an acre and a half or so, have more time than money, and aren't concerned about efficiency, then a tractor shaped machine (lawn tractor)will be the most bang for the buck. This class of machines is largely commoditized, which is to say that engine and transaxle wise they are mostly the same or at least similar. If it were me, I'd want the support of the nearest dealership for quick repairs and parts support. John Deere, Toro/ Wheel Horse, Cub Cadet, and Husqvarna are go-to brands in this category.
If you have a large space to mow, want to do much more than mow, would like to add attachments, and are interested in a "lifetime" type machine, then a compact utility machine would be my recommendation. Kubota, John Deere, and Cub Cadet make excellent products, all of which could easily last you a lifetime. Once you get to a machine with a true 3 point hitch, you can save immense amounts of money by being able to rent or buy a needed attachment for a reasonable sum. In my case, the loader has already saved me hours and hours of shoveling dirt, rock, mulch, etc. in only one year.
Whatever category you decide is right for you, research the brand and model number online before buying. Google something like "Cub cadet LTX1046 problem" in order to find out what the common failure mode is for a given model. Note that every machine has its weak points, but you are looking to make sure a given model doesn't have a chronic problem like a transaxle prone to failure. One or two reports of issues is fine, but a trend of failure on a costly part can tell you to steer clear of a given model.
On lawn and garden tractors, you may be able to select either hydrostatic drive, or gear drive. The right solution for you will depend on how much close mowing you do (edge to hydro), who will drive it, desired longevity(edge to gear drive), etc. If you end up going cheap disposable unit, then I'd recommend a gear drive for maximum longevity, as low cost hydro trasaxles are common failure points.
New or used? In the lawn tractor class, I would only buy new, since these machines generally are shorter life, disposable units. Maybe a newer used unit from ---say someone who is moving would be an option in this category. In Garden tractors, comercial zero turn, or compact utility machine class, used can be a good option. I would buy a used garden tractor long before I'd buy a new lawn tractor. Think contractor saw versus Unisaw.
Some features that I would look for in all classes of machine:
-Larger tires mean smoother ride and therefore faster mowing
-Larger decks mean more mowing speed, an effectively tighter turning radius, but less cut quality on contoured areas... larger decks CAN be used on uneven ground with attention and experience. On smooth lawns, a larger deck can provide a superior cut quality.
-Horsepower is NOT a measure of how much work a machine can do, instead it is a measure of how fast it can do it. V-twin engines run more smoothly and quietly (generally) than single cylinder machines. I would say that more than about 18 HP is a waste for anything under a 48" deck. 24 HP is plenty for a 60" deck. Kawasaki, Kohler, Honda, Robin, and Briggs are all good engine brands, presented in order of preference. A Diesel is far superior to any gas engine on a mower of any type in terms of longevity and performance.
-Before buying, look under the rear sheet-metal at the transaxles on the choices. Beefier axles, gearboxes, and linkages would get the nod if it were me making the decision. Here is where a garden tractor will show its value compared to an entry level lawn tractor.
-Look at the mower deck for grease zerks, beefier drive belts (or shaft drive on better machines), thicker sheet metal, and check the manual for how easy it is to remove the mower deck.
-Perhaps the most valuable issue is what implement dealer is closest to your home. It is very nice to have a dealership for your machine a few miles away when the grass needs cutting and you are broke down. Over the life of a machine, you could visit the dealership for various reasons dozens of times, which could traslate to hundreds saved if your dealership is close to home or at least on the way home from work.
In my case, I have only an acre of lawn, but need to move snow from 3000+ square feet of concrete in the winter. I also wanted to be able to move dirt, sawlogs, firewood, and other heavier work. I was at a point in my life where I wanted a long term solution and money wasn't as much of a consideration as long term value. I was looking at new garden tractors, but before I bought I decided to look at what my $8K would buy in the used market. It was overkill, but I ended up buying a 7 year old Kubota BX2200 machine with a loader and 60" deck. So far I am tickled beyond belief. Mowing is a comfortable pleasure that makes me smile, moving dirt, tilling, grading is all easily done. Remove the mower deck in two minutes. Install the loader in 2 minutes, remove it in less. Real category 1 3 point hitch means you buy attachments from any brand at any farm supply store. I bought it used with about 200 hours on it for $8500. I would submit that it could be considered a more economical purchase than buying a disposable machine every 5-8 years. Your needs and mileage may vary, but the value of a good machine lasts much longer than the sweetness of a low purchase price. I have noticed that in West Texas, used garden tractors and compact utility machines such as the Kubota BX series can be had for a song. Just another option. Just google "Used Kubota BX" and you'll find several web sites that have listings of machines for sale. Similarly, a used John Deere 400 series machine can be had for around $3000 for one in reasonable condition.
In the end, it is your needs, your money, and your decision. If you provide more details about your specific needs, we can help steer you to the right class of machine.
Regards,
Grant in Iowa