Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Posts

Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#1

Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Terry Alexander

Ok....My craftsman finally REALLY bit the dust. It has served me well for over 7 years, so for those that want to spell Craftsman with a "P", I humbly disagree.

NEWay....the Sears store in Abilene, TX now is under-staffed and I don't have any confidence in the "support" if I purchase another Craftsman.

So, I am looking to Lowe's for my riding lawn mower solution.

Lowe's stocks "Cub Cadet", "Troy Bilt", "John Deere", and "Husqvarna" mowers. I have an excellent relationship with the Lowe's manager (duh...we built our own house and most of it is decorated in "early Lowe's).

I am apt to steer away from the John Deere because I think I will be paying a 10-15% premium simply because of the name.

So, given these choices, I would really appreciate some recommendations from this very wise group.

Uh...I have to purchase quickly or I'll be up to my armpits in grass!

Thanking you in advance!

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#2

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Howard Norman

I have no experience with riding lawn mowers but based on the names that you list I would look very hard at the Husky if it was me. That company makes some very good stuff.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#3

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Ron Jones

I have an 11 year old JD F series that still mows 3/4 acre as quickly and neatly as it did on the first day I owned it. That being said the JD products from big box stores are not the same as those from a JD dealer. My next door neighbor couldn't get his JD rider from HD to meet his expectations and the JD dealers in the area to help him. After a couple of years he traded it for a Kubota riding mower. My Husky push mower has been a major disappointment from day one--not much help from the dealer either. I have purchased my last Husqvarna product.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#4

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

Cub Cadet is a decent for the price middle of the line mower. It is part of the MTD family. You're right about the JD. You pay a premium for the name, I had a used one from a JD dealer and it was barely acceptable. I traded it in after two seasons. My daughter has a Husky. While the engine and drive train are good, , the deck quality is less than the Cadet. I had to replace the rack & pinion(sp?) after 5 years of wear, about $80 and 4r hrs labor. I believe the Troy Built is now also owned by MTD and also has about a 10% name premium. Of those you are looking at I'd go with the Cadet. Parts are readily available and servicing is easy to fine.

Good luck,

John

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#5

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Stuart Johnson

I have also heard that JD from big box stores were different than those sold through the dealers. However, the only place I've heard that is in discussions like this not from a JD dealer or someone that knows for fact. That doesn't mean it isn't true. Anyway, I bought a JD from Lowes last year and so far I'm happy with it. It carries a sticker on the back with the name of a dealer in the county and the Lowes guy told me there stock came from that dealership. I was also told by Lowes they could not offer free delivery because of some sort of competition clause.

With all the rip offs, biased and partial news in the paper and on television, I've become such a cynic I don't believe too much of what I hear. Go with what owners say they have personally experience. My JD is meeting all of my requirements but it is only a year old. My first riding mower was a Craftsman that lasted a good 12 years. I will no longer purchase anything from Sears for another reason so my next one was from Tractor Supply. Stuff started falling off about year two and it finally gave up after five. This one had better last ten to fifteen or it's going to be goats or maybe sheep.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#6

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I doubt thaere's any difference between a JD L110 at Home Depot, and the same model at a dealers. Both look/seem identical. (I bought mine from a dealer.)

I probably paid a hundred bucks or so more from the dealer than I might've at HD, but my dealer provides SERVICE. If I were to have a problem (I haven't, and the JD is going on six years old) my dealer will pick it up, take it to his shop, fix it and return it. What would HD do? I'm guessing they's say "Take it to a dealer." Why would a dealer want to work on it if he didn't sell it? There's surely no incentive there.

My dealer also sells Toro and Cub Cadet, as well as Stihl and Honda smaller equipment. My dealer is Do-Cut Equipment & Hardware in Boardman, Ohio.

BTW, if I recall correctly, TroyBilt was sold a couple years back, and their machines are now made by MTD.

Jim D.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#7

William A. Roland

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

William A. Roland

My wife loved her 54" cut Cub Cadet. It sold real quick in our estate sale.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#8

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

Well Terry, I'll addd my two cents worth. I had an old Husky years ago and it gave good service - ussed when I got it.

I replaced it 15 years ago with a Simplicity Broadmoor (sp?) with a 14 Hp Kohler, 36" swath. I just, last week, replaced the rear tires. I have had no problems with the mechanicals other than a stuck brake and replacing the bearings on the mower three yrs ago.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#9

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Gary Smyth

I own a Cub Cadet 1450, vintage 1978. It was made when International Harvester owned the brand. It's a honker. It cuts two acres often twice a week in the spring growing season. I'd rebuild that workhorse before I'd consider any new machine. A lot of others agree with me.

Alas, after thirty plus years, this spring, the PTO oil seal went. Not an extensive repair but I had to take a whole bunch of stuff out to get into the engine. It has taken me some time to repair this as I have never done it before, so the grass up until today was about a foot tall. Today my neighbor brought over the Tank. The commercial version of the Cub Cadet zero turn lawn mower. It�s a terrific machine! Cut the lawn twice (4� and then 2 1/2 �) in the time the old machine would take in a normal cutting. Full power and turns without the hassle of doing a �cloverleaf� to make the next path. But it�s hard to hold a straight line and if you get too close on a turn, you can be certain you'll rip out some expensive landscaping. The Tank is a commercial monster, but it sure does the job. Now the bad news. It is not the most stable thing on hills and there is no way to pull a cart at the rear, or install a snow plow on the front. So if all you have is flat ground, and a lot of it, the zero turn could be your baby. If you need it to serve other purposes than just cutting grass be sure to buy a tractor.

No matter what you buy, be sure you can get it to the repair place. Find a place where the mechanic isn't eighteen years old. If necessary consider buying a trailer too -- even more investment. Whatever you do, do the research. Get something reliable and more importantly a (good) dealer that is close. It will save you a bundle over the life of the tractor. My dealer charges $60/hr., plus parts. If he has to pay a house call, the travel fee is $1 a mile (each way from the shop) and minimum $25 then the labor and parts. For him to transport the beast to the shop is a flat $60 within twenty miles. If you are going to Lowes remember that even the managers there are in for two-three years and then moved. What is a good relationship today probably will not be there when the machine decides that its time to fix stuff. If the Deere is more expensive now check the web for reliability, it may be the better choice by a long shot. I�m not changing my Cadet (the way I see it, they're still flying DC3s) but my old IH is not today�s Cadet consumer version. Hope this helps.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#10

MTD makes most of them

Joe Pack

Cub Cadet, Troy Built, Sears,....pick 'em...MTD makes most of them. You can compare them right down to the bolt holes and find them to be essentially the same machine. Differences are in linkages, deck thickness, engine specs...

As for prices, there is not $50 difference between the Cub Cadet at TSC/Lowe's/you name the box and your local dealer. Cub Cadet, John Deere, Troy Built...all the "names" dictate the selling price of their mowers, which is why there is essentially no difference in the price on a specific model no matter where you buy it. The difference is service! In most cases the independent dealer will go through your mower and make sure it is set up before you take delivery while the box stores take them off the stack of pallets and tell you to go ahead and load it up. And try taking your mower back to HD or Lowe's for warranty repair...they will refer you to a service center, which just happens to be your local independent dealer! And guess whose mower he will work on first, yours bought at HD or mine bought from him?

Been there, done that, and learned. I buy lots of stuff at the boxes, but never again will I buy a decent mower anywhere but at an independent dealer I trust.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#11

My JD 4 years and counting

Dustmaker Mike

I bought my JD LA110 three years ago used at Lowes. It has cut flat and level no problems at all. I use it to pull a cart full of dirt and rocks etc and it does not even notice. I did send it in this year for the first time to my local JD dealer for service Tune up deck leveling etc belt tension and it came back to me in a week just as promised. My local dealer seems not to care where the mower came from they do the same great work. I do buy my oil filters etc there every year so I can do my own service. If I where looking for another one with the options you named I would not think about the Troy built or MTD not sure of the Cub because I have repaired to many newer ones for neighbors that live around me. Broken deck springs pulleys binding bearings and rusted decks after three of four years of residential use. My 2 Bits

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#12

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Dale Stansbery

I have a Husky 2348 starting it's 3'rd year, and just under 100 hours. It has a Briggs engine and the starter/battery combo power has been marginal from day one. If I stop the engine for a few minutes, sometimes the starter won't kick over against the compression. I just have to wait a little longer for it to cool off a little, then it will start OK. The only service problem I've had is when it was new, an idler pulley bolt snapped and the pulley went flying out into the yard. It was obviously a fluke faulty bolt. All in all, I'd buy another Husky, but may opt for one with a Kohler engine rather than the Briggs.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#13

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

MTD Yardman from Lowes was dead after four years. JD L110 still going strong after seven years of cutting 2.5 acres of steep mountainside. Ditto on MTD, Cub, Bolens, Troy are all the same machine.

Bought JD from dealer...same price as Lowes but he delivered it with full tank of gas and oil and taught wife how to drive it! He drove thirty miles round trip for free.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#14

I know you said something from Lowes *LINK*

Christopher Fitch Memphis

...but I'd advise getting a Snapper. My grandfather had one for decades, my dad used one when he mowed yards during his off time from the fire dept. and I have had one for 6 years now and it's going strong.

On top of that you should read the link I included. The Snapper CEO rejected selling his mowers at Walmart.


The Man Who Said No to Wal-Mart

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#15

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Art

i have a john deere that i bought at lowes two years ago. The local jd dealer had to inspect it before lowes could sell it. i got the zero turn 42 inch and it is avery stable mower.very satified. I also owen a 46 inch troy blit. the jd will do the work in half the time. both mowers are excelent mowers.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#16

Re: I know you said something from Lowes

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

Christopher,

Interesting story. Thanks for the link.

Al

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#17

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Joe Burke

I bought a Cub Cadet LT1042 from Lowe's. Lowe's will, apparently, take anything back on return, and someone had used this mower for 11 hrs. and brought it back. $1200 bucks, and that pretty much dictated my purchase choice.

There was a short in the electrical system that caused it to blow fuses, but I seem to have beat that down. Might very well be why it was returned. I had to replace a steering assembly part this year. (3rd year with me)

I'm not really surprised to hear that it's an MTD product. Disappointed but not surprised.

Bottom line is it doesn't cut grass all that well.

I looked into a Simplicity recently because someone on another forum said they were great. Maybe so, but it came with a price tag ... as many things do. Their smallest lawn tractor, made in the same style as my cub, starts at $2500.

Based on it's quality of cut I won't buy a cub again. I'm afraid though, that like my woodworking tools, getting the performance I want will mean paying for it.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#18

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

del schisler

i have a 48"cut Husqvarna and it will cut grass Not all that much $$$ just my 2 cents

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#19

It depends..Lawn and Garden WIKI (incredibly long)

Grant in Iowa

To me it depends on several things:

-How much lawn do you have?

-How is the lawn contoured and landscaped?

-Is mowing all you want to do?

-What is the budget?

If you have lots of grass...say an acre or more, and lots to mow around, and all you want to do is mow, then a zero turn machine is a no brainer. Pay attention to what the pros use in your area, and consider those brands. These machines can also tow a yard cart, dethatcher, and other light implements.

If, on the other hand, you have lots of hills, or need to mow a ditch or want to be able to till or do any ground engaging work, then a garden tractor is the way to go. Hyraulic lift, power steering, larger tires all mean easier to use. I like garden tractors because they are built heavier, and therefore usually last longer when compared to lawn tractors.

If you have up to an acre and a half or so, have more time than money, and aren't concerned about efficiency, then a tractor shaped machine (lawn tractor)will be the most bang for the buck. This class of machines is largely commoditized, which is to say that engine and transaxle wise they are mostly the same or at least similar. If it were me, I'd want the support of the nearest dealership for quick repairs and parts support. John Deere, Toro/ Wheel Horse, Cub Cadet, and Husqvarna are go-to brands in this category.

If you have a large space to mow, want to do much more than mow, would like to add attachments, and are interested in a "lifetime" type machine, then a compact utility machine would be my recommendation. Kubota, John Deere, and Cub Cadet make excellent products, all of which could easily last you a lifetime. Once you get to a machine with a true 3 point hitch, you can save immense amounts of money by being able to rent or buy a needed attachment for a reasonable sum. In my case, the loader has already saved me hours and hours of shoveling dirt, rock, mulch, etc. in only one year.

Whatever category you decide is right for you, research the brand and model number online before buying. Google something like "Cub cadet LTX1046 problem" in order to find out what the common failure mode is for a given model. Note that every machine has its weak points, but you are looking to make sure a given model doesn't have a chronic problem like a transaxle prone to failure. One or two reports of issues is fine, but a trend of failure on a costly part can tell you to steer clear of a given model.

On lawn and garden tractors, you may be able to select either hydrostatic drive, or gear drive. The right solution for you will depend on how much close mowing you do (edge to hydro), who will drive it, desired longevity(edge to gear drive), etc. If you end up going cheap disposable unit, then I'd recommend a gear drive for maximum longevity, as low cost hydro trasaxles are common failure points.

New or used? In the lawn tractor class, I would only buy new, since these machines generally are shorter life, disposable units. Maybe a newer used unit from ---say someone who is moving would be an option in this category. In Garden tractors, comercial zero turn, or compact utility machine class, used can be a good option. I would buy a used garden tractor long before I'd buy a new lawn tractor. Think contractor saw versus Unisaw.

Some features that I would look for in all classes of machine:

-Larger tires mean smoother ride and therefore faster mowing

-Larger decks mean more mowing speed, an effectively tighter turning radius, but less cut quality on contoured areas... larger decks CAN be used on uneven ground with attention and experience. On smooth lawns, a larger deck can provide a superior cut quality.

-Horsepower is NOT a measure of how much work a machine can do, instead it is a measure of how fast it can do it. V-twin engines run more smoothly and quietly (generally) than single cylinder machines. I would say that more than about 18 HP is a waste for anything under a 48" deck. 24 HP is plenty for a 60" deck. Kawasaki, Kohler, Honda, Robin, and Briggs are all good engine brands, presented in order of preference. A Diesel is far superior to any gas engine on a mower of any type in terms of longevity and performance.

-Before buying, look under the rear sheet-metal at the transaxles on the choices. Beefier axles, gearboxes, and linkages would get the nod if it were me making the decision. Here is where a garden tractor will show its value compared to an entry level lawn tractor.

-Look at the mower deck for grease zerks, beefier drive belts (or shaft drive on better machines), thicker sheet metal, and check the manual for how easy it is to remove the mower deck.

-Perhaps the most valuable issue is what implement dealer is closest to your home. It is very nice to have a dealership for your machine a few miles away when the grass needs cutting and you are broke down. Over the life of a machine, you could visit the dealership for various reasons dozens of times, which could traslate to hundreds saved if your dealership is close to home or at least on the way home from work.

In my case, I have only an acre of lawn, but need to move snow from 3000+ square feet of concrete in the winter. I also wanted to be able to move dirt, sawlogs, firewood, and other heavier work. I was at a point in my life where I wanted a long term solution and money wasn't as much of a consideration as long term value. I was looking at new garden tractors, but before I bought I decided to look at what my $8K would buy in the used market. It was overkill, but I ended up buying a 7 year old Kubota BX2200 machine with a loader and 60" deck. So far I am tickled beyond belief. Mowing is a comfortable pleasure that makes me smile, moving dirt, tilling, grading is all easily done. Remove the mower deck in two minutes. Install the loader in 2 minutes, remove it in less. Real category 1 3 point hitch means you buy attachments from any brand at any farm supply store. I bought it used with about 200 hours on it for $8500. I would submit that it could be considered a more economical purchase than buying a disposable machine every 5-8 years. Your needs and mileage may vary, but the value of a good machine lasts much longer than the sweetness of a low purchase price. I have noticed that in West Texas, used garden tractors and compact utility machines such as the Kubota BX series can be had for a song. Just another option. Just google "Used Kubota BX" and you'll find several web sites that have listings of machines for sale. Similarly, a used John Deere 400 series machine can be had for around $3000 for one in reasonable condition.

In the end, it is your needs, your money, and your decision. If you provide more details about your specific needs, we can help steer you to the right class of machine.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#20

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

iew

Terry: Here on the ranch not counting the big stuff, we have 4 JD mowers. One of the mowers is a 1965 model 110, had to put in a new Koehler short block about 25 years ago and it still runs great. The JD you buy at Lowe's or HD is not quite the same you buy at a JD dealer. The JD dealer machines will have Koehler or Kawasaki engines, my favorite is the Kawasaki. When I had my JD dealerships we sold hundreds of lawn tractors without any problems. For the customer that wanted to go cheap we sold a Murray rider that would last at best 3 years. My friends that bought Deere's over 30 years ago are still satisfied, that's quality.

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#21

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Good afternoon, Terry.

We are now on our second Snapper walk-behind. The first one lasted around 20 years, and used up two engines in the process. The first excuse for an engine was a Briggs& S*** "vac-u-jet". I hope the guy who invented that carburetor system was eventually tied to an anthill. That was replaced with a Kohler 5hp that ran alike a top for the better part of 16 years.

The new Snapper was purchased in 2006. The original machine had a Kawasaki engine but no electric start. LOML, who does the trim mowing demanded an electric start, so I had to swap for a Briggs&S***. NO fault of Snapper. I just got it back from it's first tuneup for a little over $100. Not bad for 4 years with no maintenance except for oil changes and blowing out the air filter. Being as how the two of us are rapidly approaching 70, this may be the last mower we will need to buy. I certainly feel that way about my Scag Tiger Cub ZTR.

Buying a mower is like buying tools, buy quality and spend you money once.

Happy sawdust,

Ken

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#22

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

Jim Dillon

Hi Terry,

I went through this about six weeks ago when my 45 year old Jacobson suffered a lethal (but not fatal) steering gear failure. You've gotten lots of great advice. After a couple of weeks visiting the local John Deere, Cub Cadet, and Simplicity dealer(s), I ended up getting the Simplicity Broadmoor. Along the way, I think I learnt the following:

1. Be prepared for sticker shock;

2. Realistically examine your present and future needs;

3. Consider used or new;

4. Set a budget;

5. Within a price range based on my budget, all the mentioned brands offer competitive mowers wrt specifications etc.;

6. Consider the relationship you will have with the dealer and the proximity of the dealer to you;

7. Collect and study the brochures; there are differences between models within a price range that might be important to you;

8. If you are a DIYer, how easy is it to change the oil and filter, lube the pulleys etc.; and

8. Let Google be your friend. As suggested, type in a brand and model and you will be amazed at the info that is out there on the garden and tractor forums. In fact, it appears that some folks collect lawn/garden tractors like woodworkers collect routers and clamps :) .

I am pleased with my purchase, but still getting used to all the safety interlocking devices now mandated; be sure to check out how each brand handles the reverse interlock as there are differences.

Feel free to e-mail me if you want more info. Hope this helps.

Jim

PS. Thanks to a friendly local welder, I now have the old Jacobson nearly up and running again and am taking this opportunity to do some other restoration work on it; maybe I can get another 45 years out of it!

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#23

Re: I know you said something from Lowes

Jim Dillon

Christopher,

As the recent buyer of a Simplicity mower, I found the article very interesting. Thanks for posting the link!

Jim

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#24

Simply stated, get a Simplicity

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

When our Craftsman was dying, we parked it out front and sold it. We bought a Simplicity after trying all the brands. Try looking at Simplicity,they have several levels of mowers depending upon the size of the area. I have one of their Regent series mowers with the hydrostatic drive an it is a great machine. My wife loves the small turn radius and ease of use. The infinitely variable speed is nice as the conditions of your lawn change while you are cutting. We're starting our fourth year year with ours. We cut an acre of grass.

Be aware that the Troy Bilt and Cub cadet and other Borg brands are all owned by MTD are essentially the same mowers.

My son purchased a Craftsman the same time we purchased our tractor and he has had several annoying engine problems and there are a lot of plastic parts.

Lee

Re: Opinions wanted - riding lawn mowers - OT

#25

Re: MTD makes most of them

George, Oxford, NC

I will never buy another piece of equipment made by any MTD division. This is my personal opinion after have trouble with three different MTD divisions in regards to warranty issues and their not standing behind them. I now have a Snapper rider that is 10 years old and cranks within 3 seconds of twisting the key.

Did I mention, I hate MTD, and will bad-mouth them on any occasion I get.

George