Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

Posts

***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Yes, folks, we're actually launching our latest survey **on time** for a change. As our regulars know, every two months, on the "ides" (usually the 15th) of the month, we toss out a new and thought-provoking question about some woodworking-related issue. We compile and edit your answers and send them off to our friends at Woodworker West magazine for publication in our bi-monthly "News & Views" column. (You can view past columns in our News & Views department, accessible from the Articles menu at left. Please forgive our overworked production department for being a couple years behind in uploading our previous columns.)

At any rate, May is the time of year (speaking for myself) when lofty shop ambitions and idealized projects tend to give way to practical projects in and around the house. So, this month, I thought I'd ask: "How does *your* woodworking activity change from season to season? Do you tend to do more complicated, thoughtful projects during the winter and more utilitarian projects in the spring and summer? Do you spend more time in the shop between December and March than you do between April and September? Is your work generally more "artistic" or "functional," and does that balance change with the time of year?

NOTE: This survey is part of my ongoing interest in "art" vs "design" -- not that they are mutually exclusive. Art may be (and usually is) designed in some way, even if it has no express function (except possibly to stimulate a reaction in the viewer), and designed objects are usually artistic as well as functional. I've long maintained that we are designers and mechanics first and woodworkers second (or third or...). Our passion for solving problems and using our hands and minds to produce objects of beauty and/or function is what unites us in this activity we call woodworking. Please feel free to confirm or challenge this perception in your reply and to expand on the original question if you see fit. I'll look forward to your thoughts.

Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Woodworker West Magazine

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#2

JL

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May***

JL

"How does *your* woodworking activity change from season to season?"

Gardening is important. I have to do more lawn work in the spring and summer. I also like hiking. Therefore I spend less time indoors. I do like to do spindle preparation in the spring - when I can do it outdoors - I'd rather rake than sweep.

The type of woodworking doesn't really change - just the amount.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May***

Gary Smyth

I live in Pennsylvania. The shop is my garage converted to a shop. I store almost everything dealing with woodworking with the exception of books in that area. From December to April I�m pretty much out of business for anything other than house maintenance requirements. The holidays interfere, wood is cold, paint freezes, clear finishes dry squirrely, glue won�t set up. Even with heat of sorts, I don�t like the fumes or the danger of open flame with all the inflammables in the area.

As for the other stuff. No matter what I make I have to make it �mine�. Most of my projects are of others design and my tweaking. If it�s practical stuff like building shop furniture or jigs, stands, storage, tables, and the like, I typically take existing stuff and make it conform to what I have as tools and the way I work. The changes may be major or minor but the idea most often came from an article, book, picture, or magazine. This happens as I need it, but Fall is productive when the yard work is in decline and football is on the TV or radio. Also, the temperatures are cooler and the humidity is lower. Spring is next productive as I get antsy when I haven�t had full access to the shop for three months. Spring is when the plans for the �good stuff� get action. I do one or two big projects a year. The design is pretty much worked out over winter by April and work can start as soon as daily temperatures get above 50 (F) degrees. The woodworking normally takes several weeks of the time and finishing, for me, takes as long and usually longer. I need the luxury of time. What I make is for me and close family and friends, and everything I make is one time only, so I often stop what I�m doing before proceeding to the next step to check drawings, hardware, measurments etc. to make certain that what I do next does not cause me problems down the line. For example, I often finish some pieces before final assembly because I don�t want sloppy finish in the back corner of something even if it won�t be seen. That can be its own problem, but I prefer to work that way. In addition, if I wait until summer for the finishing, the humidity will cause other problems. That�s the way it works for me. Hope it helps.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#4

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May***

Stuart Hough

I am always planning and designing in my head. No seasonal differences to that. What does differ is that from October thru February I'm so busy at work (grocery store) setting up/changing over and giving outstanding customer service that I have little energy to get into the gara...er...shop for anything other than fixit items. Starting in March I get my ideas on paper and start gathering together the supplies and material I'll need and get started on some new project that allows me to try a new technique or process that I haven't tried before. I split my efforts pretty equally between nice stuff for the wife and shop stuff for me, though the last 15 months have been spent mainly on the workbench build. It does take a long time at 1-2 hours average per week.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May***

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Since the basement shop was mostly turned into a storeroom when adult daughter moved back home for grad school, there's very little room to work with power tools (actually, no room to work safely). I did, however, get the Stubby ensconced in the garage, so with the advent of reasonable weather I'll be able to turn.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#6

reply

Bill Tindall

Do you tend to do more complicated, thoughtful projects during the winter and more utilitarian projects in the spring and summer?*****No. I live on a farm and spring on the farm offers little opportunity to do inside work. My peak woodworking times are mid summer when heat drives me indoors and Winter when there isn't much outside work that needs doing.

Do you spend more time in the shop between December and March than you do between April and September?****No

Is your work generally more "artistic" or "functional,"*****I build to satisfy a need.

and does that balance change with the time of year? No

I've long maintained that we are designers and mechanics first and woodworkers second (or third or...).*****Then how do you explain the popularity of building from plans where the design and construction porblems have been provided? I believe a great many woodworkers build to satisfy a need. Personally, I never have built anything from a plan. It follows an from an attitude that anything can be improved upon/optimized. Personally, I do like design, and problem solving.

Our passion for solving problems and using our hands and minds to produce objects of beauty and/or function is what unites us in this activity we call woodworking.*****What unites me to WoodCentral is the availability of expertise in a multitude of areas. Otherwise, I am a woodworking introvert.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#7

'Tis The Season

David Yoho

Generally speaking, I think woodworking activity for most is greater in the "off season", primarily due to the time of year or season.

This increase of shop activity during the winter months goes back farther than the days when our forefathers worked their fields and livestock to make a meager living and feed their families. Between the growing season and the harvest season, days were long, the work was hard, and spare time was in short supply. Once the harvest season ended, the days grew shorter, and the nights got colder. With the change of seasons and more free time on their hands, people turned to indoor activities.

While most of today's modern families no longer have to grub out an existence like those before us, the time between the growing season (spring) and harvest season (fall) is filled with job and family demands. Between long hours at work, running the kids to all of their activities, keeping up with the yard, and vacations, there is little time to spend in the shop.

The seasonal change to winter provides relief of outdoor chores, allowing more time to work on things indoors where it's warm and dry. For this reason, I believe most home woodworkers take on more complicated, thoughtful projects during the winter and more utilitarian projects in the spring and summer. It's no different than before. If our forefathers needed another hay rake, they took only the time required to make or repair one. If they needed a hutch, it had to wait until the crops were harvested to feed the family through the winter.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May***

Jesse Cloud

"How does *your* woodworking activity change from season to season?

I may not be typical: I'm retired and I live in the desert (not much yard work). There are some tasks I save up for warmer weather when I can spray outdoors (not having a paint booth in the garage).

Do you tend to do more complicated, thoughtful projects during the winter and more utilitarian projects in the spring and summer? Not much difference there, though I do like to sit by the fireplace with a couple of the FWW Design books in the winter.

Do you spend more time in the shop between December and March than you do between April and September?

No, and the reason is that I'm pretty much 'up with the sun', so my days are longer in the summer.

Is your work generally more "artistic" or "functional," and does that balance change with the time of year?

Everything I do is functional. I am trying to build more "art" and thoughtful design into it, though. Hardly ever build anything without some curves now.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#9

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May***

Dave Paine

The time I spend in the workshop is not seasonal. I try to spend time each weekend depending on other crisis, such as the wife's PC needing to be fixed.

So far all my work has been functional, but over the years I have tried to incorporate more artistic touches, such as inlay's with different colourful species, shape, edge design, etc.

I have seen many artistic pieces in links, articles. One day I may get the inspiration to make an artistic piece.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May***

Ed Henderson

Hi Ellis,

I retired 3 yrs ago and so since then everything is transforming a bit.

Last Oct 2009, things were a bit cool in my garage shop so I buckled it up a bit. I have woodworking magazines that span the last 20 yrs, hundreds and hundreds, so I started through them and spent a few hours each day reading. I made plans over the winter for a few projects and researched them and got supplies and equipment ready for my startup.

I should mention that before retirement I kept the shop heated so was out there on weekends. After retirement and now on a fixed income, although it's reasonably liberal, I turned off the nat gas heat to save a few bucks( actually about $70.00 per month). So no more weekends.

In March 2010 I got back out there more or less regularly and started on some projects, one of which will be some bookcases to house all these woodworking mags. In addition, over the winter I acquired a new Dovetail jig and a power sharpening system so the first projects involved designing and making a sharpening storage unit and a storage unit to house and complement my new dovetail jig and it's multitude of accessories.

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May*** *LINK*

#11

Re: ***SURVEY: The Ides of May***

mdclor

Ellis,

My shop is heated year around so I don't really have to deal with seasonality issues; when I finish one project I start another. I tend to make nicer projects from plans or pictures and shop related items are very utilitarian of my own design. While I don't have any set plan or schedule, it seems that I tend to do a shop project, then something for our house or family. That is probably based on "needing" a new tool for the nicer project and the new tool needs a home of some sort. I usually have 3-4 days per week available for hobby time and home maintenance so woodworking probably gets the lions share of 2 days per week.

FWIW,

Merle