Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

Posts

Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#1

Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics?  *LINK*

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Just reading a new article which states that they think there is a large plume not making it to the surface. I am having trouble getting my mind around that, unless the oil changes density while under pressure at that depth.

Sounds like new rules for physics to me. I am having trouble buying this explanation. Specific gravity of Oil, 0.88.

Seems like they are not very close to stopping the leak any time soon. No telling how this DISASTER chapter will end.


http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/05/13/wheres-the-oil-your-gover_n_575647.html

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#2

JL

Some things to consider..

JL

Oil is only has a limited solubility in sea water. It also is less dense than sea water. So yes - you would expect it to float.

However - at the pressure that the oil is spewing out of the sea bed, you have a very good chance of forming an oil/water emulsion. This would have a density closer to that of sea water. You are also talking about a lot of water in the Gulf. If your solubility is 0.001%, that means 10 liters (2.6 gallons) per cubic meter of sea water. Various organic materials (plankton, etc.) may end up soaking up some oil.

So - some of the oil will be dissolved. Some will be dispersed. Some will be adsorbed. Some will form an emulsion. Some will float up to the surface. Where ever it goes - it is still bad news.

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#3

Re: Some things to consider..

Doug Ridley

Check this out. I say leave it to the good ole boys.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k5SxX2EntEo

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#4

Lee Grindinger

I'm impressed!

Lee Grindinger

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#5

More info

Doug Ridley

These guys work for CW Roberts, big contractor in Walton County , Florida .

They have just received contract to do the "HAY THING" for all the 26 miles of Walton County, Florida beaches including Sandestin..

They start off shore with tug boats and barges spreading or blowing the hay over the oil.

If this works it will make Janet Neapolitan, or whatever her name is, and the EPA look silly.

Didn't know if you had seen this. Farmers to the rescue.

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#6

Lee Grindinger

I REALLY hope this works

Lee Grindinger

Simple solutions are generally the best, I hope this works as well in the real world as it does in a demonstration on a tabletop. It could change the way oil spills are handled.

Lee

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#7

easier and more accessable than hair.

John Lucas

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#8

Re: Tar sinks.... doesn't it?

Brian in Brighton

As I understand the oil coming out is heavy crude, so it has a lot of tars in it. Perhaps that is why some stays below the sruface too? I heard one oil guy say it would be like ribbons in the water, not just on top.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#9

Bravo!

Jennifer Indy.USA

This is fantastic! I hope they get the chance to try this. Seems the people in charge are a bunch of bumbling you know whats. I can't beleive this thing is still spewing.

Ugh >(

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#10

Just got back...

Tony - Memphis

We were just down in Walton County on vacation. They had removed the hay that was on the beach just before we got there becuase it was "scaring" the tourists. I never saw it, but I did see a large boat just south of grayton beach and wondered what they were doing. I bet that was the hay boat! A local shop owner told us about it. The beaches were their normal beautful selves while we were there. Hope they stay that way.

Tony (still daydreaming about the beach)

Re: Back to the Gulf Oil Spill, New Physics? *LINK*

#11

Good call JL.

Jim Dillon

I was just reading my latest issue of Chemical and Engineering News (May 10) where a geochemist at LSU said that tested samples of the oil contain high levels of asphaltenes, the high-molecular component of oil. Asphaltenes promote emulsification which will happen as the oil travels to the surface especially, as you point out, at those pressures. Unlike oil leaks from surface tankers, this emulsification will slow down the normal evaporation of the volatile components of surface oil. Less evaporation of the more volatile (and toxic) chemicals will mean that what hits the shore will be more toxic than normal. To make matters worse, the article states that the chemical dispersants don't work nearly as well on emulsions as unmixed oil. Plus emulsions take up a much larger volume, thus making the problem larger. Pretty depressing and I think things are going to get much, much worse as the oil spill is now reported to be entering the eddy current that will carry it around Florida and up the east coast. Anyway, thanks for your insight.

Jim