Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

Posts

OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#1

OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

Barry Irby

I looked at a balcony on a condominium yesterday. It had Trex type decking spaced about a 1/4" apart. The frame was supported by a treated wood frame that was in turn cased in one of the man made wood fiber product. There were treated 6X6's boxed in to appear to be about 12x12". The beams were boxed to also appear to be about 12 x 12", but in fact the treated beam was 3 2x10's. There was about 4" of "air space" on one side of the treated beam and I could not see into the other side. By using a mirror I could look into the cavities at the top of the beam under the deck supporting the balcony.

There is nothing to stop rain dripping from the decking above from running into the top of the beam. A few leaves were already in there. There were ample opportunities for birds nests and several were present.

My concern is that the leaves and other debris will turn into potting soil and keep the inside of the beam soggy. The water can drool out of the joints in the beams and run down inside the posts. Does anybody believe this will be successful and that this material can be durable in this application?

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#2

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

Andy Wright - Allen, TX

The trex will probably survive, but the moisture, bird nests, and leaves will accellerate the rotting of the beam (and unfortunately I dont think the Trex is strong enough to carry the load once the wood rots away)

If the gap is that big, the original builder should have put some sort of barrier at the top to keep "big" stuff like leaves and animals out. Can they add some ventholes and/or weepholes to the post and beam boxes?

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#3

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

Barry Irby

My thinking was that if they had put a top on the beams, even if it did not keep ALL of theater out, AND had install drainage and vents, they probably would have held up much longer.

And interesting thing was that every column was twisted, just the way treated 6 x 6's twist. I'm guessing they built the deck out of wet treated lumber and wrapped them immediately. Then they twisted.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#4

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Down the line, there's going to be a very happy remodeling contractor, charging good money to repair the problems created. The ventilation details should have been a lot better.

I know the modern wood treatment does not make as strong a distinction between ground contact and non-ground contact as the older CCA stuff, but I would bet that, if you can buy non-ground-contact pressure treated wood, these are.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#5

Sounds like a recipe for decay to me

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I always try to build where there is flashing from above, and breathing space between layers of build-up beams.

When crud from falling leaves and pollen etc can get between layers, then the potting mix will get in there and rot just about anything.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#6

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

George Koch

Barry, I would recommend that they at least remove the beam cover material on the hollow side and build out the top of the 3~ 2x10s solid with treated material, and also opening the boxed posts and correct the twisting and then drilling some weep holes for air circulation both in the posts and bottom of the beams. George

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#7

Re: Real Danger Will Robinson!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Barry,

You should know that the failure to flash the top of that beam is a recipe for disaster. The boxing material will prevent proper inspection and accelerate rot until the whole structure just collapses; usually when loaded with the maximum number of victims. For the homeowner's (purchaser's) benefit, I'd see no real option to removing the synthetic sheathing, jacking the entire structure off the beam, then properly flashing the beam to keep it dry before reinstalling the boxing with proper ventilation/drainage. The flashing must overlap the sheathing material when that is replaced. BTW, don't be too awfully surprised if you find that beam is not treated wood. I've seen several jobs like this where the mutt, saving a couple of bucks to beat another bid, told the homeowner that it didn't need treated wood because it wasn't in ground contact. [You'd better write a monster exception on your report!!!]

A twisted 6x6 is still structurally sound unless it has broken its tie to the footings or is otherwise unsound. (Have you checked that the stooge didn't just pour mushrooms?) The columns definitely need weep holes.

Sounds like this was built by some joker working out of his trunk with the word "Doctor" in his business name.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#8

Re: Real Danger Will Robinson!

Barry Irby

Mark, The amazing thing was this was on a condominium selling for over $625,000 (really big bucks here) and there are a bunchum. (Bunchum is Southern for more than a few.)

I am wondering if I should not go to the local Building Official and inform him?

Many of these units were sitting empty. We walked up and down the row and found that the twisted columns were pretty much universal. Which ever end had the weakest connection twisted. They were standing on a slab and most of them twisted at the bottom but some of them twisted at the top. Now that you mention it, I could not see the bottom attachment at all.

I pointed out the the buyer that the boxing material was not designed to remain saturated and would surely fail. That soon, brown drool would start to run out of the joints. And that at best the condo association would simply come back with a one time assessment for the repair/replacement, because everybody has one.

This is completely outside the structural issues.

As an aside, a Condo Group that was managing almost 400 units asked me to consult on their rotting railings. This was a picturesque river side group with what looked like a mile of railings. Very nautical. The rails were about six years old and falling apart. What could they do? Oh! Dear, Oh Dear! I suggest vinyl rails. No! Wrong appearance. Powder coated aluminum Rails? No, again wrong appearance. Custom Redwood rails? (or other suitable decay resistant wood.) Are you kidding, that will cost several thousand per unit, well above a million dollars, if not two million. They took my last suggestion. Put a carpenter on staff who does nothing but repair rails.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#9

Suggestion

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Have them contact their liability insurer and ask IT what they should do. If they still have a policy after the call, I've little doubt there'll be some serious work being done by the Group and the Group's attorney.

No fixing and just sitting on the slab? And you're gonna call the guy who approved and then inspected the build? Really??? My call would most likely be to the county prosecutor!

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#10

I don't want to be harsh but

Gary Smyth

it seems to me that this is a tempest in a teapot. If you are looking at a condo and you go in with flashlights and mirrors, functioning as a building inspector, and with your experience you don't like what you see, then walk away. You already know the answer. Problem solved.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#11

If, However

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

he's hired by the condo association to inspect and report on conditions throughout the development, or is hired by a prospective purchaser to write a report that will have continuing effect either after the closing or after the contract blows up, he can't "just walk away" but rather needs additional input to be able to make cogent recommendations on remediation.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#12

Not all condos are trash

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Back in the dark ages, I worked as a tinbender for six months. We happened to be running rain gutter on two projects - different contractors, different cities. The projects had in common that there were a lot of identical or mirror-image buildings in each; the buildings were not just mirror-image, but symmetrical in design from one side to the other. The journeyman under whom I was working had worked on other projects by these contractors.

On one, we measured the roof lines on one side of one building, and soldered up the gutters for all four eaves on two buildings from that one set of measurements. All four fell into place. As a lark, we measured the foundation, too - the buildings were out 1/8" in a two-story rise. Those buildings are still standing and still looking good, 35 years later.

You can guess how the other one was: we had to measure each and every roof line, and do some grunting when we installed because the eaves lines weren't straight. I used my hammer more on that job to beat the gutters into submission than to tack them down. We would find deviations of several INCHES in buildings across the street from each other that, at first glance, were identical buildings.

There are good contractors, but, because their work holds up, they're not as visible as the cornflakes-for-brains contractors. It's kind of like payroll offices; the payroll supervisor at my old employer told me once that she always knew when she was doing the job right, because no one ever came into the office.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#13

Re: I don't want to be harsh but

Barry Irby

Gary, I was there inspecting the unit for a buyer, not for me personally. I wanted him to understand that it was very unlikely that the deck/balcony would survive well over a long period of time. I see it as unlikely the boxing will survive and that may in turn accelerate the demise of the deck itself. There are potential safety issues as well. In addition to all that he needs to understand that the builder will most probably be out of the picture by then. The home owners association will be left to deal with this and if I am correct, this is a universal defect. There will be no opportunity to spread the cost around because each unit will have the same damage. Their only choice will be to cough up enough money to fix it and there will be no money escrowed for this repair, because it is not anticipated. If you want to see what the potential danger is, Google "Deck Collapse". People are killed and injured far too frequently by such failures and they are far more common that most of us care to believe.

The boxing may be MiraTek. But it may also be a less durable but similar material. I wonder if any of the research on the product to predict its performance included have it sit filled with wet potting soil for years on end. Also, how durable is treated wood when sitting in a box full of wet potting soil? Wonder how well the fasteners will hold up?

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#14

I deserve a knuckle wrap.

Gary Smyth

My apologies. If you are/were doing the work for someone else and the choice to walk is not yours, but theirs, you of course need to not only report possible problems, but present alternatives based on your own (and other) opinion. I stand corrected. As an aside, I was attending a graduation at University of Virginia balcony when a balcony collapsed to the walkway below. One lady underneath when the balcony collapsed later died of injuries. With all the care that school takes with building and tradition and "architectural correctness" that balcony escaped notice. I'd tell the developer about what you found. I'd not be shy about telling building inspectors too if the information you relay falls on deaf ears. You don't want that on your conscience if something happens in the future.

Re: OT Column and Beam Boxing Question

#15

Not so much....

Barry Irby

In my business as a Home Inspector I have to find effective ways to communicate with people. Sometimes I feel totally ineffective. Some people seem to show up with the attitude "I am buying this house and you can't stop me." I tell them they have massive termite damage and they say Uh huh. I point out terrible settlement and they say Oh yeah. I put numbers in their reports like $15,000 or 20,000 and they look at them blankly. Later I get a call that is like "Hey, this is costing $20,000!!! You never made us understand!" When I sense this is happening I tell them to get smart now, not later. I am astounded at how dense some people are.

So, when the problem is more subtle and based on experience and in some cases distrust of the materials and techniques its even more difficult to make them listen.