Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Posts

OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#1

OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Barry Irby

I recently applied for Health Insurance. They demanded a copy of my medical records. I gave them permission to get them from my doctor. He sent the form back with "What? You think I work for Nothing?" written on it. Insurance company asked me to go get it straight. Doctor's staff insists I must have an appointment. The next day, I return and they take my blood pressure Which is elevated higher than any other reading they have ever taken. Doctor's comment is something like "Ooh! Your pressure is not managed." Then spends half an hour bitching about Obama Care. (This doctor has been "managing" my pressure for years.) He filled out the form for the insurance company and faxed it back. I was declined because my pressure was elevated.

At the same appointment, he changed my meds and for the first time ever my pressure is near or below normal. For about the last eight years and with two different medicines it has bee something like 130 over 85, not high, but "we can manage it a little better". Except that it never came down. Even with the meds it was still 130 over 85. He gets one reading of 150 over 100 and adds a diuretic to the one I was taking and within a week it has dropped to 110 over 75 and night and lower than that in the morning.

I had no idea they would simply reject me. I thought they would have "rated" me or suggest I get hings under control and reapply. Nope, a flat rejection. I think it time for new insurance and a new doctor. My question is, did he do me a disservice by sending the report in immediately? Would it have been in his purview to suggest I wait until the medicine kicked in?

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#2

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

FredD

"My question is, did he do me a disservice by sending the report in immediately? Would it have been in his purview to suggest I wait until the medicine kicked in?"

It sounds like you would like the good Doctor to help you defraud a Insurance company, I think that would violate his ethical code of conduct to say the least

Anyhow, one of the new Insurance stipulations is "no rejection for preexisting conditions"

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#3

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Howard Norman

>Anyhow, one of the new Insurance stipulations is "no rejection for preexisting conditions"<

Fred, as I recall that doesn't kick in until 2014.

h

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#4

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

FredD

I believe your right Howard , though there was a blurb about modifying the starting date when Congress gets back in session , we should live so long.

FredD

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#5

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

John E in SC

Probably wouldn't have mattered if the doctor had "waited" to send in your form since they asked for copies of your records anyway. They would have seen the BP readings. And yes, I've heard of insurance companies "rejecting" people for incredibly trivial problems, including inconsequential lab results that were a fraction out of "normal". I'm a family doc, and I just wish I had time to spend 30 min. griping about Obamacare - I'm too busy seeing patients trying to make a living! I'm sure that's all gonna get better though! :D

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#6

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

wilbur

Even worse, when a potentially large claim gets filed, such as discovering and starting to undergo treatment for cancer, insurance companies have been going back to the time that the insured client applied for health insurance, and retroactively canceling the insurance policy on the basis of inconsistencies found in the original application, despite the fact that the insured client had been making premium payments for many many years before the major health issue came up.

Going back to Barry's original questions:

(1) Charging for filling out insurance forms is not uncommon -- it does take up the time of the doc and the staff, and can be looked at as the medical equivalent of bringing a table top to a woodworking shop for a pass through the drum sander. Yes, it's a pretty minor thing for the shop, but the time spent drum sanding your tabletop is time that could be spent doing something else.

(2) Spending time complaining about Obama's health care policies for half an hour is not a great use of appointment time.

(3) It doesn't matter when the doc sent in the forms -- there would have been some mention of your high blood pressure.

(4) It looks like your doc is doing the right things, although his bedside manner could be better, from what you say.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#7

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Kirk (KC) Constable

Had the doc sent the form when first requested instead of sending a jackass flippant response, there would have been no mention of the newly elevated BP, and maybe no rejection by the insurance company to begin with. I undertand why Barry was POd. And given the circumstances, I think it's a bit of a stretch to suggest he was "asking the doc to defraud the insurance company" by waiting a bit to see if the new meds worked. All that would be in the records anyway.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#8

Was it Health or Life Insurance?

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

I was rejected once back in my 30's for the same reason. It was when I applied for additional life insurance.

I don't believe that is covered in Obamacare--YET!!!!!!!

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#9

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Barry Irby

Fred, I find your response to be something of a wakeup call. A shift in thinking.

I have been carrying health insurance for forty years give or take. Lately it has been $3000 deductible. They have effectively paid for nothing, ever. I could have covered my entire demand on the health care system for way less than a year's premiums. One policy I had had a rider on it that paid for "Accidental" injuries. Had a shop accident that required stitches. The bill came in in tow parts of about $650 each for a total of $1300+. The rider was for $2000 worth of care. Took a year and had to threaten to take them to the state board that regulates coverage. They paid about half and the hospital took it. I went the emergency room because it happened on Sunday evening.

I bought insurance from a company rep that specifically assured me that the policy covered diagnostics. No deductible for diagnostics. Important to get diagnostics. Much cheaper for the insurance to pay for diagnostics that to pay for heroic care later. When my Urologist sent me for a diagnostic on my prostate there answer was that they paid for the Urologist, not the biopsy. They paid the $89 and I paid the $2300. Oh! and they got the discount from $140 and I did not.

The insurance company asked the doctor to send in a copy of my records. Not to do and update and send that in. He has a sign up that says there is a $15 for copies of records. I offered to pay the $15. No. He and his staff upped the anti by demanding I pay $147 to take my blood pressure and report he elevated result. Is he working fr me or the insurance company? If I had had insurance, he would have provided the visit for $90 because the insurance company gets a better deal than I do.

I had allowed my insurance to lapse because of a cash flow problem. About 60 days. I offered to reinstate the insurance and pay the back payments, but they wanted to start over.

As I mentioned in the original post, this doctor has been "managing" my blood pressure for at least eight years. He gets a single reading that is the highest he has ever seen. Would continuing to manage it and changing the meds to something that finally worked have been defrauding the insurance company? I'm not sure. I went back to the insurance company through a local agent and they will sell me insurance if I get three BP readings on three separate days that are "normal". This is what makes me wonder if it would not have been better to wait for the results for the new meds and then submit the application. And, Rather than gripe about Obama care, would it have been better for ME for him to advise me they would reject the insurance and that I would have a better chance if I got the blood pressure under control first.

Incidentally, I have wondered why he has never suggested I lose weight and eat better as a method of controlling BP. On that last visit i looked around his office while I was there. At 20 pounds overweight, I was the most slender person in the building. His entire staff and fellow doctors were all heavier than I am. Maybe I should have mentioned that to him when I saw him in Hardies eating hot dogs.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Jesper, Denmark

barry,

I thought a bit about if a response to this was appropriate or not. I certainly cannot give you any advice.

So, maybe this is a philosophical commetary instead. I find it sad that Health care seems to be solely about how much money the providers can extract from the patients - not how to provide care for the patients and make a reasonable profit from it.

I was under the USA health care system for 32 years, paid reasonably for minor stuff and never had anything major. I had insurance coverage continually and never made a single claim.

Now, here is a different system. all health care is "free", paid for through taxes, which we grumble about all the time.

I have a high blood pressure, managed continuously for several years - typical Corodil Comp, which is similar to your description of a medication with some diuretic added. My cost for the medicine is around $8.00 a month.

I recently had prostate surgery and since some follow-up treatment. The decisions as to what procedure to do and which type of follow-up was entirely done based on the best projected result. Money was not involved at any stage. So far it has cost me only parking fees at the hospital.

The levl and quality of treatment is up-to-date, but the latest and greatest heroic and super expensive procedures are not used. There is simply no patient survival statistics that support it.

I do get very upset when the professionals, who are supposed to helps us and who are under an ethical oath to do so, put their own gain way in front of our well being. They should certainly get well paid - and they are well enough paid that when they get to micro manage their financial gains in place of taking care of their clients, I get ticked off no end.

Like I said, it will not help you personally. i will get off the soap box now.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#11

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Barry Irby

I have problems no end with our system.

A major one it that I am Grist in the Mill. The insurance companies have all the cards in this game. They have all the information about health and the costs. They know much better than I do what will a hen to me and what that will cost. They have the clout to go to the doctors and dictate what they will pay and what can be done. They have teams of lawyers and word smith that write the contracts, both with me and with the doctors. I am a Home Inspector, what do I know? Even if I knew everything I needed to know, there is no choice but to deal with one of several equally tricky insurance companies.

I actually went to my doctor's office years ago and asked them which was the best insurance or at least which one they liked to deal with? They were baffled by the question. It never occurred the them that one was better, they just ground through whatever the procedure was.

Here, they use scare tactics like..."In Canada if your hip goes bad, you get a bottle of aspirin and a walker, here you get hip replacement surgery." Yep, they get health care, but which one would you want? And, "those Canadians vote with their feet. When they need serious health care, they come across the border and get it here." Was It their PM who recently just did that? But, Canadians on this site report liking their system.

It really does not matter to me. I will not be given a choice. Obama care will either arrive or it won't. While my vote may count in the end I get no choice.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#12

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Bill Howatt

Being in Canada and knowing several people who have had hip and knee joint replacements, I can tell you with certainty that the aspirin and walker are not how you are dealt with. I will say that the time to get scheduled may take a bit of time though. However, if you are dealing with a very serious condition such as heart, etc, the problem will be dealt with quickly.

My mother, who was over 80 at the time, had back surgery promptly done. So much for the "old grandma being dumped in the garbage out back" BS that has been touted.

The Cdn politician was the premier of the province of Newfoundland. He said the the treatment was not available in Canada which raised the ire of various doctors/hospitals who said the procedure was done all the time.

Is our system flawless?. Absolutely not. Is it free? No, there is no such thing as a free lunch. Is our biggest cause for personal bankruptcy health care expenses? No again.

Bill

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#13

Rejects

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

An attorney I know who represents companies before a state's insurance regulatory agency has been predicting that health insurers would be increasing their rejection percentages by a substantial margin in order to "push" applicants into the new "higher risk" pool that will be subsidized under the new reform statute. Her comment was that companies, using the abolition of "pre-existing condition" protection for their profits as a premise, would attempt to put anyone with any condition beyond a common cold or poison ivy into the government pool to justify charging higher rates and, therefore, get more money out of the federal government for the same coverage they provided before for less.

Waiting to see how this develops, but I suspect that anyone who carries a sign saying "I love my insurance company" may be either a shill or mentally challenged, if not both.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#14

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

FredD

That was my first thought John , I have had more then a few Doctors in nearly 73 years on this planet and none that I can recall had the inclination or the time to rant about health insurers ,they had one staff person who was kept busy filling out forms and dealing with the companies.

Contrary to what they represent themselves to be , Insurance companies are neither compassionate or altruistic , they exist only to collect premiums and return dividends to their share holders.

FredD

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#15

Re: Rejects

Howard Norman

You could well be correct Mark. I certainly don't know anyone that says their insurance company is great. I am in a Medicare Advantage Plan under Humana and have had my share of problems with them. Most of my problems have been in drug coverage.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#16

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

Barry, have you thought of getting a new doctor and trying a different ins company? From what I read I doubt if your rejection would have happened in Wisc - but I could be wrong.

I read of the problems and am relieved I am covered by the State of Wisc and now, of course, Medicare.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#17

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Barry Irby

Robert, Thanks.

I am reluctant to change things. I have been going to this doctor for years but with the nagging suspicion that I am getting nearly nothing out of the relationship. I have been dealing with this insurance for years and gotten nothing. I bought it through a company rep. Now a local rep tells me they sold me the wrong stuff. How am I to know? They tell me that the coverage I had had a max out of pocket of $3000 and what they want to sell me has $4500 plus 20%. I'm not clear how that could be better. But then the loyalty gene kicks in.

If you go to the doctor you have a record of a pre-existing condition. If you don't go, ????

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#18

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Howard Norman

It doesn't seem to me that you owe the medical doctor any loyalty, certainly not any insurance company.

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#19

I'd be looking for a new physician

Kneale Brownson..Back enjoying CO snow

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

#20

Re: OT, Doctor Insurance advice Question

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

Barry. First, do get rid of that Medico. From what you have said he gets money from you and you get almost nothing from him. If you stay with him out of loyalty, that is misplaced loyalty as he appears to have no loyalty to you.

Second, have you any insurance agent, car, house, whatever, whom you trust? If so, go to that person and discuss your insurance problem - especially if there can be no sale from that person! If you are on a friendly basis with that agent, he will probably help. Most people, enjoy giving advice, good advice, helpful advice. It is called counseling. (I did it for years with students)

Third, as to a new Doctor, is there a good, well thought of and well run company that runs one or more local hospitals and has clinics in the area? We have what is called Pro Health. They own and run two or three hospitals and have several clinics in nearby cities. They are complete with outpatient surgery, etc. My primary care physician and my dermatological surgeon are both with Pro Health as is Waukesha Mem Hosp, Oconomowoc Hosp, and at least one other. I go to Waukesha Mem for my Respiratory exercise therapy. We also have Aurora Health Care. They operate much the same as Pro Health. These are clinics only in name in that patients "have" a physician, not a different Dr. for each visit. Everyone is on salary! Tests are not ordered by the dozen, only as needed and sparingly.

I think you are being and have been shabbily treated, Look arouond.

If you wish, here is my e-mail rclough57@wi.rr.com