Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

The Gulf Oil Spill

Posts

The Gulf Oil Spill

#1

The Gulf Oil Spill

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I sure hope they can get this under control soon.

Listening to my radio alarm this morning as I was waking up, I heard them mention having a hose connected to this concrete dome. Still in my groggy state, I scoffed to myself. Hell, any hose is going to collapse under the pressure of five miles.

As I was climbing down my tree, I was trying to figure out just how much the pressure would be. Five miles @ 5280 = 26,400'. Without looking it up, I was thinking it is ~ one psi for each 2', so 13,200 psi at the bottom. Sheesh, What hose can do that? Then as the coffee starts to kick in, I realize that it can be flooding , on the way down, so the pressure on the inside would equal the outside.

However, I have been wondering ever since this thing happened why they weren't trying to capture it with some kind of big tent just under the surface, funneling it up to a central pumping ship. They could be collecting it before it got to the surface.

I am no Engineer, but those floating links are about like showing up at a major train wreck with an ambulance full of band-aids. The environmental impact of this much oil which has already spilled, is likely to have a huge impact on lost of species of birds and aquatic creatures. If they can't stop it soon, I hate to think about it.

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#2

Re:  The Gulf Oil Spill

Normp

I understood the broken pipe is one mile deep.

Very devastating, and like you say it pains to even think about the long term consequences of this.

This is definitely a wake up call to the viability of these offshore oil rigs.

Norman

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#3

5000 ft deep not 5 miles

Bartstar

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#4

A little over 5000 feet

Dustmaker Mike

the well head is a little over 5000 feet down.

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#5

Thanks for the correction. I was sleep-typing

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I think I pointed out in the first paragraph that I was still groggy, and laughing at myself for dumb thinking. %\],,,,,,k

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#6

Re:  The Gulf Oil Spill

Brian in SLO

Norm, I wish you were right about a wake up call. But if we remember the spill of 1969 off the coast of Santa Barbara and what happened as a result of that one.

The offshore rigs still exist and they continue pumping.

Humans are the still dumbest animals on the planet!

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#8

Re:  The Gulf Oil Spill

Normp

What I don't get they say if this containment dome fails to work there is no alternative but to bore another hole which takes months. In my opinion, the only way this plan can fail is if the dome were lowered in the wrong place. They don't even have a 2nd dome being built. Crank them out and keep trying!

They should be throwing everything humanly possible at this problem, having a Plan B , Plan C, Plan D and on and on in place.

We put a man on the moon 40 years ago and can't fix this problem today?

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#10

Luckovich . . .  *LINK*

Yonak


Mike Luckovich cartoon

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#11

Lee Grindinger

Hah, hah, ha..., gonna need a bigger box!

Lee Grindinger

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#12

Re: A little over 5000 feet = about 2200 psi

charlie belden

From my scuba days, every 33 feet you go below the surface you double the pressure from one atmosphere we experience above water - at sea level (14.7 psi = 1 atmosphere).

5,000/33 = 151.5 atmosphere

151.5 atmospheres x 14.7 psi/atmosphere = 2,227 psi

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#13

You'd think....

Marv

They could just take a big O crimper down there and crimp the pipe shut. A giant Jaws for life kinda thing.

Marv

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#14

Re:  The Gulf Oil Spill

brian in brighton

Keith. The problem is some of the language being used. The hose is actually a pipe made of steel, not a hose made of rubber. The rig on the bottom is, from what I've heard, several stories tall, so it's not a small problem.

Why they want to contain the entire thing and not just some of it has to do with the way oil rises in water. If you can hold a 20ft column of oil inside the 40ft tall box you can effectively seperate the oil from water before pumping up. If they pump it up and then have to seperate the two they will make a mess on the surface and will need huge seperators that I'm not sure exist. Add to the mess of having 5000 ft of bent and kinked pipe on the floor of the ocean that can get shifted with currents and you can see the mess. It's worse than trying to find a screw you drop in the sawdust.

It's a mess and a shame. Now we get to see the finger pointing about who and what is at fault with it.

Brian in Brighton

Re: The Gulf Oil Spill

#15

Yea Charlie, I had already done that math too.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

From my scuba days, every 33 feet you go below the surface you double the pressure from one atmosphere we experience above water - at sea level (14.7 psi = 1 atmosphere).

5,000/33 = 151.5 atmosphere

151.5 atmospheres x 14.7 psi/atmosphere = 2,227 psi

Then 2,227 X 144 = 320,688 psf. or 160.3 tons per square foot.

Sometimes it is hard to visualize these kind of numbers. If you converted the weight to steel, which is a little less than 8 times heavier than water, a steel beam one foot square and 625' long stood on end, would provide ~ the same pressure.