Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

Posts

Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#1

Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

FredD

In May's issue of WoodShop News , page eleven the Plaintiff's co -counsel that won a lawsuit against Ryobi says this.

"The Consumer Product Safety Commission is considering a rule requiring , flesh-detection technology on table saws. Our understanding is that the commission directed the staff to begin the rulemaking process,although the rule has not been published in the Federal Register."

Gass (the inventor of SawStop) said this after the commission listened to him.

" I think this establishes what I have thought all along and that is that saws being sold today are unreasonably dangerous and defective and should not be sold"

FredD

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#2

Its a problem

Kevin

I can understand both sides to this argument. However, I thought from the beginning the saw manufacturers should have listened to the guy who developed the technology. Made perfert sense. I afraid I would award damages in a suit where recently made saws did not have the techology and someone got hurt. Some saws have been redesigned since the technology was offered but the claim was it was too expensive to redesign. What? If only one manufacturer had imbraced the technolgy, they would be sitting very pretty right now. They should have seen this coming. They got very bad advise from their attorneys.

Remember, the govt made it a requirement to have a brake on your lawn mower so that it stopped when the idiot (operator) would move from the back handles to stick his hand underneath the mower.

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#3

And Then . . . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

That same idiot got out his trusty roll of Duck Tape and wrapped up the deadman bail to defeat the safety brake. Then, when his hand got taken off, couldn't understand why no self respecting attorney would take his case to sue the manufacturer.

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#4

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

Steve in Phoenix

This kind of thing drives me insane. So instead of going crazy with a lengthy response, I'm going to have a Martini. In a glass. That is until I'm required by my betters to use a no-spill sippy cup...

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#6

Make Sure

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

it's insulated. Keeps the hooch cold longer without watering down the alc.

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

Clint Searl

It gives the CPSC an excuse to add headcount and increase budget. The nanny state knows what's best for us.

Clint

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#8

Don't tell anyone, but

Steve in Phoenix

after breaking a box of Martini glasses due to our "festive nature", we've switched to stainless steel. Unbreakable so far. Big Brother would be so proud, he'd send us a one month supply of soy products!

Oh, they get cold in the freezer nice and fast too...

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#9

Re: And Then . . . .

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

Apropos of deadman switches, my Simplicity tractor had one which stopped the machine each time I got off the seat. Naturally I deactivated that one. I know the dangers of machinery. I have seen the results of improper usage. A farmer we knew lost one arm in in Corm Picker one year and lost the other the next year doing the same thing - all through stupidity. A friend of ours was nearly crippled by his unprotected pto shaft. I have had minor injuries from poor usage of machinery. But, no matter how much we try to protect people, we, the protected ones, will always find a way to defeat the protection. Users must bear some responsibility.

Saw Stop is a marvelous device. It would be "nice" to have and perhaps manufacturers should be required to have them. However, not all suits against the manufacturers are valid. The most recent one will, hopefully, be reversed upon appeal. After studying what I could find on the case, I concluded it was a typical jury verdict: the individual was not at fault, the company can afford the settlement, so vote that way. My reading indicated something different. The victim, although bearing some responsibility, is much less at fault than his employer. Apparently the employer did not instruct the employee on how to use the equipment. Therefore, I see most of the fault to be the employer's.

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#10

Confirms

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

There ain't no sucha thing as "idiot proof". It's truly amazing how much intelligence is squandered just to establish how stupid we can be.

"Here, Bubba, Hold ma beer and watch me do this . ."

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#11

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

Jerry

Although I own a SawStop PCS I agree that government intervention is uncalled for. It should be every person's choice to buy what they want. The free market should rule. I'm afraid this is a scary trend that is occurring in the good 'ol USA.

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#12

Duct tape is too hard- rare earth magnet

john lucas

holds the darn thing so you can pick up trash, limbs, the dog toys etc. Been mowing yards now for 47 years and have never needed that lever.

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#13

In all seriousness (is that a word?)

Steve in Phoenix

please call your congressman and senators. You'd be surprised how receptive they can be (especially your congressman).

And if you are represented by Republicans, definitely call. They got nuthin else to do!

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#14

I have three

McKay

The service for SS is fantastic.... and it is a good thing. The paddle switch, then the belts then....

For the school, the SS is a real stress reliever. However, I have yet to change the switch, or belts on my unisaw. I have had the SS fire because we touched the blade with the Excalibur blade guard. It has fired because we changed the blade for one cut with the thin kerf blade. I have cuts on my forearm every time we have a change because you can not get the stupid key to pull out, or the activated cartridge and damaged blade to come off.

I will keep my unisaw and in thirty years when you have replaced everything on your SS, I will still be using my unisaw with barely any maintenance. >(

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#15

Moses Yoder

Ripping with no fence or gaurd?

Moses Yoder

I recieved the e-mail this morning from FWW that had an article on this very thing. The article states that the employee was trained in safe table saw use by his employer, but then several weeks later was ripping a 2-1/4" wide board with no gaurd on the saw and had also removed the fence. I cannot figure out how a jury would award any money to this idiot. The safety measures that Ryobi had put on the saw were totally removed. It also states that the saw manufacturers rejected the Saw-Stop technology mainly because they did not want to put it on one line of saws and therefore admit that there other saws were unsafe. In my opinion the Saw-Stop mechanism is too expensive to put on a small portable job-site saw. I used a Craftsman bench top saw at job sites several years when I was installing for a kitchen cabient refacer, and normally used it with the guard in place and with a rip fence and never was injured on it. In my opinion requiring the Saw-Stop mechanism on saws is just another example of big wasteful government.

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#16

Re: Don't tell anyone, but

mdclor

If your tongue freezes to the metal glass, you will be looking for damages from the stainless steel glass manufacturer because your primary safety device that should be located between your ears was malfunctioning. :D That is why I never drink a "naked" martini!

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#17

Ditto Moses-well said

John Lucas

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#18

Want it to work for all --

Gary Smyth

then give the technology away.

Remember the Sony Betamax. It was by far the better technology of its time. It died because someone at Sony made it too expensive vs. alternatives (VHS) and the device manufacturing competition. Remember the audio cassette? It made everyone a bloody fortune because it was a standard given away by Philips so everyone could build their audio equipment versions using that standard. How about the Fein hand held saw? They held the patent and charged $500. Now that the patent has run out, it is available to anyone and the price is 1/3 for similar tools. Remember Xerox? They gave away the Graphical User Interface to first Apple, and then others, and today we have a pictorial internet, not just text..

If the government wants to get involved with the saw stop technology to �improve� the industry, then they ought to legislate that there be a one time payment to the inventor and the technology be awarded to the public as a safety device (in the greater public interest) and the manufacturers be allowed to use the technology and newer versions (re-engineer for lower cost) free, to build their machines.

With a one time finite pay commitment on the books for other manufacturers--not a perpetual annual fee, then let�s see how fast the industry reacts to Saw Stop or its clones..

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#20

Re: Want it to work for all --

FredD

Not bad Gary, and better if one could convince Politicians to ensure that the tool making industry isn't held hostage by a single guy with a idea yet to be accepted as necessary to make woodworking absolutely bullet proof safe.

FredD

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#21

Re:  Bib Brother? Is that the new Boogyman,

FredD

Keith, actually it is the result of small keyboards and big fingers which is a whole other peeve of mine.

But I kinda liked it ;-))

FredD

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

#22

Re: Bib Brother is closer then yu may think

BrianA from Monument

I wonder what the linear foot of cuts made between injury saw stop could have prevented is.

Then I wonder what the amount of injuries are simply stupid users.

(Stupid users also includes workers not trained to use equipment.)

We don't need government telling us we must have tools with expensive toys that make one man rich.

Unless they cancel his patent.