We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
My wife found a picture of a segmented cutting board. She wants me to make some. A few questions come to mind..
Is titebond3 an advisable glue for this type of project?
Will woods like walnut cause problems for individuals with peanut and other allergies? Are woods softer other than say hard maple -cause for concern if nicks and cuts develop and collect bacteria etc?
I've seen Mineral Oil as a recommended "finish" for cutting boards. What sort of maintenance/care must be observed to prevent de- lamination etc.?
Made several with TB-3 with no hassles, however your joints must be very tight. Using TB as a gap filler is a recipe for creepiness.
Made mine from walnut and cherry. No issues to report; its dust and juglone extractives that cause the issues with walnut, which are mostly gone when dry.
I finish all treenware with laxative-grade mineral oil which I heat and then add a combination of bee's wax and paraffin. Raise the heat above 190� for a few minutes, then decant into a small aluminum forms. Apply the oil/wax by rubbing while heating the wood surface with a blow dryer or heat gun. Wipe off the excess. Renew the board from time -to-tome with a new application of the oil/wax. Board will last for generations.
If you're really concerned about germs, scrub the cutting surface with course salt, and a little water. done
There is way more fretting over cutting boards than what seems necessary. I have made bunches of them with out incident. The picture is a board I made in 1966. It is maple glued together with "white glue".
It is our "utility board". It has been used to cut up dozens of lambs and deer and other critters and critter parts. It gets washed in the sink (NOT the dish washer) as needed and when it looks dry it gets a slather of what ever cooking oil is handy. I like the cooking oil because it doesn't bleed back out like mineral oil. (This recommendation will elicit the usual howls of disagreement to which I respond, "it's worked for me since '66".) Some time last year I ran it through the planer to remove some of the cleaver and meat saw wounds. Looks like it may last a couple of centuries more, or less.
"on the other hand given the equipment of most shops you couldn't approach their finished product."
I got into all sorts of trouble the last time I said "baloney" to someone's post but I'll risk it again. A cutting board is the easiest thing possible to make. Glue a bunch of pieces together, run it through the planer, trim to size. What could be simpler? The one shown below has lasted 40 years of rough use and it is the first thing I ever made in a wood shop class. In what ways would a commercial made board prove to be better?
Can you elaborate on what kind of equipment that most home shops don't have access to?
All of the attributes you specify seem to me to be something attainable from a home woodworking shop....easily, based on the quality of workmanship I've see from the members of this forum.
Bill mentioned Commercial cutting boards just like I did and I specifically mentioned John Boos and company who are in Effingham Ill.
They are the premier countertop manufacturer in the US and I have installed tops from them for years and made many cutting boards from scrap left over from a counter job.
Visit the site and you may rethink "easily"
How big is your Vacuum chamber for instance , know anybody who has one ?
They impregnate the Maple a 1/4" or more with their proprietary sealer and finish, can you do that , easily?
Before you succumb to feelings of inadequacy , let me say I am not speaking of your woodworking skills , but your lack of equipment that the manufacturer has.
That's it for me on cutting boards , the original poster was asking questions about things like sanitation ,advisability of mixing woods and I simply suggested a easy way to go that is guaranteed to produce acceptable results.
The ones I make from scrap counter stock for gifts are appreciated and favorably commented on.
I have made a lot of cutting boards out of various woods over the years. Most have been finished with mineral oil but some have had other finishes. Have never had a problem with any of them in use. All of them have been greatly appreciated as gifts.
I would stack up any that I have made against just cutting one from any commercially made counter top.
The only cutting board I ever made, around 1953 in junior high shop class, is still being used by me dear old Mum at age 93. It's just a slab of chestnut with a handle, but she's mighty proud of it.
I am once again amazed by the variety of information that is provided by the good folk here. Cutting boards seem such a simple topic-I just about tweaked my own nose for even posting the questions but wifey did in fact pick up a used cutting board recently at some yard sale. I am quite sure no one in this house put it in the dishwasher-although it may well have received a sink bath of longer duration than should have been allowed-what ever happened -I came into the kitchen to find it warped and split along some of the glue lines-hence my questions. I suspect I can indeed produce a board with satisfactory qualities. I am however happy know that the Boos Company's- Sealing process is as sophisticated as it is. I did take some time to wander through their web page.
Alan, the only times I've used Titebond III were on some very large maple cutting boards I made for customers. I think Titebond II would work as well but you never know how folks will handle these things after they get them, so I decided to go the extra mile with the type III just in case.
Where I differ on these things is the finish. For the life of me I can't bring myself to use mineral oil. It doesn't seal the pores of the wood, which is where bacteria will enter. It also never dries and can possibly become rancid.
To that end, I've found what I believe is a better finish, which is Waterlox. The first thing those reading this will think is - "I don't want a film finish on something that will show cut marks and possibly have shards of dried finish flaking off in my food".
It's all about how you apply it and how much. I've had great success by thinning the Waterlox about 10 - 20%, applying it very heavily, and wipe away all that remains on the surface. That's it! There's not enough to build a film on the surface and flake off over time because it's down in the wood. Unlike any plain oil, the Waterlox dries and seals the pores of the wood. Down the road as the board gets used a lot, the process can be repeated.
I like the Waterlox because of its tung oil base, which makes it more flexible than a straight polyurethane or varnish. The whole point is to allow the finish to go into the wood - not on top of it like a salad bowl finish. I'll leave the mineral oil to those who like it. To me, it's nothing more than a laxative!
I think the problem is that your talking about counter tops and Bill is talking about cutting boards which is much more pertinant to Alan's original question. I don't think John Boss makes segemented cutting boards, they do make really nice countertops.
Alan, titebond 2 or 3 will work fine so will polyurethane glue as well as weldwood and as Bill said they are pretty easy to make and you can pretty much do anything you like design wise as long as you can glue them up.
I must have made fifty by now. I like cherry but have used many different woods. I have used all the Titebonds, 1, 11, and 111.
I glue up strips to about the size I want the board except a little longer. I plane or sand them into submission. Then I cross cut them into strips and Tip them up ninety degrees to reveal the End Grain and flip every other one end for end to make a brick pattern. I usually join them with biscuits, usually three rows. Not sure they are necessary, but they help keep the pieces lined up.
I glue the strips again and then run them through the Performax to level the surfaces. I make them about 1 1/2" thick but have made them as little as 1 1/8" thick. 14 by 20" is a nice big board. Probably not necessary to make end grain boards, but they show knife marks less and look great.
I finish them with Sunflower oil. Does not go rancid and nobody is allergic to sunflower oil. I soak the surface over and over. They soak up an astounding amount of oil.
I like to sand a depression in one or both sides. Dish it out so that the board sits on four corners. It helps to make the juice run to the center.
I recently received one of those "pass it along" emails that contained words of wisdom from an old farmer. It included some pretty clever and humorous advice on life. But one line really stood out: Most of the things people worry about don't happen anyway. So go ahead and grab some hardwood, glue it together with Titebond, and finish it with mineral or walnut oil. It will look good and be functional for at least a year or so depending on how much it gets used or abused. When it needs renewal your skills and technique will have improved enough to make a higher quality replacement.
you took the time to reply , perhaps I was unclear again.
So one more time , I was talking about making cutting boards from scrap countertop stock because I generally have a lot ot it.
With all due respect I think you need to visit John Boos and company website.
www.JohnBoos.com , there you will see many cutting boards from many different domestic hardwoods. Expensive , you bet , so back to scrap.
You mention how easy it is to make one, here is a pic of a Cheese Board/ hot pan holder I have made dozens of from scrap countertop material milled to 7/8ths thickness , cut out on the bandsaw, edge sanded on a Oscillating Drum sander , edges eased with a router and it takes about five minutes per board in a production run. What could be easier or faster?
I wanted a fast easy way to make gifts Women like and so they do.
No time was invested in probably what Alan has in mind , no inlays , no alternating woods, but a product that makes Ladies smile and I get a bang out of doing it.
Some time ago when I worked for a door company we would have cutoffs from the ends of red oak glued panels. I saved a bunch of these cutoffs and ripped them all to the same length, I think 1-1/2", and then face glued them together, making cutting boards which had end grain on top. These would be difficult to hand plane smooth but were no match for the companie's Timesaver widebelt sander I finished them by shredding beeswax with a cheese grater and putting it in a pint can, then pouring in enough mineral oil to cover the beeswax. I then set this in a pan of water and turned on the heat. The beeswax will melt and blend with the mineral oil, which is then set aside to harden. It ends up being about the same consistency as cold butter, and is then simply wiped on the cutting board with a rag. It makes a really nice long lasting finish for cutting boards and other kitchen utensils.