We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Have an oak tree near my house that has started to concern me. (It's a pretty big tree, and COULD hit the house if it fell the right way.) Anyway, I initially thought it was dead as it started dropping limbs out of the top, but this spring, it actually started leafing out on about the bottom 2/3 of the tree. Top 1/3 looks dead as a doornail however, with some pretty good-sized limbs up there that are completely bare. What are the chances of this tree remaining viable? If the top limbs fell, they wouldn't likely cause any property damage. But if the tree is toast, I may as well take it down now. Appreciate any thoughts.
Sometimes a late freeze can kill young leaf buds. Give it some time and then consult a local arborist to see if the tree can be trimmed to save it or if it should be removed.
I'd cut it down in a heartbeat, and then plant another. Roof damage could cost you a lot more, and you'd still bear the expence of having the thing cut up for firewood or and hauled away. Why take a chance on a half dead tree?
Is likely underground. What you're describing is a failure of the tree's vascular system which would usually originate in the roots.
That said, if you've got good binoc's, do a careful examination of the upper section paying special attention to the trunk where the change takes place. Any holes pecked in a ring around the tree or ruptured bark? Sap suckers can do this to a tree which will cut off the flow of nutrients to the top. Ruptured bark can be a giveaway to a lightening strike that would also sear the tree's internal vascular plumbing. Is the tree trying to sprout new leaves from the trunk? Good indication of serious internal damage.
All of the above from an arborist friend whom I just spoke to. While you should have it examined, chances are you're in line for a year or two's supply of firewood.
Have an arborist look at it and take it down if there is a chance it will fall down.
I have a monster red oak in my backyard. Every two years I have an arborist give it a check up.
Should it fall, it has the potential of taking out several garages and/or doing a lot of damage to my house and the neighbors'. It's not worth taking a chance in my opinion.
I live in a densely populated suburb. Houses are practically built on top of each other. Not much room for falling trees.
Just a side note. Our town used to have trolley/street cars that ran down the main boulevard. Years ago, the tracks were removed and basically replaced with oak trees. They are now very big and old. The city has been cutting a lot down. Sad really. But if you look at the stumps, they are rotten/hollow in the centers. They look healthy and fine on the outside. That is what worries me, and keeps me awake on windy nights, about my oak which is the same age as the ones being taken down.
"Is the tree trying to sprout new leaves from the trunk?" Yeah, that's exactly what it's doing. Hadn't thought about using binoculars to get a closer inspection - I'll certainly try that when I get home. Sounds like it needs to come down. I live on 10 mostly wooded acres,so losing one isn't a problem, but this is probably only one of two that might hit the house if it fell, so of course that would be the one to need cutting!
Slow down...put the chainsaw away for a while. Just because a tree is declining or reacting to a stress doesn't mean that the best management practice is removal. If that concept were valid we'd be cutting down ALL trees..silly to think that way.
Get hold of a QUALIFIED arborist. There is no reason for anyone to claim that they are an arbo just because they've looked at trees and burned firewood. Now...being a Certified Arborist or a Registered Consulting Arborist...that's different. If you have questions about qualifying an arborist let me know, chances are I know some good arbos in your area anyway. One of the best consultants that I know lives in Cary NC and he travels quite a bit. You might have him stop to look sometime.
Just because it's not leafing out doesn't mean that it's dead. Agreed, late frost can kill the buds. Give it a bit of time to react.
If there are a lot of fuzzy type sprouts coming out of the trunk or major limbwood it is likely to be a reaction of the tree to a stress. Trunk sprouting doesn't mean that the tree will die either. There are many things that can cause the reaction.
Be sure to gather lots of info about the tree before you decide to whack it down. There is an amazing amount of scare mongering and unskilled knowledge passed around.
Give me a shout if I can be any help. I know way more about trees than I do lumber.