Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Seal or not

Posts

Seal or not

#1

Seal or not

Gary Smyth

I have made, for want of a better description, a practical bookstand with pivoting top. The top is 13 x 17 and made of 1/2" pine and it and the frame is very soft... I need to cover the top with laminate to prevent writing dings. The rest will be a painted piece. I'm planning on sealing the remainder of the piece with two coats of wipe on poly before painting, but my inquiry is, should both sides of the top be sealed? Would contact cement adhere better to raw wood or would it be better to seal the total top and when dry and light sanded then apply contact cement? The can of contact cement seems to suggest that raw wood would be desirable but I'm thinking that if both sides were sealed the tendency of the thin top to warp would be less. Suggestions?

Re: Seal or not

#2

Lee Grindinger

Your cup will runeth over

Lee Grindinger

First, raw wood is fine, just use two coats on the wood and follow the instructions on the can.

Laminate will contort that piece of pine into an unusable surface in a relatively short time. Laminate is virtually impermeable so whatever moisture changes are in the air will affect only one surface and regardless of the change in EMC it will be bad. Use laminate on both sides.

Lee

Re: Seal or not

#3

Re: Seal or not

Howard Acheson

>>>> I'm planning on sealing the remainder of the piece with two coats of wipe on poly before painting,

Why do you want to do that? Oil based paint is just varnish with lots of opaque pigment. There is no benefit to "sealing" with a clear finish. The first coat of any film finish is a more than adequate "sealer" of the wood's pores and surface. If you were going to use a primer, then something like Zinsser BIN or one of the Kilz primers could be used.

>>>> both sides of the top be sealed?

Yes, but see Lee's comments and mine that follow.

>>>> Would contact cement adhere better to raw wood or would it be better to seal the total top and when dry and light sanded then apply contact cement?

Apply the contact cement to raw wood. I recommend a solvent based contact cement, not a waterbased version. It has proven to me to be a much more trouble free and more durable adhesive.

Let me go one step further than Lee. If your top is solid wood, even laminating both sides may be problematic. The substrate will want to expand and contract with changes in relative humidity but the laminate will try to prevent this movement. Something may ultimately "give". That's the reason that a composite substrate like plywood, MDF or particleboard is used.

Re: Seal or not

#4

Clint Searl

A dissenting opinion

Clint Searl

The 13x17 top dimensions suggest using 3/4 ply or MDF instead of pine. Neither will warp. Pine never sleeps. Whether or not the bottom is painted ain't gonna make any difference. Water based contact cement will work just fine on either bare or painted substrate. Consider water borne acrylic wall paint instead of an oil based. It'll be just as durable for your use and quicker and easier to apply. I like flat acrylic under clear water borne poly.

Good luck

Clint

Re: Seal or not

#5

Re: Seal or not

Gary Smyth





As has been pointed out laminate is a liability to the top. You can see that one side will be anchored with a piano hinge as the tilting anchor. Laminate will not work with seasonal change at the same rate as the pine over the width. New pine was a bad choice for this little project. I do have room for two battens on the rear to keep the top flat and also to lay flat in the frame when not in use. I can hold that with brads or elongated screw holes. Finding small enough wood screws for this soft wood might also be a problem. I may have to use longer screws and file the brass down flush to get enough thread purched for the battens. I was hoping to save weight using the pine but a thicker, harder wood would now be my choice. I still need something better for writing on the top surface. Perhaps a 1/8� cutting mat or even leather or some other suggestion.

Re: Seal or not

#6

Re: Seal or not

Bill Tindall

The top is 13 x 17 and made of 1/2" pine........Why didn't you use plywood?

. I'm planning on sealing the remainder of the piece with two coats of wipe on poly before painting............Why? What will the poly due that the paint won't?

should both sides of the top be sealed? NO, but it would be better to laminate both sides. Would contact cement adhere better to raw wood ......Yes

I'm thinking that if both sides were sealed the tendency of the thin top to warp would be less.......... You need to be worrying about the effect of the laminate not the paint. I'll bet it warps if there isn't laminate on both sides.

Re: Seal or not

#7

water based adhesive a bad idea

Bill Tindall

If a water based product- paint or adhesive- is slathered on one side of this thin pine a potato chip will result.

Re: Seal or not

#8

Save a Few Bucks

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

As mentioned, in this application your top must be a laminate "sandwich" with both sides being covered. If, however, you have a laminate supply near you (not HD or Lowes) you can get a piece of "backer" laminate which is designed for just this kind of use to prevent warping of the substrate. This is thin material at about a rd of the cost of "show" laminate. To properly laminate a door or top, you apply the backer sheeting first, trim flush, do the edges and trim flush, then lastly do the top or face material.

BTW, if you'd like a wood edge, glue 1/2" strips with mitered corners to your substrate's edges after you apply the backer sheet. Lightly sand them flush with the top surface before applying the face laminate. Then laminate over the edges with the top material and trim flush. You can then finish the wood surface. Put a slight champher on the top edge which will help protect the plastic from nicks and bumps.