Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

I need new shop lights

Posts

I need new shop lights

#1

I need new shop lights

Stuart Johnson

About a year ago I bought some mid range ($25) two tube t-8 fluorescent lights that are suppose to be commercial grade for my shop. So far 3 out of have failed. There is a day or two of flickering then they go out. I've tried new bulbs with no luck. I guess the ballasts are very cheap to be failing so soon. I'm also well past Lowes return date.

1. Could the problem be something besides the ballast?

2. What is a reasonable amount to pay for this type of light but one that is of a decent quality?

3. What brand is recommend and can it be bought online?

Any input on decent shop lighting for 30x40 foot shop with 12 foot ceilings would be appreciated.

Re: I need new shop lights

#2

why buy new fixtures

Bill Tindall

Ballasts are easy to replace, vastly more so than replacing the whole fixture. When the ballast fails, replace with a good quality ballast and other than changing lamps now and then that is the end of your problems.

Re: I need new shop lights

#3

Re: why buy new fixtures

Neal in San Jose

That's what I do. I originally lit my shop with T-12 lights. As they fail, I leave the fixture in place and replace with electronic ballasts and T-8 bulbs. I keep one or two ballasts on hand, and only buy T-8 lamps. It's easy.

Re: I need new shop lights

#4

Re: why buy new fixtures

Stuart Johnson

That sounds easier than replacing the fixtures. Anything special about finding the correct ballast? Looking online the least expensive ones run about as much as new fixtures.

Re: I need new shop lights

#5

selecting the correct ballast

Bill Tindall

There are dozens of kinds of ballasts each tailored for the lamps it will drive, so yes, it is essential to select the correct ballast. If you are unsure what to buy, go to your local electrical store(wearing electricians clothing so you will fit in), and have the person at the sales desk select a ballast. (editorial: if the persons manning the sales counter at the contractors supply stores were more customer friendly to novice customers Lowes would not have put so many out of business)

Yes, a commercial quality ballast will cost more than the whole fixture you bought with a ballast that lasted a few months. This observation should not be a surprise. And in my experience you will never need to replace the ballast ever again.

PS while you are shopping you will need to get some wire nuts to install the new ballast.

Re: I need new shop lights

#6

Re: I need new shop lights

Barry Mabery

I have a little bit of knowledge in this area being a partner in a small lighting fixture manufacturing company. I'd make a few observations and hope I don't offend anyone -

1. A $25 shop or industrial fixture is pretty to close to the minimum price and most likely imported or at least made with low cost components.

2. Electronic fluorescent ballasts should last 15 - 20 years, easily. The manufacturers warrant them for 5 years and, if it is the ballast that's faulty, you might get a replacement for free or low cost. On the other hand it could be cheap sockets that have arced.

3. F32T8 lamps are rated at 25,000 hours or more, so they shouldn't go in just one year.

4. You could replace the ballast with a quality one from Advance (div. of Philips Lighting), Universal Magnetek, or Osram Sylvania, but

5. If I were in your position, I think I would buy new lights from Lithonia Lighting, Metalux (div. of Cooper Lighting), or other known brand through an electrical distributor, and not from the big box stores. You'll pay more than the $25 but you will not have to worry about them except to change lamps every 5 years, or so.

A quick calc of your 30 x 40 shop suggests that you would need 34 - F32T8 lamps (11 x 3 lamp or 16-17 x 2 lamp fixtures) to get approximately 60 footcandles average illumination. I believe that would be enough light for most situations.

Re: I need new shop lights

#7

Re: I need new shop lights

wilbur

FWIW, when I set up the lighting for my shop I did go to the local borg to get fluorescent light fixtures. They had 4' 2 bulb fixtures for about $25, but I went with the ones that were about $50. they have been near silent, reliable for the past two years, and have the added benefit of spacing the two bulbs fairly widely, which helps spread the light more evenly than the fixtures where the bulbs are right next to each other.

My only regret is that I didn't go for four bulb fixtures.

So if your local borg has a pricier option for fluorescent light fixtures, I'd be comfortable going that route. Sometimes you do get what you pay for.

Re: I need new shop lights

#8

Re: I need new shop lights

Stuart Johnson

Thanks Barry, I will go with the better lights for the rest of the shop. In the mean time new ballasts fixed the problem. I also sent Lowes an email about their quality problem. The new Advance ballasts I purchased from the Elliott Electric Supply were about half the price of those from Lowes. This was a very pleasant surprise as I thought they would be as much as the original fixtures. The wiring was a little different but an electrician came in just about then and explained how they were wired as compared to the old one. Five minutes each and all is good.

I've laid out a lighting plane that calls for 24 2 lamp fixtures. This is probably an overkill but anymore I like more light. I have some natural light at one end from the roll up door but no windows.

Re: I need new shop lights

#9

Re: I need new shop lights

FredD

Thanks for chiming in Wilbur, a professional approach to Stuarts lighting problem is accurate and straight to the point.

BTW

I have always used Advance ballasts and the company backs up a hardware store,replacement.

If you could offer a opinion on how much the lamps decline time wise with light levels , I think i could get a better approach then the one I have been using.

FredD

Re: I need new shop lights

#10

Lamp lumen loss

Barry Mabery

In addition to the efficiency of a given fixture, i.e., how much light actually gets to where you want it, there are two other factors.

Lamp Lumen Depreciation predicts the loss as lamps age. In modern fluorescent lamps, this is a very flat curve, with less than 15-20% over the life of the lamp.

Dirt Depreciation which is a more important factor in a shop environment. Dust, dirt and other crud can reduce the output of your lights by 25 - 50%. Fully enclosed and gasketed fixtures don't permit that dirt to get inside and on the lamps, so it's easier to periodically vacuum the lens and bring the output back to nearly 100%. I'm sure a dust collection system helps a lot, as well. But most shop fixtures are open or have plastic lenses which hold dust through their static charge.

Bottom line is change the lamps when the ends start to blacken (or before then) and try to keep them clean. That way you get the light you're paying for.

(Hope I didn't put too many people to sleep.)

Re: I need new shop lights

#11

Re: Lamp lumen loss

mdclor

Barry,

Thank you for two really informative posts. I wish that I had known this when I fixtured my shop. The only thing I would do differently from your suggestions is to try for about 120 foot candles for my aging eyes. :)

Merle

Re: I need new shop lights

#12

Re: I need new shop lights

FredD

Oops , sorry about that Barry , I read yout informative post and replied to Wilbur , sorry Wilbur.

I am sorry I am alive sometimes . ;-((

FredD