Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

Posts

Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#1

Should I be ticked??  OT Insurance/Doctor?

Barry Irby

I am applying for new health insurance.

Insurance company sends to my doctor a single page request for blood pressue and cholorestorol readings etc. Doctor wirtes on the fax cover "Do these people think I work for nothing". Staff writes on it ther is a fee. Insurance comapny faxes it to me. (I have the numbers, but they want them from the doctor.) I drive to the Doc's office to pay the fee and get the form filled out. I am informed I have to have an appointment with the doctor and discuss it with him and then pay the fee(s). Since he had the day off I have to go back later. Should I be ticked? Is this routine? Do you usually pay to ahve the doctor translate the info he keeps on me to a format the insurance comapny will accept?

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#2

Re: Should I be ticked??  OT Insurance/Doctor?

Howard Norman

Yes, I think that you should be ticked. Sounds like my doctor. Most MD's are prima donnas IMHO. I have gone around and around with MD's most of my adult life.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#3

Re: OT Insurance/Doctor?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

A. Insurance company won't take the info from you as they expect you to lie.

B. Time was, the Ins-Co would send out their own vampire for BP and 50cc of your personal juice.

C. Doc is pissed over all the BS the Co puts him and his staff through just to get paid half what he needs to keep the doors open. Hence, the patients get the bill up front for the time it takes the staff to pull and fill the correct form, and then the time for the MD to check its correctness to comply with HIS malpractice insurance policy procedures in case you bail in 6 months and your insurance company comes looking for somebody to blame 'cause they got 6 months of premiums, but had to pay out a Million.

D. Insurance company has signs posted in every department. All read . . .

"This Ain't Burger King. You'll Get It MY Way Or You Won't Get The Son-Of-A-Bitch At All."

See what a free market health care system has done for us all?

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#4

Re: OT Insurance/Doctor?

Barry Irby

The Doctor has a sign up that says there is a $15 fee for filling out forms for ans insurance company. Fine by me. Not only has the sign been there forever, but I perfectly understand there is work involved and $15 seems reasonable. What bothered me was they turned it into an office visit ($125) and a fee. And they sat on it for two weeks.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#5

Paul Kramer

Yes

Paul Kramer

Barry,

Yes, I think you should be a little put out by this profiteering. I can understand the charge for filling out the form but to insist that you also be seen (and incur an additional charge) seems a little much to me.

Paul

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#6

We need to nationalzie the whole industry

Phil Joines

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#7

Re: Office Visit

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Barry,

Consider the situations.

If the doctor just signs the form and someone made a mistake in the information several things flow from that.

The life insurance company tries to deny your widow's claim on the basis that they agreed to write the policy in reliance on the doc's signature. But the info was inaccurate, was supplied by your doctor who was acting as your agent, and if they had been given correct information, they never would have given you the policy.

Your widow goes after the insurance company with guns blazing. They, then go after your "careless" doctor.

Then Mrs. Irby joins in the claim against your doctor since his negligence impaired the policy when you might have gotten another policy from a different company, but now your kids have to drop out of school as the money's gone, the house is in foreclosure, and the car just got hauled away on a flatbed.

Poor Marcus Welby's now got two sets of lawyers threatening to take his office, IRA, and the Ranch. He tries to hand it over to his own insurance company who blinks and says: "In paragraph 473(a)(16)(bbb) of your liability policy it clearly states that 'we will not be responsible for any loss caused by the insured's [your doc] failure to examine a patient before providing medical information for the purpose of insurance applications by the patient.'" "Tough nuggies, Doc. You're on your own." Doc goes bankrupt, his life's work is wrecked, and all his patients are out looking for a new doctor when there's a severe shortage; all over a stupid little form.

See, properly, Doc's insurer wants to control their liability and exposure for claims, and properly directs its doctors to follow certain procedures like not signing forms with information that he or she hasn't verified as accurate. Clearly reasonable.

So, the choice comes down to your doctor charging you for an office visit to comply with his own protection, that also happens to help you because, in the event you do bail in 6 months, your insurance company will have no grounds to dispute the policy, your wife and kids will be provided for, everyone walks away with fond memories of Barry, and the only people who get short-changed are the lawyers who didn't get the case because everything was done properly.

I just love happy endings :\

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#8

Ellis Walentine

A classic, Mark. Thanks

Ellis Walentine

Might as well be correct about these things.

Ellis

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#9

Depends

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

First, having spent a lot of my career thinking about what the lawyers would do with a given situation, I'm inclined to think Mark Mandell's take on it, a little earlier in this thread, is probably the most accurate.

But the other question I'd ask is how long it's been since you've seen the doctor. If it's been two weeks, getting upset makes sense. If you haven't been in for some months or a year or more, how would the doctor know if your last readings are still accurate?

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#10

Re: OT Insurance/Doctor?

Dan Donaldson

Not free market health care, but free market legal system.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#11

They just did

Dan Donaldson

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#12

Re: OT Insurance/Doctor?

Randy Johnson

At least you would get to see the doctor for that $125.

In 1992 I lost a job that I'd had for 14 years and suddenly found myself in need of health insurance. I was told that I could save ninety bucks on my first premium by providing a copy of my health records. At that time, my medical history was not very long and I could have gone to the local convenience store and copied it myself for about a buck fifty or less IF they had let me.

Instead, I was informed that I would have to pay the doctor $150.00 to get copies of my own medical records. They did say they would be happy to provide them free to another doctor, so I told them I would have another doctor to send them to as quickly as possible. In the end, I didn't have a "family" doctor for almost fifteen years.

About two years later I was working for a local contractor and was sent to my former doctor's office to change a light ballast. I walked in, took one look at the fixture, and asked them if they had any new tubes. They did, I installed them, and the light worked fine. They then had the gall to ask me, "We won't be charged for a full service call for this will we?" I reminded them of how understanding they had been when I was between a rock and a hard place and said they sure would be charged for a full service call. If it had been up to me it would have been about four times the going rate.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#13

Correct(ed)?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Concept also applies to the health care insurance that Barry actually asked about, except now Barry's lying in a hospital bed with no insurance because the policy got canceled for a "pre-existing condition", so his medical bills are eating the family home and all their retirement assets. . . . . . .

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#15

Re: Depends

John E in SC

I agree. I'm a family doc, so would like to present the other side of the story. I've "only" been doing this about 15 years, but you can't imagine how the business of medicine has shifted in those 15 years from patient care to paperwork! Now, a HUGE chunk of my day is spent documenting not just office visits, but labs, referrals, phone calls, etc. etc. ad nauseum. And the insurance companies seem to come up with new tasks to add to that list every day. Now, it's now longer enough that I write a prescription and sign my name to it - that really means nothing. The key is whether or not the INSURANCE COMPANY thinks I have prescribed the best (read: cheapest) drug for my patient. If they don't agree, I have to get the Rx "prior authorized" before the patient can fill it, unless of course they are willing to pay the full amount out of pocket. The whole "prior authorization" game is absolutely ridiculous, and nothing but a hoop to jump through, hoping that the doc won't be willing to go through the process, and they can deny the medicine. We had to hire another nurse just for this process! She frequently will spend 15-30 minutes on hold, trying to talk to the right person to get a medication authorized, only to then be told the ins. co. will fax a form, which must be filled out and signed by the doc. So do we charge for this? Absolutely. We have to. Couldn't keep the doors open if we didn't. Now, I don't usually make patients come in for an office visit just for paperwork, but often those "simple forms" (patient's words) require a physical exam, and least briefly. Am I going to make that up and let it slide? Of course not - I have too much to lose. And of course if it's been several months since the patient has been in, it may be time for an update anyway.

Just wanted to present the other side of the story. We aren't all out to get rich and screw over out patients. I promise, if I was doing this for the money, I'd have quit long ago. There are much better ways to make a better living without the hassles.

Take care (and thanks for letting me vent!)

John

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#16

They're worse than you think

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#17

Well said & thank you!

mdclor

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#18

Ditto 

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#19

Re: Depends

Howard Norman

John E, I didn't mean to imply that I think all MD's are jerks. In my adult lifetime I have known four that I thought were great human beings. Two were acting as family doctors, one is a oncologist and one is a orthopedic surgeon. The last two I consider as personal friends.

Quite frankly I don't consider my present internist in that league. I have thought of changing doctors but being on Medicare and living in a small town my options are limited to say the least.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#20

Re: Depends

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My wife is an RN in charge of the prescription refill program at our local clinic, and she would verify what you said in spades. The degree to which the whole shebang is run by the insurance companies is truly sad. There isn't an hour that goes by where some insurance bureaucrat isn't questioning the decision that was made by a physician aware of the complexities of the case.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#21

Preemptive mention of rules

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>People of good will have a lot of strong feelings on both sides of the health care reform issue. We need to recall, though, that politics is one of the subjects not permitted on Wood Central.

I wanted to remind folks before this part of this thread got hot.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#22

Thanx, Bill! I was about to...

Stuart Hough

weigh in about the future implosion, but you reminded me that this site can have an almost Zen-like effect on the BP, if used properly.

It's better than aspirin!

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#23

Not so fast.....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

The sign clearly says there is a $15 fee for filling out forms for an insurance company. I got a similar letter from my HMO doc with fees for other paperwork services as well.

So how do you make the leap that there's a $125 doctor appointment that goes along with that? Using that logic, the local lawn service is justified adding an additional $125 landscape consulting fee to the published $15 mowing fee everytime they show up. This one fails the reasonableness test.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#24

A Little Slower . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

So Tim, where does the information that actually gets entered "on the form" come from? How current is it? And, if Barry's insurance company requires (but won't pay for) the current exam as part of the application process (most now do) what does that do to your $15.00 form fill fee that is done by the doctor's insurance secretary after the exam?

You expecting Doc to also do the lab tests (blood, etc) for nothing as well?

As I mentioned, insurance companies used to send out a nurse who would do the pressure, draw blood and sometimes urine, all as part of the application process. They've now shifted that cost to the consumer. As their profit margins shrink, don't be surprised when the insurers come up with new ways to soak you, their "valuable" paying customer.

Re: Should I be ticked?? OT Insurance/Doctor?

#25

Thanks Guys and.....

Barry Irby

I went to my appointment this morning. I lost my health insurance this winter because things were so tight for me I had to make some decisions and I was too slow on the payments. So things are a little better and I decide to reinstate it. The company tells me I am too slow and I have to start all over. They have my records for the last ten years, but they want me to start again.

The Doctor spent a long time griping about the upcoming turmoil. Then spent a few minutes filling out the form. Their computerised records don't match the Insurance company's format so he had to translate and write it in by hand. They took my blood pressure. so, fifteen or twenty minutes of commiserating with the Doc and $147 later I got the form and had to fax it back myself. The Irony being that the reason I was there is I could not afford insurance but apparently they thought I could afford to pay to apply.

My problem is that I am grist in the mill. If I go to the doctor he records the visit and reports whatever he wants to the insurance company. Then I have a pre-existing condition. He warns me that having let it lapse they will now consider everything I ever had as a pre-existing condition and not pay for any of it for a year. Even though I was covered for all of it but two months.

I don't have sympathy for the insurance companies. Been buying health insurance for forty years and got practically nothing.