We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Sorry for the duplication. This post will also go to the turning board. My AAW chapter has volunteered to turn 65 balusters for an historic building in Flagstaff. The balusters will be painted and will surround a balcony on the front of a lovely 1895 vintage clapboard Victorian home. When I say volunteer, we are actually going to be paid $20 per baluster which will go to our club treasury. The volunteer part is that the lady who is remodeling the building has had trouble finding someone in Flag to do the job, and came to us for help.
Here is the problem. We are using a Vega duplicator to rough turn the pieces. They are rough off of the duplicator, and require quite a bit of sanding. I am using the Vega diamond V carbide cutter, so sharpness shouldn't be an issue, but the Vega cutters are basically pointed scrapers, and there is some tear-out. I am thinking the wood, poplar, may not take well to this type of scraping. We were given the wood by the home owner, so we are stuck with it.
I would like to be able to fill some of the tear-out. The balusters will be sealed with shellac, primed with oil-based primer, and painted with oil-based paint. Flagstaff is in the dry high desert, but has tough winters, so the wood will move. This year we got 140" of snow. I have been advised against using epoxy, but can I use CA glue or is there another filler that would work and survive outdoors here? Also, for future reference, am I right about poplar being a bad choice for a duplicator?
With a few clicks, she could find mountains of balusters on-line in most any wood she wants at less that 40% of what she's paying your club, but if the requirement is to use a unique pattern to match existing work (65 won't translate to many lineal feet of rail) I can see the issue.
Poplar is, as you know, fairly soft. You'll have to keep your rpms high to get any kind of surface from that cutter. I would then suggest you use an acrylic grain filler like Crystal-laq as a combination filler and sanding sealer. Apply it on a lathe with a brush and sand level. When the house was built, they'd have used gesso or encaustic (wax) as a filler.
Wood Central is an amazing collection of knowledge and talent. I read your post and the responses over on the Turning forum and them came here to see what was said. You have gotten some excellent advice, or maybe I should say it matches up with my thinking so it seems excellent to me.
I doubt there is any filler that will be successful in your climate for tear out. You might find something that would work for something like a nail hole (think dentist filling) but the expansion and contraction will cause anything I ever tried to fail if it is spread over a surface.
I take it somebody has already turned your pickets with the duplicator and gotten less than spectacular results. Maybe you should return them and have them returned. (Couldn't help it) Perhaps they can refine the setup and remount the spindles and take a 1/16 off and eliminate most of the tear out.
Poplar was a poor choice, not so much because it doesn't turn well, but because what is available now does not offer anything in the way of decay resistance. There is much discussion about second and third growth timber's decay resistance verse old growth timber. Freshly cut locust and cedar don't seem to offer the decay resistance of their legendary ancestors and poplar never was legendary for decay resistance.
I would investigate soaking the balusters in some sort of preservative (perhaps Bora Care or copper naphthenate) if you insist on keeping the poplar. Unless the rail is well designed they will rot from the bottom up. You should soak the bottom end if nothing else.
I would avoid shellac outdoors as well. Not only a waste of time, but it may ruin any chance the other finishes have of being successful by failing underneath the superior finish.
In the local turning club there is a professional Turner. The company he works for routinely takes orders similar to the one you describe. He sees turning a 100 or 200 of something as a regular day on the job. Just another day in paradise. They restored the rails on either the Governor's Mansion or the Capitol Building in Richmond, VA. (I can't remember which.) He got the job of turning something like 256 balusters. They called for them to be made of inferior wood (Poplar?) and he and his company warned them they would not last. The Architects insisted. They almost lasted long enough for the builder to get out of site, but they failed and he turned them again out of some really nice Western Red Cedar. He did a demo for us on how he did it and we were growing about have to turn 256 again. He just thought it was job security for him.
The demo was amazing. The spindles were about 2 1/2" square and close to two feet long. Had several vases and some coves and beads. He did them with a skew chisel. Had a little storey stick with a few tick marks to denote the high and low points and two or three calipers. When he was in the groove he could mount the piece turn it and touch it here and there with some sandpaper and take it off in 7 minutes. We should all aspire to be that good with a skew. A joy to watch.
Don't know about AZ, but "high" air (I'm in Summit County, CO) is so dry they can't get horse crap to rot sufficiently to make good garden soil. So the poplar may not deteriorate like it would elsewhere.
I use bondo all the time to do outdoor repairs of window sills etc. It last like iron with no rust. If it is just a little tear out I would apply the bondo then sand it smooth. If it is a deeper tear out i would use two coats of it. Have fun
Thanks everyone. We are stuck with the poplar, and she has been warned about the life span. I will try to talk her out of the shellac, and I will try to take light cuts and avoid tear-out as much as possible. Mark, she came to us with the price. I know she can get ready-mades for much less, but she has a very particular shape in mind. Not that fancy, but it took took 5 drawings and 3 templates before she signed off on it. This has been/will be a learning experience.
BTW, what's your problem with a shellac sealer? Contrary to what I saw over on the turning board, dewaxed shellac is the most waterproof stuff you could apply. It doesn't weather well as a finish outdoors, but as a pre-paint sealer it will do fine. You can also soak the ends of the spindles in a 1 pound cut for a day to allow the poplar to soak it up. You'll have to give the ends time to dry (about a week) before applying another coating, but I'll bet it would control the moisture uptake of the end grain. Needs to be dewaxed product, however, like Zinnser SealCoat or mixed from flakes.
Don, I agree that poplar is going to give some tearout when lathing, but I also agree to use the bondo to fill in those tearouts. After you paint the balusters cover the entire baluster with SPAR VARNISH....like they use on nautical items on boats.
While old growth poplar heart wood lasts forever outside if painted, the poplar being sawed today (primarily sapwood) will not last outdoors, at least in TN climate. If water can wick into a joint the wood in the vicinity will soon disintegrate into soft mush. Would you like pictures of examples of this problem? I used poplar for outside trim and I have lots of examples of the problem described.
The customer mandated and supplied the poplar. The turning club does not have a choice.
I trust they've told her about the short-comings of the material, and I hope they've given her a written notice about it and that they cannot/will not warrant the material.
True, the lady's gonna be pissed in a few years if the spindles fall apart, but . . . .
I am a member of that club. And we did. But she had already bought it, being advised by one of the pricier wood vendors in the state. She had the need to save as much as she could, so to sell her something, he told her poplar would be just fine. Then she had it cut so it couldn't be returned. Sad how unethical or stupid some can be just to get a few bucks.
I think we have her convinced that before any more wood purchases, she contact one of us. Gave her my phone number and a hearty invitation to consult first.
Is always risky for those who don't know what they're doing. Your "client" is learning the hard way. I'd suggest that you try to convince her to use the poplar some place else in the house (like interior stair spindles) because, as you'll point out to her, she'll be replacing the outside turnings in a few years at this rate, and the cost of the replacement wood now will be a fraction of the cost to re-turn the spindles all over again with proper wood then.
She made a mistake, but she doesn't have to live with it.
Did that too, Mark. Her house is on the National Historic House list. She is under a deadline to get it ready for tour. We had a half dozen or more suggestions around this, but they fell on deaf ears.
Que sera.
Some members agreed to do this and the money is going in the club treasury. I have no time this year, so I am not a part of it. My plate is way full. I did give her my phone number and an invitation for consultation before she spends any more money on this thing. But, in the end, its her money.