Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

White cedar fence failure -

Posts

White cedar fence failure -

#1

White cedar fence failure -

Philip Berman

Hello everyone -

I have a white cedar picket fence, installed 12 years ago (professionally installed, professionally made, loose use of the word professional!)

Anyway, 12 years later, most of the buried posts have rotted away, as has some of the railings. Service people are coming today to examine, but i'm looking for some ammunition to use when they make up a story as to why the white cedar, with their 'special protective solid-color stain', failed so soon. Am I mistaken in believing that this thing should have lasted longer than 12 years? I'm in NJ, well-drained property, southern-sun location, no plants growing on the fence although some small azaleas in front of it. But even some of the pickets have rotted, and they're 5 feet off the ground.

thoughts? comments? I won't let them rebuild (this is a nationally-known manufacturer that does custom work)unless it's on their dime - this wouldn't be one of my most fun projects to tackle, but I KNOW I can do better, with better materials.

Thanks for your input.

Phil

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#2

Surprised

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You got 12 years out of it in the ground. Cedar takes up water like a sponge and turns to punk from the inside out. In the 80's and 90's Cedar was "sold" on its alleged durability. Many miles of cedar sided homes have been stripped and redone in vinyl or aluminum because they turned black and rotted.

Know several people with Cedar decks that wound up replacing them in less than 10 years due to water-rot at every joist. Cedar's great for insect-resistance, but it's anything but maintenance-free, and I'd never use it for ground contact.

You want a fence that lasts? Black locust is the champ.

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#3

Re: Surprised

Philip Berman

hmmm, well that sucks. Thanks for your thoughts on this, and yes, I'm going to rebuild using black locust as you suggested, IF Walpole doesn't make good on this, which I doubt they will. Kind of unbelievable though - nearly $500 per foot for this thing, I expected better durability. We've got houses with 200-year-old fences still in fine shape - what do you suppose they used?

What part of NJ are you in? I'm 12 miles north of Morristown.

Thanks for your help Mark.

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#4

Re: Surprised

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Hunterdon

Old saying: "A black locust fence post will outlast 3 post holes."

Used to live down in Ocean County. Had a cedar fence running across the back of the property. Ground there is 100' of sand with a little topsoil overlay. Every fence post rotted off at ground level, even though you can't have better drainage.

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#5

Ric Taylor

Re: White cedar fence failure -

Ric Taylor

Are you sure it is cedar? Sometimes they sell you pine, and tell you it is cedar.

Here in southeast Texas, cedar fences are very common, and they typically last for about 15 years or so before being replaced. I don't often see the posts rotting, the fence usually just dies of old age. Normally the posts are pressure-treated, and the rest of it usually is left unfinished and turns a grey color.

Sometimes the original posts are kept in place when replacing the rest of the fence.

Ric

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#6

cedar experience

Bill Tindall

Miscellaneous information some of which could be relevant to your problem.

Cedar has a heartwood that is considerably more decay resistant than the sapwood. It could be that your material was cut from younger trees. It also could be that 12 years is the live expectancy of the posts.

In my youth in NYS we used cedar posts that came in from Canada for fences on the farm. I presume they had good life of we would not have used them. I think we would have been satisfied to get 15 years life from a post.

Here in TN the "post and rail" cedar fences installed a few years ago are not lasting. The posts rot off at the ground. I don't know what variety of cedar is in these fences. On my farm the sap wood from red cedar rots very quickly when used as a post. Some locust posts last 15 years , while others do not. I suspect it depends on growth rate of the tree, slow is better.

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#7

200 years?

Bill Tindall

There aren't any posts on any farm I ever owned or worked on that had a post that remained functional 1/4 that long. I just bought a place with about a 60 year old fence. The locust posts are visible but certainly not functional.

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#8

Re: White cedar fence failure -

Dick Coers

I read about the amount of sapwood affecting the life of cedar the other day. Another commment was made on that forum about 2nd and 3rd growth cedar not being nearly as dense and much quicker to rot than the old growth. Tough luck on your fence.

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#9

Re: White cedar fence failure -

Justin Szeliga

As was mentioned earlier cedar will rot pretty in contact with the ground. I was rebuilding a deck for a client who used #2 cedar 2x10's & 2x6 redwood for the deckboards. One joist was next to a groundhog hole & the soil from the hole was up against the joist. As I was walking across the joists I lost my balance & had to step on that joist & my foot when 7" into it. It was like a sponge, rotted & full of water. Cedar is rot resistant if allowed to dry out between rains.

Peace

Justin

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#10

ok, maybe I was exagerating a bit :-)

Philip Berman

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#11

Re: 200 years?

FredD

Around here it is not uncommon to see Black Locust and Osage Orange fence post that were put up prior to 1900.

About the only enemy they have is grass fires and it has to repeated at that.

Gordon Kuntz a long time friend of mine showed me his tepee stacks of Osage Orange posts that his grandfather had cut about a hundred years ago and he still repairs and puts up barbed wire , four strand fence around his pastures using that stock.

FredD

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#12

Duribility in-ground

John K Jordan

One of my books has a table with life expectancy of various species for in-ground use. I didn't have time yet to look it up, but this article on the web has an interesting comment which may explain some confusion about duribility:

http://warnell.forestry.uga.edu/service/library/index.php3?docID=326&docHistory[]=14

"Recent experience with redwood, Western redcedar, and baldcypress have indicated heartwood now available from these trees may not be so durable as that formerly used. Perhaps it's because of coming from younger trees. However, old growth, 'close-grained' redwood heartwood, used above ground, does have a reputation for resistance to termites.

Heartwood of the Southern pines which is saturated with natural resin, is very decay resistant too. It also has a reputation for termite resistance. However, little of this 'fat', or 'lightered', or 'heart pine' material is being cut any more. Old lumber salvaged from 'previous service', usually is too valuable for decorative purposes to be used for its durability."

The same article lists osage orange, black locust, and red mulberry as "Exceptionally high decay resistance."

JKJ

Re: White cedar fence failure -

#13

Re: Surprised

Jorge Casta�eda

Phil,

The white cedar is good for slats, but not for posts and rails, as Mark tells you the posts of black locusts outlast 3 holes. Also, white cedar does not like to be painted, that will make it rot faster, just leave it alone.

The old growth cedar , the one in the 200 year or more old houses is not the same as what we get now, that was probably grown around the time of the "mini ice age" when trees grew extremely slow and made wonderful wood, like the maple for the Stradivarius violins.

White oak and long leaf yellow pine are also long lived outdoors, so is mahogany, another maybe not as long lived as these, but long lived enough is hemlock. I bet there are others I don't know.

$0.03 adjusting for inflation

Jorge