Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Stopped Grooves, long

Posts

Stopped Grooves, long

#1

Stopped Grooves, long

Al

This is embarrassing, but I hope to learn a better technique and maybe prevent someone from making the same mistake I did. I need to find a safer way to cut double stopped grooves in cabinet door frames. I�ve been plunging the pieces into a dado bit and had one kick back on me last night. The dado blade sliced through the tips of three fingers. A few stitches fixed the fingers but it could have been much worse. I have cut many of these over the years without a problem by placing the end of the piece nearest me onto the saw table, plunging the far end down onto the blade, and then pushing the piece forward to the stopping point. I changed things a bit last night because saw dust was collecting under the piece during the plunge, causing parts of it to lift up over the dado blade as the piece was advanced. So I tried dropping the far end first, which let the sawdust clear before the entire piece was lowered. This seemed fine for about ten cuts and then the kickback hit. Years ago I cut stopped grooves with a router table, but somewhere I saw it done with the dado blade, tried it, and it felt more stable (safer) than the router. So I�m also uncomfortable going back to the router table. How do you safely cut these?

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

Dale Lenz

Very sorry to hear of your misshap, glad it's not worse. I done many stop dados with a router in a table. I don't take more than 3/32" cut max/pass, maybe less, 1/16". Having a router in the table might use an up-cut spiral big. Once you have plunged the wood use a shoe-style push stick. Practice on some soft wood until you build your confidences back up.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#3

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

David Hay Denver

Many years ago I tried making a long stopped dado in a board using the table saw and a dado blade. The saw threw the board at me for my trouble. Fortunately, all that was damaged were my nerves. I ended up finishing the cut with the router and guide fence. I would think doing stopped dados on the router table would be much safer.

David

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#4

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

FredD

Well Al , I am glad your hand survived.

Hope it wasn't your bowling hand.

If your talking about doing some kind of fluting on a face frame I always did that with a router and router mounted fence.

I did it many years before the Plunge router was invented, so I still do it this way, but the Plunge router would be easier for you to learn.

Clamp a stop at either end of the stile and , place the Router against one stop and rout toward the other , watching your progress so you will be ready to withdraw the bit before the wood burns.

Also I will do it in one pass , it's a relatively shallow cut that any router can handle with ease and doing it in one pass will prevent any slight misalignment that will happen with repetitious cuts and be really hard to disguise.

By using a router with a fence you can do both sides of the stile in the fluted area with perfect offsets before you move the fence to the next cut .

Also sometimes doing the face frame stile before the final assembly may work better , then not.

If this isn't what you was doing, there's no charge.

FredD

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#5

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

Al

Thanks for the input. I was cutting double stopped grooves in a frame for a panel to fit in. They are 3/8" deep. That's where I was having trouble with the router in the past. Working up to that depth the cut entry would change a bit and catch.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#6

Re: Stopped Grooves, long *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Al,

I hope you heal quickly and get back out into the shop very quickly.

A few years ago I was faced with a similar cut and I used an edge guide from

Porter Cable on my router to make the stopped grooves.

Below is a link to a review on that attachment from the articles section.

The guide will fit both fixed and plunge base routers.

Andy


http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=reviews&file=articles_209.shtml

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: Stopped Groovs on the table saw

Moses Yoder

You can make stopped grooves on the table saw safely. One option is to clamp an auxiliary fence to the saw fence and clamp a stop to it so the board cannot kick back. I have made many stopped cuts free hand, but the things to keep in mind are that your hand always needs to be in front of the blade not behind it; if your hand is behind the blade and the piece kicks out your fingers go into the blade as you found out. Also stand to the side of the board in case it does kick back, it will not hit you. I hope your fingers heal quickly.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#8

Re: Stopped Groovs on the table saw

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

If your blade height adjustment mechanism can be made to produce repeatable results, set the blade at table height, place the workpiece on the table, raise the blade into the workpiece, push the workpiece along the fence, lower the blade, remove workpiece.

Make sure the workpiece is secure when you raise the blade. I use my hand firmly pressing on it. Count turns of the height wheel to consistently raise and lower the blade the same distance.

I use this technique if the dado is wide and a lot of waste is being removed. For small cuts I use the plunge method with the cut made using the front of the blade.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#9

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

Barry Irby

Hope you heal quickly. I have been there and done that. Don't remember exactly what I was doing, but it had something to do with hardwood flooring and the dado blade. I was luckier than you and did not need stitches.

You have gotten good advice. If I were doing this, I would take a little more time with set up. I would clamp a piece to the fence long enough to have two stop blocks. One on each end. Then I would set up something to hold the pieces against the fence. Either another board parallel to the first, but lower or finger boards. Finger boards would be less likely to accumulate debris.

I like the idea of raising the blade into the work, but only if you can set it up to keep your fingers well out of the way. Drop the work piece into the slot, raise the blade, slide it forward until it hits the other stop, lower the blade, repeat. Raising the blade allows you to set the work piece in place firmly without having to drop it onto a spinning blade.

Same sort of set up would work on a router table and that might be my first choice. Set up the "slot" for the work piece and run them back and forth. You might need to make several passes, but with the slot left in place, you could run them all, raise the bit and run them again.

Have your dust collection ready. Shop Vac would be good and or a blower nozzle on your air compressor. It helps if you don't set the stops tight to the table and let the dust escape under them. Same for the other "rail" or the finger boards.

How many are you doing? Monotony is your enemy. I have a terrible time repeating an endless number of steps in the correct order. Its when you slip and raise the blade when you shouldn't that gets your fingers in trouble. Take the time with the setup to make it quick and safe.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#10

Hand tools

wilbur

This may not be a popular option on this part of Woodcentral, but a plow plane and a chisel would do the job quickly, easily, and safely.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#11

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

Sgian Dubh

Al, I have to admit that I find reading all the obviously unsafe, complicated and fiddly methods for making a table saw do what it's very poorly suited to doing, ie, stopped grooves, does make me wonder a bit.

The simple solution surely is to use a tool suited to the job as it's going to be less fiddly, safer and probably quicker. One obvious solution is one you were almost using, ie, a router. Instead of dropping a piece of wood into a spinning router bit (another questionable practice) simply use the router hand held and with a side fence; the job becomes very simple. If you feel the piece is too narrow to balance the router on securely, eg, 2" W X 1" T, just machine another piece of wood the same width and thickness and rest it on edge on the bench next to the piece you are grooving. If you are doing multiple parts that are the same dimension in section, you have plenty of parts to make yourself an impromptu or makeshift additional base support.

Another tool perfectly suited for this kind of cut is an overhead router, but not many amateur woodworkers possess one of these as most of them are three phase, have a lot of cast iron and weigh several hundred pounds.

Anyway, I hope you heal soon, but do consider retiring the table saw for operations it's really very poor at doing, as well as being unsafe. Slainte.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#12

I need a router Class......

Barry Irby

It seems to me that much of woodworking is about applying the wood to the tool or applying the tool to the wood. If you rip a piece on the table saw, you are applying the wood to the tool. If you rip the piece with a portable circular saw you are applying the tool to the the wood.

Setting up a router table with appropriate guides and stops seems to me to be a lot safer than using a router with a fence. Perhaps my problem is that I don't own a fence for my router and thus have no experience. I must need the fence because I have ruined a few things trying to route grooves in them using a homemade fence. If these pieces are door stiles and rails they are likely to be about two inches wide and 3/4" thick. So I have to arrange a way to clamp it on edge and make it flush with some sort of surface the route can rest on but leave enough space for the fence. And the stops. Then I have to clamp up the pieces and hoist that ten or fifteen pound router up there and position it and plunge it into the work accurately. Just seems more fiddly and dangerous (to the wood) than setting up the router table and doing it that way.

The Macgyver Gene kicked in and I tried to figure out how I could route the slots accurately and safely with the tools I have. I could do this on my router table before I could drive to Lowes and buy a router fence and Lowes is only about two miles away. OTOH, I doubt they have a router fence and Woodcraft is about an hour away.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#13

Re: I need a router Class......

Sgian Dubh

Barry, I'm somewhat flummoxed by your comments. Are you saying that you've lost the fence from your router? I can't think of any routers big enough to rout grooves in door stiles that are sold without a side fence, but maybe side fences are no longer sold as standard items with routers in the US, which is where I'm guessing you are from based on your mention of well known American retailers.

As for finding a surface on which to sit the piece(s) being grooved, a workbench with dogs works well, although there are alternative arrangements that can be set up easily.

It does sound like you might benefit from training in elementary routing techniques... I also suspect your whole post might really have been jocularly written with your tongue firmly planted in your cheek. Slainte.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#14

Re: I need a router Class......

Barry Irby

Richard,

I am untrained as a woodworker. I started In high school shop and the first year was good, but that shop teacher left and the second one knew less than we did. That was forty five years ago. Since then I have acquired tools and taught myself to use them. Which is to say, I have invented my own approach and have learned from reading magazines, watching television like New Yankee Workshop and David Marks. I see now that it would have been worth while to invest more in direct training.

My "big" router is a Porter Cable plunge router that is about 2 1/2 hp. I also have a smaller Stanley router that is about forty years old and Two midsized Bosch routers I bought to go with a Dovetail jig that I leave set up for that. I realized that I do have a fence for the Stanley router, but the router stays in the router table, so the fence is put away. It is not a plunge router, it would not work well for routing slots in doors.

Other than that, none of them came with a fence. I can buy a fence for the Porter Cable router but if I recall it is something like $30 or maybe more. Without the training or even a video of the fence in use, I am left imagining what I would do with it. Its sometimes hard to tell which of the gizmos and gadgets will be useful and which will get relegated to a drawer and unused forever.

I also lack a nice bench. Perhaps with better training I would have come to love hand work and a nice bench. I have been to your site and admired your work. Wish I had the skill and especially wish I had the design skills. Once I see soemthign, I can figure out how to execute it. Just wish I could see them in my head.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#15

Thanks All

Al

I appreciate everyones comments and wishes for a speedy recovery. I'm actually healing much faster than I expected. Got back into the shop tonight and tried a couple different setups. One with a router in the table using a slot cutting bit with a stop block and the other with a straight bit and fence on a handheld plunge router. The slot cutting bit in the table felt more controllable than the hand-held router and could do the work in fewer passes, so I think that will be the approach for the next batch.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#16

Re: I need a router Class......

Sgian Dubh

Barry, perhaps your earlier post wasn't tongue in cheek which is what I half supected it was.

Using a hand held router with a side fence really is one of the most basic operations with the tool. I guess that about 60% or 70% of common hand held router opperations incorporate an adjustable side fence. I'm not sure of the names of books written on routing subjects readily available to you, but I do know Pat Warner is a well known American author on the subject. It might be useful to have a look at what he's written, and I believe he has quite extensive website devoted to router use.

I'm afraid I can't help you at all regarding a bench, but I've done a fair amount of woodworking on something as simple as a couple of saw horses, ha, ha! Slainte.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#17

Re: I need a router Class......

Barry Irby

Thanks, I will look into a book or two. I actually want to by the one by Carol Reed who posts here frequently.

I see my router as being top heavy and awkward. It SEEMS to me that it would be wobbly to use with a fence. This is the problem with working alone and making it up as you go. Perhaps working with a router with a fence would become second nature and prove to be useful and a stable application of the tool, but It SEEMS it would be unsteady and wobbly. I imagine the bit waving around like a dog's tail while I try to steady the router on the narrow edges of the stock and keep the bit from wandering around and causing the fence to skew away from the face of the stock leaving a crooked slot.

I'm still trying to figure out why they lopped on side of the base off.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#18

Re: I need a router Class......

Sgian Dubh

"I'm still trying to figure out why they lopped on side of the base off."

Barry, you've lost me on that. Perhaps I missed or forgot something you said elsewhere?

"Perhaps working with a router with a fence would become second nature and prove to be useful and a stable application of the tool... "

I think you'll find with a bit of practice the tool is far more stable than you now expect. You are actually using two faces at a right angle to each other to bear against the piece being worked, ie, the router base and the side fence. This in itself provides a great deal of stability. The trickiest bit you'll find will be the beginning and end of the cut where the support provided by the base and fence are not properly engaged with the wood.

It's true that routing the edge of narrow material provides limited support for the base of the router, but this is where you can use extra pieces of the same sized material sitting on their edges behind the piece being worked, and this effectively makes the base much wider and therefore stable. However, do remember to do a normal cut with the router, ie, position the router with the fence between you and the work and move the tool left to right along the wood. This way the rotation of the cutter pulls the router fence tighter to the wood thus pretty much eliminating the chance of wavering grooves, rebates, mouldings, etc.

I'd forgotten about Carol Reed's books. I've not read any of her work, but I understand her books are well thought of. That certainly sounds like one place to start. Slainte.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#19

Re: I need a router Class......

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Barry,

Please excuse the crude drawings but I do not draw worth a darn .Hopefully the pics will begin to give an understanding of a couple methods I have used.

The first method uses a plunge router(this could be accomplished with a non-plunging router,as well) with a fence attached to the router base and the router above the work.

I like to join/clamp several stiles/rails together to provide a stable "platform" for the router base to help eliminate tipping.The router fence is set to center the bit into the stile/rail.Alot of time I like to use a 1/4" bit and sneak up on the width of my slot by making a couple passes.The P-C router fence makes this easy as it has a micro adjuster built in.


Also when using the smaller diameter bits I like to make a couple passes to obtain the depth instead of trying to hog it all out at once.

The second set up is done using a router table and a slot cutter.I happen to have an Amana slot cutter that has (4) 2 wing cutters and brass shims in case you really need to dial in a particular width of the slot.


I set the height of the bit to approximate center of my stile/rail and by plunging the front end into the cutter and then pushing til I have reached a stop/mark on fence,etc I then flip the board end for end and re rout the groove to center it on the stock,provided that is what the project calls for.This also allows me to cut the slot /set up the bit slightly narrower than what my finished slot is and by flipping make the slot to finished width while making a minimal cut/clean up pass.

Depending upon the length of your stock and/or router fence you can set stop blocks to limit the travel.many times with longer stock I just mark the leading and trailing edge of the router bit as well as the start/stop of the groove on my stock and rout until the lines meet.

Hopefully Ihave been clearer than a mudpuddle in a monsoon.

Andy

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#20

Re: I need a router Class......

Barry Irby

Richard,

I was babbling. I have a router that has the side cut off the base so that it is no longer round, it sort of D shaped. I know the argument about using the perimeter of a round router as a guide is that the bit may not be perfectly centered in the base. Thus, if you rotate the router the distance of the bit from the edge of the base will change and the cut will vary. I find that in use this is very practical and that you do not tend to spin the router while sliding it along a straightedge. Thus, even if the base is not concentric around the bit, it does not matter because you tend to reference off the same or nearly the same spot on the base. It you push the base against the straightedge and rotate the router clockwise and counter clockwise, the bit remains equidistant from the fence.

OTOH I see drawings with the flat side of the base against the fence. If you rotate that router clockwise or counterclockwise, the bit moves away from the fence and the groove will be crooked and not parallel to the straightedge. Considerably more difficult to keep the flat edge against the fence that the single point on circumference. I just have not found a good use for or reason why they made a flat side on the base.

I think the router is vaguely similar tot he lathe in that they are both simple tools with limitless possibilities. Its astounding what talent can produce with a lathe. The router is basically a motor that spins a cutter. But the versatility and productivity is amazing.

Re: Stopped Grooves, long

#21

Re: I need a router Class......

Sgian Dubh

"OTOH I see drawings with the flat side of the base against the fence. If you rotate that router clockwise or counterclockwise, the bit moves away from the fence and the groove will be crooked and not parallel to the straightedge."

Barry, I think you'll find that it becomes second nature to keep the straight edge of a router base tight against a straight edge you've set up to do such cuts as grooves or housings (dados).

Again though, you generally need to make sure you're not attempting a climb cut with this operation. You should cut as follows when using a router against a clamped down straight edge:

*If you are working with the router between yourself and the straight edge, push the base of the router firmly against the straight edge and move the router from left to right.

*If you are working with the straight edge between you and the router, do the opposite, ie, pull the router firmly towards you and against the straight edge and move the tool from right to left.

I imagine you already know this and it's all a bit granny, teach and sucking eggs, and if that's the case I do apologise. Slainte.