Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

Posts

Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#1

Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

Jennifer Indy.USA

Hi Gang,

I was bummed to find out that Rockler no longer makes its Wipe on poly gel that Michael Dresdner endorsed. I loved that stuff. It never looked like "plasticky" poly when cured. Wondering if anybody who used to use it has found an equal substitute?

Thanks for any info!

Jen

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#2

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

Bartstar

Jen,

Isn't Bartley's Gel Vanish similar. I think it was Bartley's that first produced a gel varnish, now copied by Minwax.

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#3

Not Only Similar

David Yoho

but I'm pretty sure the same stuff.

David

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#4

Been looking...

Tony - Memphis

I really liked the stuff too. I have ordered some Bartley's, but it seems to be out of stock everywhere. I ordered two cans a month ago or better and still haven't received it.

Tony

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#5

Thanks guys

Jennifer Indy.USA

I'll look for it at Rockler or Woodcraft. The name sounds familiar but I can't remember where I've seen it?

Jen

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#6

LRSmith

Supply chain hiccup ...

LRSmith

if the Bartley site is correct. No dates were given for the following post:

"GOOD NEWS!! Bartley recently received the following letter:

The Bankruptcy Court has recently approved an Asset Purchase Agreement for the sale of Lawrence McFadden's intangible and intellectual property to Seagrave Coatings Corporation of Carlstadt, New Jersey. At this time, LMC has transferred title and possession of its formulae, other intangible property and related finished goods to Seagrave in order to insure a timely and smooth transition of our operations and your orders. We are continuing the Bartley Gel Stain line and plan to be able to ship within 2 weeks, but we must check inventory first and then can give definite ship dates.

Seagrave is a long established technology driven manufacturer serving customers in aerospace, industrial, defense, maintenance, and home furnishings for over 150 years with an impeccable reputation in the coatings industry.

We are very excited to hear that the Bartley line of finishing products will continue. We also would like to thank our customers for their patience while we awaiting word on the line. We will be filling our back orders as soon as we receive our first shipment."

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#7

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Not Only Similar

Barb Siddiqui

What is the shelf life on these gel stains?

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#8

General Finishes

Jennifer Indy.USA

I picked up some General Finishes brand wipe on gel poly at Rockler today. I'll report back after I check it out. Thanks for the all the info on Bartly's. Tha manager at Rockler told me Rockler was working on a new line of finishes and he didn't know if it would include a gel poly.

Jen

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#9

Not Long

Jennifer Indy.USA

Barb, once they're open it's not nearly as long as regular poly. I always buy the smallest container now after tossing out several cans that went bad. I haven't ever used Bloxygen to try to make them last longer though.

Jen

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#10

Behlen

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi Jen,

Behlen makes one I like, just don't use too much at once.

j

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#11

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Not Long

Barb Siddiqui

Thanks Jennifer, I have some two years old and I haven't opened it all and inspected it yet. Probably time to throw it out!

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#12

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

Don Orr

I was going to recommend Lawrence-McFadden gel poly but from the above post it looks like they have sold their business to another outfit. I have had good luck with it in the past. It skins over in the can, but is usually OK underneath. It is very easy to apply-wipe on wipe off, fast drying. Too bad, I'm going to need more soon. I'll be watching for your report.

Oh and thanks Jorge, missed you at Totally Tuning last weekend.

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#13

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi Don,

I missed all of you guys,

I had to stay here and work, hopefully next year.

Jorge

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#14

The real lowdown

Michael Dresdner

Bartley and the Rockler gel were indeed both made by Lawrence McFadden, who declared bankruptcy late last year. Their remaining stock and formulas were purchased by Seagrave Coatings, a NJ company with a very long history. The owner of Seagrave, Peter Teppermann, assured me that he would be continuing all the major McFadden products, including the gel you asked about and the famed guitar lacquer McFadden was known for.

Yesterday I emailed Peter to ask when he'd be rolling out the gel and what name it would be under. He'll most likely get back to me on Monday. I'll fill you all in once I hear.

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#15

Re: The real lowdown

Don Orr

Thanks Micheal-so nice to have an "insider" and get the real story. This forum never ceases to amaze me !

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#16

Re: The real lowdown

Jennifer Indy.USA

Thanks Michael. Appreciate your input.

Jen

Re: Rockler wipe on gel substitute?

#17

Re: General Finishes

pecker

I actually like the GF version better than the Bartley/Rockler version.

Smells better, too.