Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

2 questions about Sawstop

Posts

2 questions about Sawstop

#1

2 questions about Sawstop

Thomas

I don't want this thread to turn into a war about lawsuits or anything, but I have a genuine interest in any opinions on the effect of this saw on other saw manufacturers.

Specifically, is there any possibility that the flesh-detecting technology will be available on other saws in the near future?

Also, is it possible to easily retrofit a Jet cabinet saw (about 11 years old) with a riving knife?

Thank you for any advice you can offer.

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#2

Alan Young

Well Sawstop competitors are already on the go---  *LINK*

Alan Young

I "saw" this link on David DeCristoforo's blog a few weeks back.

(http://blog.woodshopnews.com/tbaw/?p=155%22)

Check this link to Whirlwind

-Alan


Whirlwind

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#3

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Thomas,

Shortly after I had my accident [9 sutures, kept the thumb) I researched the retro-fit question. Answer was no. Reason was/is, in order to mount the brake, the saw needs to have a completely different elevator system.

Same answer for the riving knife that sits about 1/16" behind the blade with it's top about 1/4" lower than the blade. The true riving knife can't be removed and never has to be because it allows dado cuts. A riving knife must move up and down with the blade. If you open your saw and look at the arbor arm assembly, you'll see there's no point to mount the permanent knife.

Were it otherwise, I'd have both mounted on my JET in about 3 heartbeats. Now if you find out different, please let me know the whos, hows, and wheres.

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#4

Alan Young

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

Alan Young

Maybe we should file a class action suit against Saw Stop for not making their product retrofitable to other saws.

-Alan

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#5

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

FredD

I can't speak to what the other saw manufacturers are doing , but whatever it will turn out to be , is in the future.

I would say if you have reservations about using a saw without hurting yourself , by all means purchase a SawStop.

If one is to follow that line of logic, then of course you will need safety glasses, steel toed boots, a Kevlar vest, hard hat ,ear plugs, heavy leather gloves and locking switches on all of your power tools, not to mention a full face mask/ helmet with on board air if you put a coat of finish on your projects.

;-))

FredD

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#6

No Comment

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#7

I know it was meant as a joke

Neal in San Jose

But I do many of those things in my shop. I have safety glasses at work that I like so well that I bought another pair that I use in my shop. My steel toe safety shoes are so comfortable and have such good support (Red Wing) that I often wear them if I expect to spend much time standing. I have hearing protectors that have an FM radio built in, and I'm thinking of upgrading to one with a digital tuner (I keep bumping the knob and changing stations) that I wear pretty much all of the time I'm out there. I think the heavy leather gloves may be a mistake, tho. Bottom line is that being safer doesn't require being uncomfortable or inconvenienced.

Oh, yea, I have a Sawstop, too. I fired it back in December - posted about it at the time, but basically it saved my right index finger. My old Jet would have sawed it off without slowing down. That's the best money I ever spent out there.

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#8

Re: I know it was meant as a joke

FredD

I know you have a SawStop Neal and I am certainly glad you have all of your digits, but given that I find it impossible to protect people from theirselves regardless of how loaded up on safety apparel they own and use 100% of the time and that is really what we want, cradle to grave .

I also encourgage people who are nervous about using equipment to buy it all including SawStop.

I have most of what you have and I find it extremely uncomfortable to wear all day and so it gathers dust, but I do pay attention all of the time when I am in the shop, I think if I don't take care of myself , who will?

FredD

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#9

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

AZ, Colorado Springs

If the development of the "flesh detecting technology" was really just about safety, then it would not be patented and it would have been made available to the various manufacturers for free.

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#10

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

Jesse Cloud

As I recall, the Sawstop inventor originally tried to sell the technology to saw manufacturers, but there were no takers. If I were Sawstop, I would be feeling the waters to see if there might be a licensing market now. If I could license it, I would get out of the manufacturing business asap. Licensing would be pure profit with way less hassle than manufacturing. That would be a shame, though, because the sawstop is a first class saw, even without the safety technology.

As far a riving knives go, just about any recently designed saw will have a riving knife.

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#11

Wake up call

NORTH OF THE BORDER

Short of either gov't regulations or more court awards like this one (http://www.boston.com/business/articles/2010/03/06/man_wins_15m_in_first_of_its_kind_saw_case/ ), other saw makers will continue to argue the saw stop technology is too expensive for them and some consumers continue to belittle the call for such technology to be made mandatory. I see this lawsuit as a blessing in disguise, even though I don't quite agree with the jury's decision. I am sure today if cars without airbags were allowed, there'd still be car makers which would produce them and buyers who would take them.

Re: 2 questions about Sawstop

#12

Thank you...

Thomas

I agree 100% with you about the lawsuit. I'm sitting here with 4 mangled fingers, trying to decide between giving up a hobby I enjoy and spending what I'm guessing will be about $3500 on a saw to replace a perfectly good Jet cabinet saw.

If I thought this technology would be more available in the near future, it would aid in my decision. That is why I posted this question. I asked my son last night if he thought he might be interested in woodworking in the future (thinking if I'd pass on the saw it might be easier to rationalize the price). That would help me decide too.

I know my stupidity caused my accident. I also know I'm not perfect, and may be stupid again, if I can bring myself to continue. I don't understand the logic that since you can't use all safety devices, you shouldn't use any. I have to say, it's not really funny to me right now either. Using that logic on the other end means things like push sticks, splitters, blade guards etc. are unnecessary. Some of the features of the Sawstop are standard now (and aren't even possible on my saw). I believe all will be at some point. In any case, it's my decision what to use and what not to. I'm just hoping for some possible scenarios in the near future that might impact my decision.