Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

pin oak

Posts

pin oak

#1

pin oak

rw kates

2 large pin oak trees came down in my friends yard in northern NJ. trunks straight for 30 ft and avg 28" in diameter. can anyone tell me if these trees produce an interesting usable lumber. wondering if it is worth having the trees milled. thx

Re: pin oak

#2

Google is your friend *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I got 215,000 hits from Google - of course, not all of them will be relevant. Still, it should give you a beginning. "Pin Oak lumber" was a more refined search than just "pin oak," which gave me elementary school websites and so on.

Wikipedia doesn't like it much for furniture, but with all those knots, it sounds like it could be interesting.


Wikipedia words

Re: pin oak

#3

Re: pin oak

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

No more interesting really than its cousins red and white. Similar in most respects. Quarter sawn is always nice if possible. If you have a sawyer and the price is right then they might yield a nice stack of lumber worth pursuing.

T.

Re: pin oak

#4

Huge Diff

Ron

Red and white, similar...not in my books, ever try to work red, stringy and spliters, kinda nothing like white, which works amazinly well and finished so much nicer, never mind the density...white is my favorite.... try working some, you'll see...

Ron B

Re: pin oak

#5

Dale Lenz

All Pin Oaks...

Dale Lenz

are in the red oak group, that is their lumber if put in the market place will be sold as red oak lumber. One thing to be concerned about is the yard tree part. Many yard trees contain hidden metal treasures that the sawmills hate to find. If they do find metal might be out some extra $ for blade repair. Band saw blades for the portable mill used to be about $30, it's a gamble, your call. Some folks will cut the first 6' or so off the butt cut and cull it, if they suspect metal. Hint: When you buck the logs to length, looks for blue-black stain in the oak wood, a sign of iron in the log.

Interesting side note: When I worked in SE OK, the piney woods, folks call water and willow oaks pin oak. Moved to the NE part and folks call chinkapin oaks pin oak. Know your trees, : � >.

Re: pin oak

#6

Re: pin oak

Grant in Iowa

First question is are they worth the effort? in my mind, yes, but you should consider the following:

1. Talk to the land owner first to find out if they are available. Tell the owner that the value of logs in a small quantity is negligable (the truth). Offer to remove them at no charge. Don't commit yet if you can avoid it (unless you can use some firewood). Find out if they'd be willing to allow you to saw the lumber on site. If they are open to the idea, ask them to give you a day or so to make arrangements before they saw them into firewood.

measure the logs while you are talking to the neighbor. Visit http://www.woodweb.com/Resources/RSCalculators.html to find out how much lumber they'll likely yield.. use doyle and add about 5-10% since you'll be using a band mill.

2. Call local sawyers with a mobile mill. Call Woodmizer (they have a list of owners and points of contact in your area). Find one that will work with yard trees and find out the terms (should be somewhere between 25 and 40 cents per board foot).

3. Do the math and make a business case for yourself. Consider:

-need to move or handle the logs

-need to buy or make stickers to dry the lumber

-need to "put" it somewhere

-need to pay for kiln drying, if desired (not entirely necessary, IMHO)

-time and effort and tools to complete the job (chainsaw, log handlers, etc)

-there are items to consider, but these are the major ones

-The cost of similar lumber in your area

-The usefulness of it to you

-A place to keep it once it is air or kiln dried

-The wife acceptance factor(always on my list)

-Tools to process rough sawn lumber (large jointer for face jointing, planer, etc.)

4. decide and move on your decision.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa<---works almost exclusively with lumber like this

Re: pin oak

#7

Of course

Bill Tindall

All the oaks make good lumber. No mattter what it starts out being, once it crosses the saw it is either "White Oak" or "Red Oak" lumber with no differentiation made as to the details of the species.

Re: pin oak

#8

Moses Yoder

Re: Pin Oak

Moses Yoder

In my opinion if a lumber retailer sells pin oak as "red oak" they are ripping off the customer. This is done frequently in spite of my opinion. Pin oak has hundreds of tiny knots and is a very interesting wood but is not red oak.

Re: pin oak

#9

Re: pin oak

John K Jordan

The wood is certainly worth having.

Is it worth the trouble or cost? Maybe. 28" is on the upper end of what a small bandsaw mill can handle. My Woodmizer has a limit of 28" but it is a real chore to cut a log that big.

If you have to move the log to the sawmill, it can be a bigger chore unless you have the right equipment. A 28" pin oak log 10' long will weigh almost 3000 lbs. The best thing is to hire someone with a portable mill to come to the site. If you find someone with a swing mill (Lucas, etc) they can set up over the log and cut it where it lays. There are limitations on the width of boards but wide oak boards can be a challenge to dry anyway without warping. Most mills charge by the board foot. One thing - I can haul my trailer to a large local sawmill and BUY green oak boards for about the same as the portable mill guys would charge to do it on site.

As someone mentioned, some sawmills will NOT cut logs if they know they came from a yard. If they run into steel or ceramic insulators or something they will charge you for a new blade. Mine are about $30 each. I once found pieces of a broken file in a log.

If the site is someone's yard it might be a real mess when all is done. Besides the ruts in the yard there will be a lot of slabs and sawdust to clean up.

After milling, you need to air dry or kiln dry. If air drying, you need to properly prepare a place for the stack, make stickers, and keep the rain and sun off until it's dry.

I saw oak all the time and certainly would cut up a pin oak if I had one. (I use most of mine for things like barn siding.) There are small mill owners like me who will mill for free in exchange for part of the wood. The deal is typically 1/2 the lumber if you haul the logs to the mill and help with the sawing.

Another thing you can do with the logs (other than firewood) is sell them to a large sawmill. But don't expect much. I took three 14' red oak logs once and got $65 - hardly worth the trouble of loading and hauling. I got my own sawmill shortly afterwards!

JKJ

Re: pin oak

#10

clarification of grade and species

Bill Tindall

Whether something is sold as red or white oak has nothing to do with defects and everything to do with how the lumber looks. So, if it comes off the saw looking like red oak it is sold as red oak and you will not be able to tell the difference among scarlet, northern red, southern red, etc.

As an example hickory lumber looks like pecan so once it is sawed hickory logs become pecan lumber, when there is a market for it.

If the lumber has defects such as knots then it will be graded accordingly. Hence, a pin oak board that is loaded with knots will be sold as pallet lumber or rail ties and that lumber is typically not sold by species but only grade.

Personally, I have never seen a pin oak sawed but I am confident that the lumber will look like red or white oak and be sold accordingly.

Re: pin oak

#11

Red works just fine

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mountain

Never had a problem with it. No splits, no splinters, planes well, sands easily, stains without blotching, finishes very nicely.

Clint

Re: pin oak

#12

Re: pin oak

rw kates

thanks guys. this is all very helpful. logs are free. only cost is milling. looks like I might take a shot. If anyone wants some pin oak cheap, send me a note. i am near Bethlehem, PA.

Re: pin oak

#13

Wood Genre

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I did not read the original question as one about specific workability issues but more as appearance questions. In that regard I would say that pin oak is generally of the same appearance genre as the other common oaks. I say that in general terms knowing there are some color differences and grain differences throughout the order of quercus.

In general a pin oak will yield a very useful wood that will be similar to its cousins. One can always hope that any tree will yield an uncharacteristic prize of uncommon figure.

T.

Re: pin oak

#14

disagree

Bill Tindall

Until the recent popularity of quartered oak stuff, red oak always carried a premium to white when selling to furniture factories. They found the red easier to work and match in glued up panels.

There is a huge difference in working properties of either oak species, depending on growth rate. The fast growing trees produce very dense heavy lumber, while the very slow growing trees produce light weight lumber that works as easily as poplar and is nearly as light weight. Slow growth oak can be readily nailed, for example.

Re: pin oak

#15

Re: clarification of grade and species

John K Jordan

Wood varies widely in color. The biggest practical difference between red and white oak is the absence or presence of tyloses in the pores. White oak pores have numerous tyloses, blocking liquid movement. Red oak has no or few tyloses and the pores are like soda straws. Tyloses are easily visible using a hand lens or low power microscope. On a transverse section they look like sparkling membranes in the pores.

Tyloses make white oak more useful for some things like barrels and ships and outdoor furniture.

JKJ

Re: pin oak

#16

Hmmm...

Grant in Iowa

Bill, you are always a bounty of information here and I respect your input and experience. I am pondering your response and it seems to challenge my understanding of the order of oak things. Perhaps the cause is that we live in different regions and likely work different species and therefore have different experiences with the oaks we are familiar with.

Red and White oak are not species of oak. They are varieties, or groups of species. Red and white oak varieties differ primarily in leaf shape, pore size and leaf color. We all live in different areas of the country, and therefore likely have dealt with entirely different species of red and white oak. I think it is also fair to say that trees often have regional names that conflict with the true species identity to science.

It has further been my experience with the oaks in Iowa (not sure what species) with close grain can be nearly impossible to nail. I have experience with fast growth (widely spaced rings) being easier to nail than closely spaced ringed wood from the same stack of lumber. As a result, I had thought that close grain oak was generally harder than quickly grown widely spaced grown oaks of the same species. Your experience suggests otherwise, and I am intrigued. Perhaps our varying experience is a result of different species.

I'd like to hear more from you and others about their experience with close grain versus wide grain oaks and hardness. I know when selecting wood for furniture, I prefer tightly grained boards for parts requiring strength. As it relates to furniture making, is strength synomous with hardness and close grain? Not sure now... thoughts?

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: pin oak

#17

Ellis Walentine

Re: Hmmm... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Actually, there are over 400 species of oak in the world, 56 or more here in PA, and they are distinct species. Varieties are subsets of species. "Red" and "White" are groupings for commercial purposes based on similarities. White oak, though, is also a distinct species Quercus alba and Northern red oak is another distinct species, Quercus rubra.

Regarding working properties, appearance, nailing, etc., I agree that species, soil conditions and growing conditions can greatly affect these things. Personally, I find it difficult to match grain of any of the oaks if the boards are flatsawn because of the variability of the grain patterns depending on the size and straightness of the tree and how it was milled. That's a pet peeve of mine about commercial oak cabinetry: the jangled visual effect of poorly matched grain. Quartered and rift-sawn oak are much easier to match up.

Ellis


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Quercus_species

Re: pin oak

#18

hard and soft texture

Bill Tindall

Don't get excited about my careless use of taxonomy terms-species, variety, etc., a botanist I am not. I once called a steer a "cow" just to annoy my company (I grew up on a farm) and the gentleman farmer almost had a melt down as he delivered a hyperventilated explanation of the difference.

I am flummoxed that your experience with growth rate and texture is contrary to my experience. Your oaks are the same as here in TN except we have more varieties native to our forests. I lived in southern MN for a few years so I have some acquaintance with oak from that area (primarily "northern red", having worked lovely soft textured "red" when I lived there. Maybe some wiser soul can rationalize the difference in experience.

The oaks put on a burst of growth in the spring (spring wood which is dense) followed by late wood which is porous and provides the open pores distinctive to the oaks. The ratio of porous late wood to dense spring wood depends on growth rate. A fast growing oak in this area will have up to 3/8" inch rings of dense spring wood followed by the porous ring. Slow growth oak will have a just perceptible ring of dense spring wood followed by the porous ring.

It seems clear that lumber from a slow growth oak with a large fraction of porous wood will be lighter and "softer" than fast growth lumber where the wood is mostly dense spring wood. I have seen fast growth white oak so dense that a nail from a flooring nailer would not readily penetrate it. Slow growth oak can be easily nailed as seen in the PIC where a finishing nail was easily driven into the white oak piece. In this case the nail is largely penetrating the porous growth structure

The veneer buyers speak of "soft" and "hard " texture oak, soft being slow growth oak with closely spaced rings (which is soft). I prefer the soft textured (slow growth) lumber more common from northern climates, but also available here in more limited supply. It is easier to work (softer and lighter) and looks better, I think. I have a bit of red oak from NY state that has 1/16" growth rings and it is as easy to work as poplar. I have some white oak with less than 1/16" growth rings and it is as light as poplar. The close spaced rings lead to a less "bold" grain pattern in flat sawed lumber and a plain but not unattractive pattern in rift cut. I have some oak with 3/8" growth rings harder than the hubs of hell. A drill burns whilst drilling it, an essential task to allow entry of screw or nail.

Re: pin oak

#19

oak and color

Bill Tindall

Especially with the red oaks, put various boards out in the sun for a few minutes and they all look the same. The pronounced red seen in some lumber is fleeting in sun light. Of course the sap wood remains white and dark mineral stains are forever.

The white oaks tend to have more permanent color variation, maybe because the varieties of oak that get graded in to the white oak catagory (chestnut oak for example) can have more permanant differences in color.

Re: pin oak

#20

My head nearly exploded....

Barry Irby

Had to wrap it with duct tape. Had to read and reread your explanation. Seems exactly counter-intuitive. Thanks. I think.

Got to go back and read it again.

One of the things that distinguishes the red from white is that red has open pores (?) and white has them filled in and closed. Is it pores or tyloses (sp?)? Not sure this is a 100% true but you can take a piece of red oat several inches (feet?) long and blow air through it end to end and blow bubbles in water. You can't with white oak. Roy Underhill demonstrated that on his show. I have used it to distinguish one for the other in flooring when making a patch. Most of the T&G flooring I have dealt with had red ink markings on the back of red oak and black ink on white oak. I guess they did not have any white ink.

Is it that rounded leaves produce red oak? Pointed leaves are wihte oak?

Re: pin oak

#21

relief for exploded heads

Bill Tindall

I need to improve my writing skills. Can't risk loosing WC participants from head explosions.

It is vastly easier to drive a nail into Styrofoam (porous late wood that predominates slow growth lumber) than polycarbonate (dense spring wood that predominates with fast growth). Slow growth has a lot of air and fast growth doesn't.

Re: pin oak

#22

Re: My head nearly exploded....

John K Jordan

>...Is it that rounded leaves produce red oak? Pointed leaves are wihte oak?

Leaves of the white oaks have rounded lobes. The red oaks have pointed lobes.

JKJ

Re: pin oak

#23

Dale Lenz

Respectfully, Bill

Dale Lenz

My knowledge of the question of Northern grown oak vs. Southern grown oak is the reverse of yours. Southern oak with longer growing seasons puts most of its wood growth in the summer wood, late wood. Look at your example, the left wood has about a 1/3 spring wood, the lighter colored wood with the larger pores in them vs. 2/3 summer wood, late wood. Late wood to my knowledge is always more dense. The higher volume ratio of summer wood makes southern grown oak denser, heavier. On the plus side for Northern red oaks, the ratio of summer wood to early wood in Northern grow oaks are closer to 1:1 and tends to be more stable than Southern grown oaks, generally speaking.

I think back to sanding oak or SYP using a vibrating sander with a soft pad. I get ridges and valleys, ridges are the summer wood and valleys the spring wood. Spring wood is less dense and gets sanded away quicker, can be a desirable affect, depends on what your outcome wants to be.

Regards

Re: pin oak

#24

Re: My head nearly exploded....

Gene DiNardo

The leaves of the RED Oak are Pointy like the RED Mans ARROW

The leaves of the WHITE Oak are Round like the WHITE Mans Bullet.

Re: pin oak

#25

What was I thinking!  Spring doesn't follow summer

Bill Tindall

I have returned from a camping trip refreshed. Spring is here and my sap is up, and apparently mind is working better. too Upon reviewing what all the fuss was about I see that I got the tree growing in reverse. In my above discussion I have spring wood (early wood ) and summer wood (late wood reversed). The porous layer of the oak ring is made in the spring, as has been pointed out, more diplomatically than called for considering the error.

Never-the-less, the conclusion is correct. If an oak grows very slowly it will have a larger fraction of porous wood and hence be lighter and softer than a fast growing oak where the volume of dense late wood predominates. Prettier too, in my mind.