Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

Posts

OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#1

OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

Doug Ring

I would like to replace my downstairs windows (seven in total), and have quotes from three local companies for exactly the same windows (Milgard Ultra, laminated glass). This is my first "large project" handled by a contractor, so my question is, how likely are they to negotiate on pricing? Specifically, I was going to take the lowest quote, subtract 10%, and then present the offer to all three. If they all say "no", then just stick with the original quotes.

Thanks,

Doug in San Diego

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#2

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

davhamm

If all you care about is price... Sure give it a try... worst case they all say no.. you call the lower bidder and he says no to busy don't want to play games with you and you have to find someone else.

Personally I would look at a lot of factors and If I feel the price difference justifies the other features I like thats who I go with.

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#3

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - BEWARE!

Dave (PacNW)

Before you chose a contractor, get a exact Quote with an entire description of what they will do! I had 2 bids to replace 8 windows. Both bids were over $6500.00. I replaced them my self with top line Milgard windows for $1100.00 but that included replacing the Patio slider with new steel french doors. This was not on the bids . My neighbor, identical house, had his replaced last summer (8 windows only) for $5995.00. They came in and cut out the old window, cut the tabs off the replacements and glued them in with Caulk!! They were in and out in 3 1/2 hours. Make sure your contractor will do the job right and get a written guarantee Don't worry about the small difference you save by going with the cheapest bid!

Also, get at least 5 references

Dave (PacNW)

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#4

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

So you want to pay 10% less than the guy who planned to do the job with the least effort and time invested, as evidenced by his bid cost?

Remember that a badly done window replacement will cost you more than the bid cost, because a leaking window installation can lead to rotten walls and floors.

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#5

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

Barry Irby

I searched Milgard Ultra with Google. Certainly did not look good. May be disgruntled former employees, but there was a lot more negative info than glowing responses.

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#6

Why hire it done

Bill Tindall

My brother, a contractor, LOVES replacement window jobs because he makes so much money per hour doing them. I did 13 in my daughters house in just part of a day. Typically they are very easy to do. Preplaning and accurate measure will ensure success and save a pile of $$.

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#7

Counter-Offers to Quotes?

Tom Dunlap

I ran a tree care company for 25 years. During that time I learned to be a better salesman as well as a better arborist. One sales lesson that I learned was never to change the price without changing the job.

If I lowered my price the customer would know that I was overcharging and had 'lied' to them in the first place. Getting in a downward cycle like this never ended well. When I talked with clients I let them know that they were getting more than just a labor, ropes and chainsaws. They were hiring skilled, educated arborists.

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#8

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

Mark Nowicki

The worst thing would be agreeing to the 10% right away and asking for an immediate commitment.

I do that sometimes (when I don't want them as my customers). Nine times out of ten the HO will not commit, because they regret not asking for 15%.

Mark

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#9

My thought exactly.....

Barry Irby

I wondered why you would hire this done. I have done two houses, one where we installed the Lowes/Pella vinyl windows into the existing frames of the old DH windows, and the other where I put DH windows into the the frames of old aluminum awning windows. I even put in a sill liner they did not demand. It was Really simple and I did most of it by myself. If it takes an hour a window, you are wasting time.

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#10

Guess it depends

davhamm

It does depend on what type of windows your putting in. I replaced all mine with casement windows. I had to enlarge some openings and shrink others, of course this then caused trim work both inside and out.. took much more than an hour a window.

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#11

Re: Guess it depends

Barry Irby

Clearly that's true. Inserting and exact replacement window into an existing frame is completely different that changing the size and style of window. The skill set to do it would be entirely different. And so would the cost of having the "Pros" do it.

Part of me is making the assumption that someone posting here on Wood Central would have some woodworking skills and enough sense to sort out whether this is a job the want to do themselves or one they would rather pay for. Doing exact replacements is easier than it appears at first glance, the others, not so much. Everyone who posts on Wood Central is taller and better looking than average and smarter too.

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

#12

Re: OT - Rep. Windows - Counter-Offers to Quotes?

Doug Ring

Guys,

Thanks for all of the feedback - that is exactly what I wanted to hear. Here in SoCal, houses made in the 80's/early 90's typically have aluminum framed horizontal-sliding windows, which is what I have. One complicating factor is that the window frames are covered/embedded in the outer stucco wall covering, so the norm is to leave the perimeter frame in-place and size the new window to fit; the gap is filled with foam, or shims where the screws are located. I'm very tempted to try one window myself, and then proceed from there.