Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

End drilling a post question...

Posts

End drilling a post question...

#1

End drilling a post question...

Barry Irby

A friend of mine is installing a railing at his stairs. His idea for mounting the posts is to drill a hole into the doubled joists and install a pipe vertically. (He provided blocking during framing to allow for this.) Then he wants to end drill the posts to slip over the pipe.

So he wants to drill about an 1 1/8" hole into the end of a post and needs it to be centered and straight and parallel to the faces of the post. He has several to do. He has a Shop Smith and a Drill Press.

So, the question is how would you do this? Particularly, what drill bits would you use?

Re: End drilling a post question...

#3

One with teef?

Barry Irby

Re: End drilling a post question...

#4

Little trick

John K Jordan

I've done this with a chuck on my radial arm saw, on the lathe, and by hand. Seems to me the roundness of the hole doesn't have to be too perfect for strength so a cheap spade bit may be fine. If drilling by hand having someone with a good eye at hand to help keep it straight is helpful.

I don't like forstner bits in end grain. They can get real hot, especially with deep holes. When I use them on the lathe (pepper mills, etc) I use carbide tipped bits and a little trick I came up with once: the entire time it is drilling I blow compressed air into the hole. This not only helps clear the chips but cuts WAY down on the heat.

JKJ

Re: End drilling a post question...

#5

Re: End drilling a post question...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Make a jig for the drill press to hold the piece vertical, then adjust the post with a 2-way level. Once set and the table locked, use a carefully sharpened long spade bit. He will have to use the table elevator to get the depth.

Kind of a strange way to do things. Is it that he wants the railing to be removable? While a drill press will do the posts, he's gonna have fun trying to drill the framing with matching holes that are plumb and square.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#6

Re: End drilling a post question...

John Lucas

Barry I did that exact thing roughly 25 years ago. Put the miter gauge on the shopsmith table to keep the wood aligned. Use the auxilliary table to help hold everything. Clamp the wood to the table and use the quill feed on the head to feed it into the work.

Then use a spade bit and blow compressed air into the hole to blow out the shavings. I did that initially to keep the bit cool but I don't think it accomplished that because it would get really hot. It did make the drilling go better.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Agree on the strange approach.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The best-set newel posts I've seen have always been notched to make contact with the framing below the tread or floor and then glued and lag- or through-bolted.

Jason

Re: End drilling a post question...

#8

Or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

putting the post, newel or otherwise, direct to the frame with ledger supports for the notched decking. Only time I drill post is to put in concealed wiring. Use a 5/8" installer's bit to easily drill a 30" hole.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#9

Re: Agree on the strange approach.

Barry Irby

I also agree this is a strange way to do this. I probably would have framed a socket into the framing and inserted the butt of the posts into it.

If I were going to do what he proposes I might end drill the posts but probably would rip then, route a hole with a core box bit or even just use dado blade and cut a square hole and glue the post back together. Then I would drill the hole in the floor slightly oversized and bed the pipe in epoxy after I got it nice and plumb.

I may be over thinking this, but the way I see it is that there is almost no chance you will get the pipe perfectly plumb in the floor and then get the hole in the post perfectly straight if you drill it. If it were a round post, you might be able to spin it so that the angles of the holes matched and it was nearly plumb, but with a square post its going to look like its leaning into the breeze.

He wanted to start by drilling a pilot hole with a really long 1/8" bit and then following that with a pig tail auger bit. My take on that is I am nearly sure the 1/8" bit would wander, following the grain.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#10

strange

Bill Tindall

Why would someone want to invent a new way to install newel posts. It would have been so easy to arrange the framing to bolt an extended post to the stair's framing. Or if that opportunity has passed there are other means that have stood the test of time.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#11

I agree.....

Barry Irby

OTOH, as a Home Inspector I see them everyday installed incorrectly. In fact, I can remember the last one I saw that was done "right".

Railings around here are generally "colonial". The top rail is about 2 5/8" wide and almost as thick. the makers of the rails sell all the parts. Curved pieces in any direction posts etc. They also sell connector systems to securely fasten all the parts together. I cannot remember Th last one I saw that used the fasteners. Most of them are toe nailed together with finishing nails. The installers seem baffled that they should be doing a better job.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#12

Re: End drilling a post question...

FredD

This being made harder then it needs to be.

If he wants butt connection from the post though the flooring tell him to turn a dowel on the end of the Post.

Newel posts are typically mounted against the end and centered on the stair stringer which should have a plumb cut thereby automatically insuring a true vertical post.

I have many times inserted a 3/8ths Lag bolt into the end of the post and cut off the head and held the post in position and hit the top of it with my hand thereby making a mark to drill a 3/8ths hold .

When the post is in position drill two holes thought the face and into the stringer end and then counter bore for a one inch plug which all stair companies carry and bolt it to the stringer plug the hole and your done.

Notching the Newel post is a half assed way of doing it , it weakens the post and most likely prevents the Balusters from being on the tread where they belong.

FredD

Re: End drilling a post question...

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

You're assuming...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...a skirted stair system. What about an over-the-post system with volutes on open treads? Mortising the tread and notching the post ends up being very strong, particularly if the joints are tight, glued and mechanically fastened. The shoulders at the bottom of the post don't have to be very deep, which leave plenty of meat below the tread.

Jason

Re: End drilling a post question...

#14

equally strange, Bill,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

my emails to you are bouncing.

Seven Corners Hardware - http://www.7corners.com/

let me know if your schedule allows for coffee time.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#15

Re: End drilling a post question...

chrispy0623

If I was to fit a newel post using this technique, I would make the whole thing a super loose fit (say 1/4 inch oversize hole) and use plenty of epoxy filled with something like microbaloons, colloidal silica etc ( a particularly strong and practical mix) available from Gougeon Bros, Bay City, Michigan (WEST System), being very careful to ensure that the post is plumb in every direction whilst the epoxy is setting. If you want the post to be removeable, coat the metal pole with a liberal coating of wax or similar before the epoxy. The beauty of this method is that the hole accuracy and exacting accuracies matter not a bit!!Good luck! Chrispy

Re: End drilling a post question...

#16

Re: End drilling a post question...

Barry Irby

I have discussed this exact idea with him. Thanks.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#17

Re: You're assuming...

FredD

I can't speak to stairs with skirts and volutes, new nomenclature to me, but.......

Wooden stairs most often are either housed treads and risers or notched stringers with treads exposed.

Either system installs a Newel post against the butt end of the Stringer.

Open end treads receive Balusters with a dowel on the lower end and inserted in a hole in the tread , usually two for each tread.

The upper end of the Baluster is cut to the slope of the stair and inserted into a rabbeted grove in the bottom of the hand rail and held in position with a filler cut to fit between the Balusters and glued into the groove.

This is traditional stair building and produces a strong stair and stiff handrail.

I have no idea what the poster is doing ,but it doesn't sound anything like stair building,

FredD

Re: End drilling a post question...

#18

What about hardware made for that? *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

How about LJ-3008 at the below link. It is what I used on my 4x4 oak posts and no problems.

I guess I am curious as to why to reinvent the wheel...

Grant in Iowa


stair hardware

Re: End drilling a post question...

#19

Why not use available hardware? *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

Newel post bolts are what are commonly used to accomplish a tight post to floor union. Not sure why that isn't an option here, as I am sure you know of this approach, Barry.

On the off chance that you somehow missed this bit of technology, I provide the following link, and recommend item LJ-3008 as a possible solution to your dilemma. Plugs are available in most common species of wood. If the railing needs to be removable for some reason, you can just tap the plug in place , so it can be removed with minimal rework.

Another option is to use a piece of all-thread to place the post in tension. Secure it to the joists with epoxy or a nut in hole design if access is available to the sides of the joists. Then built a boxed newel post with an integral block (maybe dado'd into the inside of the post) to tighten a nut against. No drilling long holes.

It seems to me also that a shopsmith is actually a decent tool to squarely drill into the end of stock, the only real issue being the use of the right type of bit.

I guess I am skeptical that a tight newel post can be achieved without some sort of vertical tension fastener to hold the post to the floor. I have used these on my stairs with surface mount 4x4 posts and no wiggle is evident after 3 years of use.

Grant in Iowa


LJ stair parts

Re: End drilling a post question...

#20

Re: Why not use available hardware?

Barry Irby

Grant, I agree. My friend lives in MI and I live in VA. He has been working on an addition to his house. He called and asked how to end drill the post and described what he was doing. He had invented this method out of the whole cloth and did not ask me how he should install a post or what hardware was available. This is his baby and is equally amazing to me as it is to you. Don't get me wrong, I have reinvented the wheel many times. My brain runs toward "how can I do this with what I have at hand" and not so much to "what can I buy that will solve this problem". The Internet is a fabulous resource and goes a long ways toward curing my problem. Also, Wood Central and all you guys here are an enormous help. The knowledge base here is an amazing resource. To be able to get input from dozens of people that have faced similar problems is astounding. Think of the fact that among us we have shopped at about every store and used about every kind of tool and product. There is somebody here that knows how to do most things and what things work. And as Importantly what not to do and what does not work. And we share. This is great. Thanks.

Re: End drilling a post question...

#21

Follow up

Barry Irby

Talked to my friend today. He drilled the posts with a spade bit a little over sized and bedded them with epoxy and is thrilled to death to have rock solid posts. Now he is reinventing how to attach the rails. I gave him web sites for the hardware, but he has a better Idea......