Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

New shop floor

Posts

New shop floor

#1

New shop floor

Hamish

At long last I am beginning to prepare the floor for my first real workshop and remove my tools from around the house. It is a room with a concrete floor built over a large water tank. At the moment I'm leveling the concrete floor with a skim of mortar and intend to lay a sheet of thick plastic over it to act as a damp course, then I want to lay 3cm thick interlocking extruded polystyrene sheets, the kind that are very dense, before covering them with plywood. I read on a recent thread that many had put down the ply on top of sleepers but I would like my floor to "float" on the insulation and not to be nailed down into the concrete, so as not to perforate the damp course.

My question is, where I live they don't seem to sell t&g ply, just normal stuff. Do you think 5/8" ply laid on top of the insulation would be sufficient and what would you do to keep the edges level, ie, not rising up, as it is not t&g?

Thanks, Hamish.

Re: New shop floor

#2

Clint Searl

Re: New shop floor

Clint Searl

A real lumber yard/building supply should have 3/4" T&G Advantech decking. It's dense, strong, stable, and won't curl up if it's floated over the plastic. Even Lowes has it around here.

Clint

Re: New shop floor

#3

Spain

Dustmaker Mike

I don't think it will work correctly. You will need a way to hold down the edges. Maybe you could rip some sleepers to the thickness of the foam insulation and place them ever 61 cm apart and cut the foam to fit inbetween them. I think this would work better.

Re: New shop floor

#4

You could tongue-and-groove it yourself *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

with a bit set and a router. Might be a lot of work, and it might be easier to spline it - get a grooving bit (see linky for one example*) and cut 1/4" plywood splines to fit. That way, you could keep the plywood full size, and have just one router setting to worry about.

*If, by the way, you decide on this approach and buy your router bit from a WC sponsor, remember to go there through the link at the WC marketplace - that way, Ellis gets credit that helps support this forum.


Lee Valley grooving bits

Re: New shop floor

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: New shop floor

Moses Yoder

I would not just lay ply over insulation and expect it to stay flat. This is the main reason for fastening the sleepers on the concrete and nailing down the floor, to keep it flat. Plywood we get around here is still pretty wet and moves around considerably unless it is a cabinet grade ply.

Re: New shop floor

#6

Float

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Hamish,

You can lay your sleepers on the plastic without fastening to the concrete, put your insulation between them, then screw your ply to the wood. I would, however, seal the concrete before topping it. This will largely reduce the amount of condensation you get under that plastic.

I do have to question what the insulation is doing for you? Do you have a temperature issue with the water below? I suspect you're over-engineering a bit. If you're trying to control humidity in the shop, you'll get better results if you ventilate the space under your floor and/or run a dehumidifier or two in the shop.

Re: New shop floor

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: New shop floor

Jack Guzman from Maine

Hamish,

When I did my shop floor,I put down 2" x4'x8'panels of foil backed roof insulation.I taped the seams. Then I laid pine strapping 1"x4"every 16"on center and screwed my plywood panels to the strapping.The strapping/plywood floor is one piece and it floats on the insulation. Stays nice and flat.---Jack

Re: New shop floor

#8

Re: New shop floor

Hamish

I have just got back in from our dress rehearsal, turned on the computer and what a lovely surprise to see all the replies to my post. Thanks guys for all your efforts, your suggestions are really appreciated.

Now to answer some of the points raised:

1). nailing the sleepers into the concrete floor. I see the advantage in doing so but as mentioned, the shop will be above a water tank and I don't want to perforate the thick plastic damp course sheet that I will be putting down.

2). Mark, I think sealing the concrete before putting a topping on it would be a good idea. I hadn't thought of that. Thanks.

3). I had thought about putting down sleepers the same thickness as the insulation and then screwing the ply onto them but first I would like to do a test to make sure the insulation does not give or sag under weight, and cause the floor to develop bumps as it rises over the sleepers. A way round that would be to use thicker ply, but apart from the added to the cost, it will also increase the weight, which I would prefer to keep to a minimum.

4). To make my own t&g ply seemed a lot of work and would require a special router bit, but your idea of making splines Bill, sounds feasible. I had even thought about ripping strips of ply and positioning them under the board edges for screwing down the board into them. They in turn would be let into slots that were routered into the insulation. I haven't tried it but think it could be very messy.

5). Mark you also asked why I wanted to insulate the floor. My reason is that over the winter I have been in my future workshop for over half an hour at one time and I found that the combination of the cold and damp, really made it uncomfortable, especially for my legs. Furthermore, when I renovated our bedroom on the ground floor, I followed the same procedure that I would like to do of putting down a plastic dc, then insulation on top, followed by a cement screed and finally a varnished t&g oak floor. I also insulated the walls at the same time. The result was a dry comfortable room. I would like to take the opportunity of including the insulation now rather than finding out that I should have done it much later on.

I will mull over all your suggestions in the coming days, do some tests and let you know what I decide. Thanks for all your input.

P.S. Do you think it would be all right to run a wire to the centre of the room for the table saw under the ply floor, in between the insulation, if I run it in a electrical tube, or would it be better to drop a cable down from the roof?

Re: New shop floor

#9

Re: New shop floor

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"strips of ply...would be let into slots that were routered into the insulation. I haven't tried it but think it could be very messy."

Oh, yes, messy. I've never routed polystyrene, but I did try power tools to cut the polyiso insulation (the kind with the foil on both faces), and there were tiny bits of plastic everywhere, and I've power-cut styrofoam with the same results. You'll think you got trapped in a plastic blizzard.

As to the electrical line: I see no reason why not. Use metal conduit of some kind - whether EMT or flex. EMT would be best, if you can handle the straight lines involved.

Be aware, though, that flush-mounted outlets are prone to filling with sawdust, which would not be good; you can get "tombstone" outlets that will work a little better, although you may have to go to a commercial electrical supply house for them. Also, you'll have committed yourself to where your tablesaw is for once and for all. For those two reasons, a drop from the ceiling might be superior.

Re: New shop floor

#10

Re: New shop floor

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Hamish,

Without a "sleeper system" to hold your plywood rigid, you're going to have corners popping up and gaps at joints. Full floating floor systems, like Pergo, all have engineered snap-together joints that effectively make the assembly a single piece; even using t&g ply without some fixing won't equate. With you putting heavy power tools in spots, that warping is likely to increase. I suspect you'll wind up clearing out the shop and redoing the floor before long.

Re: New shop floor

#11

Re: New shop floor

FredD

"With you putting heavy power tools in spots, that warping is likely to increase. I suspect you'll wind up clearing out the shop and redoing the floor before long."

Without a doubt , a heavy stationery machine will find it's own level .

FredD

Re: New shop floor

#12

Re: New shop floor

Barry Irby

I agree with all those suggesting the floor is unlikely to be satifatory unless you fasten it down.

Use the blue or pink Foam either 1" or 1 1/2" thick and match sleepers to it. If you use treated wood for the sleepers you should use dry pieces. The worst tendency about treated wood is it tends to warp. Screw the plywood or OSB down, but be careful not to drive the crews out the bottom and punch holes in your plastic vapor barrier.

I'm betting that if you don't screw the stuff down and seal the joints sawdust and other crud will work itself into the cracks and force them apart and get underneath, aggravating any bulges.

Re: New shop floor

#13

Re: New shop floor

Hamish

Thanks again gentlemen for your ideas, it looks like using sleepers will be the best way to go. I hadn't thought about the effect of the heavy machines settling down over time and of the possible warping and accumulating crud.

As regards the sleepers, I will check in the local wood stores what pressure treated wood they stock and their thickness. But I feel that in the long run, it might be better if I make my own ones to match the thickness of the insulation, round over their bottom edges, so as not to perforate the plastic, and then treat them with an anti beasty product.

At the moment, I am nearly 3/4 of the way through levelling the floor, and should finish it during the next few days. If you would like, I could try and post some photos of the progress.

Thanks again for all the suggestions, Hamish.